It's hard to complain about something when the art is Godly
The art is meaningless fluff. The story is far more important. Nobody would care about One Piece if it's story was on par with inuyasaha or bleach.
Maybe if some day I read the original version I'll say: "The redrawn version is better (in terms of storytelling)", because the redrawn version will be the first version I read.
From firsthand experience I can say: Naw. I read the redraw first then once I got to the end I picked up the original. Now I have the viewpoint of above. Seriously, the redraw is fairly crap and has fallen into the same kind of hole as the simpsons. The series used to be a tongue in cheek parody of the shounen genre, but now the redraw has just become a generic shounen. What was once a parody has become what it had parodied.
This constant redrawing is starting to get annoying. Is there any other manga that gets redrawn?
It's what happens when the guy redrawing it introduces a bunch of plotholes by taking the story too far away from the original plot. We're starting to get into Fullmetal Alchemist levels of divergent plotlines.