Foolio -
Well you made a full 180 on me. Just because I don't believe Huschel's claim, and therefore think the two of you are in cahoots? It's just a theory you know. You've been accusing several players of OMGUS but here you are now!
Do you believe Huschel's claim? You seem to be awfully nice to him and easily accept his answers. You've also given him almost no trouble since Day 1, besides casually mentioning he could be Mafia… You went after practically everyone else though. Why let him slip through the net like that?
What are you trying to do here - defend yourself and your claim, or find the Mafia? Why do you want people to believe your claim so badly?
About Galaxy 9000, I agree it's fishy that he's never voted. But a Pacifist is very unlikely at this point. He would have some recruits by now, and I think everyone left alive has voted at some point.
@Foolio:
I'm also still waiting to hear what your problem is with mass claiming.
Because I don't want the Mafia to have that information yet. I want to further interrogate my suspects about their claim before I make my own. I could catch them lying.
@Outerspec:
A few sentences later…
lol what? And in case you were wondering why I was telling people to be cautious after my vote it's because I noticed it looked like Shuhan was purposefully calling attention and votes to himself. I was right. Just for the wrong reason. I never could have imagined it was a Cop looking scummy intentionally so I thought he might have been a Fool (no pun intended). Yes, he was acting scummy as hell which is why I and everyone else voted him but I warned people about my worry when I cast my vote. Let's not shape it like I voted Shuhan and then skipped off into the sunset going la-di-da.
I meant that actual Townies could be excused for thinking Shuhan was scum - something several people have agreed with me on since then. But I also said Mafia must have been on Shu's wagon, and I definitely still believe that, so I can't exactly literally excuse everyone on his wagon, right?
And to be honest, your vote did kind of look like that. It's what Mafias do; casually mention suspicion against Townies and then cash in a vote when they can. That's what you did, but so did Huschel, Foolio, and SkullJoke.
Actually, this has made me realize something. I always assumed at least 2 Mafia were on Shuhan's wagon - possibly all 3. The only survivors of that wagon are Huschel, Foolio, and you. (and me). So that's another coin in the Fooschel jar.
Question to you, Outerspec, how many Mafia votes do you think were on Shuhan's wagon? What do you deduce from that?
@Outerspec:
Haha, nice try. But no. You and Foolio are adamantly (Yes Foolio, adamantly) trying here to paint me as the problem but your @Outerspec:
innocence is based off of what report, Iceburg??? You know what they say when you "assume"? It makes an 'ass' out of 'u' and 'me'. Town should not assume Wooden was a sane cop because he was being "friendly" to you. That's such a stretch I'm wondering
I'm not assuming I'm innocent; I know.
So yes, I know, Town can't just take over that theory. But to me it was viable and I was thinking out loud. And I abandoned the idea of Wooden having investigated me pretty soon anyway. But I'll say I did keep the option of an Insane Cop in mind. You being Godfather could still be possible too.
@Outerspec:
But let's not focus on you for a minute here. If you really were taking a look at Wooden's behaivor you would be concentrated on Galaxy because that's who Wooden really went after. If you want to assume Wooden was the sane cop why do you take this position on Galaxy? Relevant quote:
That's a good quote. No way Galaxy is Mafia. So let's say you're right. Wooden investigates Galaxy. He comes up as Mafia. If you're right that would mean Wooden is the "insane" cop. Which would make Shuhan the sane one. Which would make damn perfect sense because I'm Town!
I still don't think Galaxy is Mafia, based on that. He had better reasons than anyone to vote for Shuhan when the wagon was rolling, but he never did.
And I've been thinking about Wooden investigating Galaxy. Post #2915 (page 146) is very interesting in that regard. In it, Wooden takes a clear stand against Galaxy. He only makes one post after that before he sadly dies, still going against Galaxy. There are two options here: either Wooden got a guilty report on Galaxy, and tried to get him lynched without making it obvious that he was the Cop (believing he would live longer); or he investigated someone else, who came up innocent, and decided to pursue a different suspect. Both are equally likely, and I think if he really had a report on Mafia, he might have gone after him a little more relentlessly.
But I think we can conclude for almost certain that Wooden didn't get a guilty report on someone other than Galaxy. @Outerspec:
Funny enough that's a load of garbage. You quoted me here and I responded and the I mentioned you again but…you never responded back. So...what are you talking about, Iceburg? I was your #2 suspect all of yesterday? Ummm...sure.
That whole exchange was mostly a misunderstanding, and Shuhan replied to that with similar sentiments to mine, and I didn't want to address it any further because it seemed pointless to me. Now it wasn't so much the content that bothered me, but the fact that you made all those posts about it. You yourself called it fluff, but kept being hung up about it. I thought that was weird.
Firelord111 -
I did see all your votes on me and all those posts where you put me on the top of your list. But honestly, what is there to react to? You rarely asked me anything and you never made an actual case against me. I'm not gonna react to you just because I'm your suspect. All I can say is you're wrong to suspect me and you shouldn't let that tunnelvision on me guide you so much.
@firelord111:
@ice and huscel
where did i say i dont have role that you guys are pointing at ?
Didn't you have an exchange with Kitsune where he hinted at having a role and you said you didn't? Or was that someone else?
I'm out for now. Does anyone know how much time we have left? If necessary, we could extend the Day again. I'll make sure to be around this time.