I see, I see. Then Nami-Chan must have found a potion.
Curious that she’s wouldn’t want to clarify that for us!
Actually they were quite empty!
I didn't know I could not invent stuff on the spot, so that's my bad…
I see, I see. Then Nami-Chan must have found a potion.
Curious that she’s wouldn’t want to clarify that for us!
Actually they were quite empty!
I didn't know I could not invent stuff on the spot, so that's my bad…
Regarding the suspicious morning reads - I have a theory that it is more likely to occur if your Perception is high and the reported character has low Willpower.
Speaking of which, what do we do about for food? And I'm not interested in eating one of our own…
grumbles in my tummy
Actually they were quite empty!
I didn't know I could not invent stuff on the spot, so that's my bad…
Oho~~~! How inventive of you, young girl. Stop jokin’ around~~~!
But yes, no more playing pretend. As you can see, we are in very real danger here!
Oho~~~! How inventive of you, young girl. Stop jokin’ around~~~!
But yes, no more playing pretend. As you can see, we are in very real danger here!
Yes… I think it like how it might be in Alabasta... mirages, would make since since we haven't got anything to eat for a few days, plus bad sleep to top it off x.x
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
Argh, typo. I meant "it is like how it might be", forgot the is x.x
Then join me in some spinning! It is sure to clear your head right up and make you feel right as rain.
Un! Deux! Trois!!!
spin spin spin
Then join me in some spinning! It is sure to clear your head right up and make you feel right as rain.
Un! Deux! Trois!!!
spin spin spin
Um….. But you did give me an idea! Why not transform into someone that can carry us up this wall quicker? Hmmm, I'm sure you got some of those right? What you think?
Non, non, mon cheri.
I have refrained from using my unique devil fruit since we arrived in this forsaken place. And I dare not use it now, of all times.
Non, non, mon cheri.
I have refrained from using my unique devil fruit since we arrived in this forsaken place. And I dare not use it now, of all times.
Well, nevermind… hmmm hopefully Monet can fly us to the top and help us find a place to get some grub.
5: Monet, the Yuki-Onna
So far, no one has offered any corroboration that your night action was to follow Batman. There’s also no hard proof, yet, that your night action (whatever it was) failed. I like the way you think, Snowy girl, but I must say that you are quite high on my list of suspects for the Strawhat Sniper’s murder. If only by process of elimination. Let’s also note that she has been very vocal about not killing and also quick to point fingers at others, both of which I could see being done in an attempt to shift blame away from herself.
I did not follow Batman:
That is… unfortunate.
I also failed a follow action last night, and I suspected that you followed me but didn't trust me to corroborate you after I accused you.
I noticed you being suspicious when I woke up, so I felt I needed to confirm your innocence before corroborating you.
I think my follow action was successful though. Just the person I followed had wasted their time. But my action made me lose some stats because of exhaustion
Also, I might as well say, apparently I noticed Nami acting strange in the morning. I didn't do any action to trigger this information.
I thought you may had followed me, because I failed my attempt to follow Nami. I wasn't sure whether my attempt would have been described as walking in circles or not, and I woke up noticing that you seemed suspicious.
Everyone seems to be confused about my perspective on what happened, so I'll explain again:
Unfortunately, I was not the person he followed. So I do not have an alibi.
@SkullJoke You only noticed one person (Nami) being suspicious, right? Not Shuhan like Monet and Bon Clay?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Shuhan, of course, being Queen's epithet.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
Wait, let me recalibrate this.
Batman followed me, noticed Nami being suspicious
Monet failed to follow Nami, noticed Batman being suspicious
Bon Clay did something successfully, noticed Queen being suspicious
I, Hannyabal, failed to follow Monet. I also noticed Queen acting suspiciously, though I hadn't share that prior to this.
Nami did nothing and noticed nothing.
Queen is ???????
Here's everyone's accounts of last night so far:
Hannybal: Watched Monet, but failed. (Corroborated)
Batman: Followed Hannybal (Corroborated)
Nami: Did nothing (Unconfirmed)
Monet: Followed Nami, but failed (Unconfirmed)
Bon Clay: Unknown (Unconfirmed)
Queen: Unknown (Unconfirmed)
Batman followed me, noticed Nami being suspicious
Monet failed to follow Nami, noticed Batman being suspicious
Bon Clay did something successfully, noticed Queen being suspicious
I, Hannyabal, failed to follow Monet. I also noticed Queen acting suspiciously, though I hadn't share that prior to this.
Nami did nothing and noticed nothing.
Queen is ???????
Hmmm, looking at this all, is making me think Queen was the one who killed Ussop, as we have now two people acting him sus. Maybe it means something? Or maybe it is just flavor text… This is hard. Like I want to avenge Ussop's death, but I'm not sure who it is, though I'm leaning towards Queen since two people noticed him, so maybe that's a sign to lynch him?
I’d also like to point out that Hannya-boy’s claimed watch attempt contests his Perception versus Snowy-girl’s Stealth. If we assume that Hannya-boy attempted this because he knew his Perception skill was high, then we can also surmise that the most likely reason for his attempt to have failed is that Monet has a very high Stealth skill.
We also know that it is Stealth which is used to perform night kills…
I won't lie, stealth is tied for my second highest skill.
But I believe in trying to keep the killing in broad daylight. Murder puts me at unnecessary risk.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
A question for everyone: After reading through my list of suspects, what are your thoughts?
My suspects for the night kill are Queen, you, and Nami (In that order).
However, I don't really care who killed Usopp. It's useful to have some idea of who had alibis for the future, if someone develops a pattern of killing.
If you or Nami openly admitted to killing Usopp I would still vote off Queen today.
My mistake, Miss Harpy. I had forgotten who you claimed to follow. Your story makes much sense, and so you have slid lower on my suspect list.
I am now beginning to think that suspicious reads come from the following: A player tries a night action which uses their stealth skill. If their willpower is low enough, then another player with high perception will notice them being scummy.
What do the rest of you think?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Of course, logically, this would mean that Nami-chan is lying and did something stealthy last night.
Rereading the stat descriptions, I agree with you. "Acting scummy" is a very vague phrase and I could see it being associated with stealth actions.
Although if Batman noticed Nami being suspicious, it would mean she performed a stealth action.
Wait, where exactly did Bat-boy say that he saw Nami acting suspiciously?
Oh, you mean the person who claims to have seen and done nothing might be lying? Truly earthshaking stuff.
By the way, Bon Clay, would you mind revealing what you did last night?
Hannybal why did you say Batman saw Nami acting suspiciously? I can't find any posts by him stating that.
Nami, if you didn't do anything in the night, why do you think Buggy told me you were acting strange in the morning?
This is the post, similar to what I got on Queen. Batman mentioned he got a message about someone being suspicious odd/towards the beginning of the day too
Yeah, I was thinking that was maybe a reference to the original night action that I wanted to do, maybe it was put into action or something, even though it was useless. I don't know ><
Maybe we should clarify if we noticed someone acting strange or suspicious
I noticed Nami acting strange.
Fine, I come clean. I was trying to steal the gem that Monet had, but I failed. I lied because I didn't want to be found out; in case, I wanted to try it again when I gotten better stats down the road. But the first part I said was true, I did want to do that, but it was not part of the game mechanics, I just didn't mention the rest after it… But now that Hannybal has it, I was planning to steal it from him during the next phase.
Bleh, thanks Batman... now I lost the chance for a potential treasure spot, and it will have Hannybal on his guard now. X.X
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
*during the next night phase
Argh, typos lol xD
Fine, I come clean. I was trying to steal the gem that Monet had, but I failed. I lied because I didn't want to be found out; in case, I wanted to try it again when I gotten better stats down the road. But the first part I said was true, I did want to do that, but it was not part of the game mechanics, I just didn't mention the rest after it… But now that Hannybal has it, I was planning to steal it from him during the next phase.
Bleh, thanks Batman... now I lost the chance for a potential treasure spot, and it will have Hannybal on his guard now. X.X
Cat burglar! This explanation makes sense, but now I will need to be suspicious of everything you say in the future. Non… Non...
Oh, you mean the person who claims to have seen and done nothing might be lying? Truly earthshaking stuff.
By the way, Bon Clay, would you mind revealing what you did last night?
I will happily reveal what I did in great detail once we hear from everyone who remains. It is important that I not say anything until then, or until it becomes absolutely necessary (like closer to the end of the day).
glares at Queen
Cat burglar! This explanation makes sense, but now I will need to be suspicious of everything you say in the future. Non… Non...
Yeah, I'm sorry. ><
I will happily reveal what I did in great detail once we hear from everyone who remains. It is important that I not say anything until then, or until it becomes absolutely necessary (like closer to the end of the day).
glares at Queen
I'm just curious what you saw Queen do, hmmm. And since he hasn't replied, I'm really getting the sense that he is the one who killed Ussop.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Question to Buggy-chan, how much time is there left to the day before the night falls?
Yeah, I'm sorry. ><
Nami-chan. You say that you were unable to steal the gem from Miss Harpy last night. Is that because you were caught?
What I mean to say is; would Monet have known today that you attempted to steal from her last night?
Nami-chan. You say that you were unable to steal the gem from Miss Harpy last night. Is that because you were caught?
What I mean to say is; would Monet have known today that you attempted to steal from her last night?
I mean I was able to steal but I failed, but I was able to get away before Monet noticed anything.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Hence why I was keeping it a secret till Batman foiled my plans...
I can also confirm that I did not receive any indication she tried to steal from me.
I'm going to quote Hannya-boy, since he already started compiling this information earlier.
Wait, let me recalibrate this.
Batman followed me, noticed Nami being suspicious
This all checks out now, given Miss Nami's confession. We can surmise that Bat-boy's Stealth and Perception beat Hannya-boy's Perception and the Cat Burglar's Willpower, respectively.
Monet failed to follow Nami, noticed Batman being suspicious
Also checks out, given that Bat-boy tried to sneak behind Hannya-boy all night. Miss Harpy's Stealth lost to Nami-chan's Perception, but her Perception beat Bat-boy's Willpower.
Bon Clay did something successfully, noticed Queen being suspicious
I will explain in greater detail later, but you can assume that this is all true.
I, Hannyabal, failed to follow Monet. I also noticed Queen acting suspiciously, though I hadn't share that prior to this.
Poor Hannya-boy. Your Stealth lost to Miss Harpy's Perception. But I am glad to see that your Perception also picked up on the Calamity's scumminess.
Nami did nothing and noticed nothing.
A bald faced lie. But the Cat Burglar's later confession checks out.
Queen is ???????
And we arrive at the most disheartening mystery of them all. When will Queen say something…?! It makes me so angry!
So I must spin! Spin! I'm spinning~~~!
Maybe Queen ate by accident one of those medicines he was making, so he fell asleep on us all.
looks at Queen He does look motionless and staring into space. Hmmm.
I guess I'm gonna vote to lynch Queen at this point, looks like we have our culprit. You will pay for what you did to Ussop…
Vote Lynch: Queen [Shuhan]
Well then.
Vote Lynch: Queen
The day would've been about over by now had we not extended it. And 2 people have noticed his suspiciousness.. Whether inactive or a killer, or hopefully both, this should give us a bit of an easier climb
Also checks out, given that Bat-boy tried to sneak behind Hannya-boy all night. Miss Harpy's Stealth lost to Nami-chan's Perception, but her Perception beat Bat-boy's Willpower.
Following is actually a pure stealth role:
You can kill, which will be a battle between your stealth vs the targets athletics
You can follow someone, which will be roll of the dice on your stealth
You can try to watch, which will be a battle between your perception vs their stealth
Also quick question Hannybal:
I…uh...who would want to? I'm starting to rethink my decisions...
Well, I'll share now. I attempted to watch Monet last night but was unsuccessful. Got too distracted by the rumbling in my tummy, couldn't concentrate on the search. Sorry everyone!
Did you follow me or watch me? I don't think watching triggers suspicion because it uses perception.
Alright. With three votes on Queen, I must do this:
Unvote
I will explain more shortly.
Alright. With three votes on Queen, I must do this:
Unvote
I will explain more shortly.
Thank you. I was just about to ask someone to unvote.
I feel like there's still valuable information to discuss today.
Following is actually a pure stealth roll [sic]
Yes, I am aware. But detecting "scumminess" is purely Perception vs. Willpower. I believe that the "tells" are triggered by using Stealth night actions, though.
Did you follow me or watch me? I don't think watching triggers suspicion because it uses perception.
I can confirm that watching is purely a Perception vs. Stealth check.
Well then.
Vote Lynch: Queen
The day would've been about over by now had we not extended it. And 2 people have noticed his suspiciousness.. Whether inactive or a killer, or hopefully both, this should give us a bit of an easier climb
I need to refresh before posting! Didn't realize I was the third vote.
I'm still trying to figure out what the contest would be for stealing from someone. Presumably Stealth for the thief, but… what for the victim?
In the end, I'm left with the following suspects for Long Nose's murder, in order from most suspicious to least:
Everyone else is off my list for now. Something very fishy is going on here, and I'm just waiting to hear from Queen before I tell the rest of you what I know.
Those who noticed something about Queen, was he acting suspicious or strange? Same question for Monet about me. Just wondering if there's any difference in terms.
Monet. You're still on my list, mostly because we don't have any information to corroborate your story.
I understand. I just hope this doesn't interfere with our blossoming friendship.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Those who noticed something about Queen, was he acting suspicious or strange? Same question for Monet about me. Just wondering if there's any difference in terms.
After going back and checking my messages, it actually did say "strange" and not "suspicious."
Nami. As unthinkable as it is, I'm beginning to think that you could have murdered your own crewmate. We don't have any information to corroborate your story, so you are looking pretty suspicious.
I mean, I mentioned to Hannybal about sharing the treasure if the gem unlocks something, which I'm sure it might. It feels very valuable.
Here's my quote for quicker access:
@starlalilymoon:
Awww! That's fine! Hope you enjoy that gem! ^^
But if it opens a door to something with lots of treasure, you will share with me, yes? winks cutely at you
I did mention this way before I confessed to trying to steal. Yes… I really want that gem to get treasure >_>
I, Hannyabal, failed to follow Monet. I also noticed Queen acting suspiciously, though I hadn't share that prior to this.
Thank you, Snowy-girl, for pointing this out.
Yes, Hannya-boy. Please clarify: Did you try to watch Miss Harpy or follow her?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Those who noticed something about Queen, was he acting suspicious or strange? Same question for Monet about me. Just wondering if there's any difference in terms.
I'll go ahead and say that I did not get the same sort of "tell" on waking as the rest of you. My scum read on Queen was very different, which I will detail in due time.
Bleh, thanks Batman…
You're welcome. But you don't have to thank me. I protect this city cave for the sake of justice alone.
You're welcome. But you don't have to thank me. I protect this
citycave for the sake of justice alone.
Bat-boy… I like your style.
But you're going to ruin my makeup.
@SkullJoke You only noticed one person (Nami) being suspicious, right? Not Shuhan like Monet and Bon Clay?
Sorry Vice-Commissioner, I forgot to answer. Yes, I only noticed Nami.
But justice is blind, and so are bats.
Ugh, sorry everyone. It seems I'm not allowed to play mafia without health scares in my family. My 15 year old cat irl was having issues that needed a veterinary hospital visit for most of the day. My mind has not been focused at all since she has health scares a lot recently so I've been mentally gone.
I will confess, I did go after Usopp to kill him, but someone beat me to it. Funny thing to note though, by my understanding from the clown, there is no mafia so I'm not sure what to think about it.
Lynch me if you will, but I did not kill Usopp…not for lack of trying anyway...
Sorry to be a party pooper...
Ugh, sorry everyone. It seems I'm not allowed to play mafia without health scares in my family. My 15 year old cat irl was having issues that needed a veterinary hospital visit for most of the day. My mind has not been focused at all since she has health scares a lot recently so I've been mentally gone.
Is everything okay now now with her? And it's okay! hugs
I will confess, I did go after Usopp to kill him, but someone beat me to it. Funny thing to note though, by my understanding from the clown, there is no mafia so I'm not sure what to think about it.
Lynch me if you will, but I did not kill Usopp…not for lack of trying anyway...
Sorry to be a party pooper...
Interesting, sounds like a coverup, but since you responded, I guess we can hear what Bon Clay has to say about this all.
Killing an inactive player means better odds for the rest of us, so I'm still for lynching Queen after Bon Clay says his piece.
It's worth noting going forward that Nami, Bon Clay, and I could still have been responsible for this murder.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
(Also outside game mode: I'm very sorry about your cat Shuhan and I hope she'll be okay)
Unvote
I'm in no rush to lynch Queen. I have more to say but I'm quickly putting this out there in case the votes pile up
Guess I do the same.
Unvote
Ugh, sorry everyone. It seems I'm not allowed to play mafia without health scares in my family. My 15 year old cat irl was having issues that needed a veterinary hospital visit for most of the day. My mind has not been focused at all since she has health scares a lot recently so I've been mentally gone.
That is terrible to hear, I'm so sorry, Shuhan. Best wishes for your kitty and family, I really hope that everything works out. How are you managing? Feel free to message me about it if you need to chat or vent.
I will confess, I did go after Usopp to kill him, but someone beat me to it. Funny thing to note though, by my understanding from the clown, there is no mafia so I'm not sure what to think about it.
Lynch me if you will, but I did not kill Usopp…not for lack of trying anyway...
This completely checks out with my report on you, which means that you are off my list of murder suspects. BUT YOU ARE AT THE TOP OF MY LIST OF ATTEMPTED MURDER SUSPECTS!!!
Give me a little time to paraphrase, I don't want to copy-paste what Buggy said to me privately. I'll be right back.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Last night, I attempted to watch Queen, the sneaky bastard. And I was successful. Here is the gist of my report:
That's all, folks.
So, you should be able to see now why I'm fully convinced that Queen wasn't the murderer. But… this means that one of the rest of you is.
Now, if we account for all the people who did something "sneaky" last night (i.e. used their Stealth ability), we've got:
I'm the only one that didn't try using stealth last night. Weird.