Shu you were here. Did you not feel like talking?
Unvote
Vote Lynch: Shuhan
Shu you were here. Did you not feel like talking?
Unvote
Vote Lynch: Shuhan
Hey waffles you wanna add a reason to why you are vote lynching or are you just doing this for fun?
Votes get people scared, gets them to talk, say silly things. BTW I thought you just said you saw no point in random lynch votes. What made you change your mind a couple seconds later ;)
! Bogart, could you send me a link to whichever QuickTopic would allow me to see who's (doing) what?
Lynch Status: With eight alive it takes five to lynch. Shuhan [1]: xasjjx
trappedolphin [1]: vorlianis
Koh [1]: Waffles Waffles [2]: Koh
Not Voting [4]: Harvady Alumnus**,** Shuha****n, trappedolphin, Kitsune Inferno I don't actually have anything like that, Mrs. Iceburg. I guess I could make one…but I don't wanna...
Votes get people scared, gets them to talk, say silly things. BTW I thought you just said you saw no point in random lynch votes. What made you change your mind a couple seconds later ;)
Who ever said this was a random lynch? You randomly voted me without any explanation so i voted for you to get your attention which i see did. That is enough reason to vote to lynch you dont you think ;)
! Fine, be that way. :<
Then by your logic there is no such thing as a random vote as whoever you vote for will clearly get their attention. Xas voted and got Vorlianis' attention, my vote got your attention, I'm sure Vor's vote will get Trapped's attention, thus rendering the term random lynch useless in your world as you state above. So again, if this your logic why state "that you don't get why people are voting randomly" since we are grabbing the attention of others, and you clearly constitute this as not a random act, then why say we are randomly voting? You see what I mean, you are contradicting yourself.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Your vote is OMGUS, don't kid yourself. Also everyone, Koh's power is that his votes count as two! This would be an extremely useful power for a mafioso; and I'm sure Bogart knows this....just saying.
In what way would my power be useful for mafia? It is usually a town power and if it was a mafia power then it would be the easiest power to figure out mafia on and really I think anyone could have noticed that so no neeto act like you found something super secret and important when almost everyone probably sees it on thier own
Double votes are powerful in anyone's hands, because people seem to be allergic to corroboration. If you (Waffles) want to try and determine a person's alignment by their power, then you are surely doomed. Aside from the hopelessness of setup speculation in a Upick, you are also advocating claiming in general with your statement. Granted the size of the group will make wagons more simple, I still can't say that claiming will be of any use. Barring a specific gambit.
Powers are likely to be made clear to us in due time, so the best thing to do is keep town's advantages a secret. If Koh is mafia, then we already know the extent of his ability. If he's town, we risk losing a straightforward boon that's good for sticking it to the mafia. Voting.
**Vote Lynch: Waffles
Bogart*- We still get flips, right? When you said powers wouldn't be revealed, you were referring to an open setup, yes?
@Koh:
In what way would my power be useful for mafia? It is usually a town power and if it was a mafia power then it would be the easiest power to figure out mafia on and really I think anyone could have noticed that so no neeto act like you found something super secret and important when almost everyone probably sees it on thier own
The power can be on both sides, Let's not overstate on that kind of stuff being worth a lot to the mafia though.
Mostly only in cases that could win the game for one of the two sides.
Lynch Status: With eight alive it takes five to lynch. Shuhan [1]: xasjjx
trappedolphin [1]: vorlianis
Koh [1]: Waffles Waffles [3]: Koh, Harvady Alumnus
Not Voting [3]: Shuhan, trappedolphin, Kitsune Inferno
Yes, the game has fully-detailed flips upon a player's death.
Ugh, new internet is slow…-_-
Random lynching? Mmhh
vote lynch: Kitsune Inferno
Sorry, was slaying a virus. (This happens often for some reason).
So, let's get the random lynching started!
**Vote Lynch: Harvady Alumnus
Ze-hahahahahahaha!**
Sorry, was slaying a virus. (This happens often for some reason).
So, let's get the random lynching started!
**Vote Lynch: Harvady Alumnus
Ze-hahahahahahaha!**
So because you tend to be scum a lot lately, why should we not turn you into our whipping boy?
So because you tend to be scum a lot lately, why should we not turn you into our whipping boy?
I only remember him being scum in the last mini. In the last full game he was townie. What do you mean by a lot~?
Just saying it could be powerful if in mafia hands, look I'm already at L-2!!! People don't make the same mistake as last time and lynch me too early.
The only notable thing so far that I can point out is Koh's behaviour. The man states his displeasure at random lynching….then seconds later does the act he just criticized! (it's either a random lynch or OMGUS..take your pick)
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
So because you tend to be scum a lot lately, why should we not turn you into our whipping boy?
Like Trapped said, what? Everytime we think he is mafia (every game for me lol) he isn't. With the exception being last mini. Please explain further.
So because you tend to be scum a lot lately, why should we not turn you into our whipping boy?
I've been scum once since Mafia IX in a Mini.
"a lot" my foot.
I only remember him being scum in the last mini. In the last full game he was townie. What do you mean by a lot~?
His EM escapades still are fresh in my memory.
The only notable thing so far that I can point out is Koh's behaviour. The man states his displeasure at random lynching….then seconds later does the act he just criticized! (it's either a random lynch or OMGUS..take your pick)
He voted you to get a reaction, where did he say he wanted the lynch on you to go through yet? Just because you lynch someone doesn't mean you want that person to actually get lynched already.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I've been scum once since Mafia IX in a Mini.
"a lot" my foot.
More then me is a lot more in my book.
I've been scum once since Mafia IX in a Mini.
"a lot" my foot.
Well with how IX ended for you, I doubt you'd want to be scum again.
EM is far from recent…
EM is far from recent…
Not for you maybe.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Erm i meant not for us, sorry.
He voted you to get a reaction, where did he say he wanted the lynch on you to go through yet? Just because you lynch someone doesn't mean you want that person to actually get lynched already.
Everybody votes to get a reaction. That isn't the issue, the issue is why he would be against "random lynching". Xas tried to get a reaction out of you, I tried to get a reaction out of Harvady, you tried to get a reaction out of Trapped…thats the whole point out of these random votes. Why state that you don't get the point of it, then do the same thing...he didn't give a reason when he voted did he? No thats right he didn't, he did the same thing and thats ok if he didn't state his displeasure earlier. He contradicted himself, simple as that.
Everybody votes to get a reaction. That isn't the issue, the issue is why he would be against "random lynching". Xas tried to get a reaction out of you, I tried to get a reaction out of Harvady, you tried to get a reaction out of Trapped…thats the whole point out of these random votes. Why state that you don't get the point of it, then do the same thing...he didn't give a reason when he voted did he? No thats right he didn't, he did the same thing and thats ok if he didn't state his displeasure earlier. He contradicted himself, simple as that.
Maybe, but if you find that suspicious, why don't you question him?
Also trapped why are you not random lynching?
It's like saying "hey why is everybody getting a Big Mac? I hate Big Macs they suck!" ten minutes later Your in the drive through ordering a Big Mac, your friend then walks by and says "hey man wtf I thought you said you hated Big Macs?!" You then respond by saying "well ya, I'm only eating it cause I was hungry." Well duh thats why everybody orders a Big Mac, you bash those who get it, then you turn around and get one yourself!
Is anyone noticing how Harvard isn't scum-hunting as much? He is usually more active then just one post isn't he?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Harvady* sorry don't have a pc to type correctly with
Also trapped why are you not random lynching?
Mainly because I only managed to come at the later part of the day, after two pages. And randomly lynching feels/seems like something you do at the very start, at least to me. So yeah.~
Ugh, new internet is slow…-_-
Random lynching? Mmhh
vote lynch: Kitsune Inferno
I'll unvote now.
@vorlianis:
His EM escapades still are fresh in my memory
Meta is OK, but I don't think we should bring up EM here.
@Koh:
Is anyone noticing how Harvard isn't scum-hunting as much? He is usually more active then just one post isn't he?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Harvady* sorry don't have a pc to type correctly with
He is normally active, but he doesn't seem to post as much as other players, but when he says a lot.
@Eggo:
It's like saying "hey why is everybody getting a Big Mac? I hate Big Macs they suck!" ten minutes later Your in the drive through ordering a Big Mac, your friend then walks by and says "hey man wtf I thought you said you hated Big Macs?!" You then respond by saying "well ya, I'm only eating it cause I was hungry." Well duh thats why everybody orders a Big Mac, you bash those who get it, then you turn around and get one yourself!
I get McNuggets. Could you restate this, and replace Big Mac with McNugget? It would help me understand.
@xasjjx:
I'll unvote
I get McNuggets. Could you restate this, and replace Big Mac with McNugget? It would help me understand.
I seriously clapped out loud to this
xas, can I love you?
EM's a totally different game, vor.
It doesn't change the fact I'm not scum >_>
**Unvote
Vote MVP: xasjjx**
@xasjjx:
He is normally active, but he doesn't seem to post as much as other players, but when he does he says a lot.
Fixed .
Lynch Status: With eight alive it takes five to lynch. Shuhan [1]: xasjjx
trappedolphin [1]: vorlianis
Koh [1]: Waffles Waffles [3]: Koh, Harvady Alumnus
Harvady Alumnus [1]: Kitsune Inferno
Kitsune Inferno [1]: Shuhan
Not Voting: trappedolphin
Day One will always start off with a lot of null tells, that's a given. Speculation also follows along in most cases, seeing as most people play for the night. The main problem is that town's goal is to play with the night, not for it. That said I'm getting a lot of reads from people who're very eagerly crumbing their intentions for the night. This doesn't bode well for the hunt as many people are going to phone in the day in anticipation for the night. It's part of the reason I went with a vote on someone who'd already been voted. I'm confident that a wagon will make it to the finish if the time reaches less than six hours to deadline. In the meantime, we need to start deciding on a criteria.
Like I said, Day One is full of null tells, but it also doesn't hurt to make an example of someone. Claims are going to be ridiculous in this game, as a penned-in mafia can easily make a power claim that will appease the town for a night. To be honest, I've got a lot of reservations about claims at this point. Telling the truth isn't necessarily going to prove anyone's innocence. Which is why I'm much more partial to putting my vote out, rather than waiting for an obvious slip.
In a game of this size, lurking is a lot more noticable. Substance is going to come by less and less if people let lurking slide. There's more I want to say about this, but I'm waiting for a particular reaction.
trappedolphin, you haven't put down a vote yet, so I'd like to know what it is you're looking for. I'm not necessarily talking about evidence, but what shows up on your radar?
This is a trick, so be mindful about the answer.
Mmh. Like you said, Day 1 has a lot of null tells. I'm finding a few things I found to be slightly townlike, but it's hard to say about the reverse. It's kinda hard to get a read on random lynching, other than maybe a couple of interesting points. I did just notice one thing, though. Lurking~
Vote lynch: Shuhan
I almost forgot that he was playing until I saw the votecount while rereading. And I can't say I like lurkiness much. I recognise that this probably won't reach a full wagon today, though. And I agree with Harvy that claims are probably not very useful, even if they are the truth. So if time is of the essence, I'm willing to switch my vote if I find it deserving. (Bogart: How much time do we have left, anyway?)
I feel silly, but I don't understand what you meant. So I didn't give all my thoughts, in case that's what you were trying to tell me…
EM's a totally different game, vor.
It doesn't change the fact I'm not scum >_>
**Unvote
Vote MVP: xasjjx**
Random question was random, i'm surprised you took it as an serious attempt for me to make you a whipping boy.
"Because i'm not scum" is a rather redundant answer.
Perhaps I missed something, but I don't see why xasjjx unvoted his lynch vote on vorlianis in regard to Shuhan's post. As for the lurking thing, I'm game with lynching our least-productive player, especially in a situation like this where claims will do us little good and waiting for a scumslip is, well, anti-productive.
Perhaps I missed something, but I don't see why xasjjx unvoted his lynch vote on vorlianis in regard to Shuhan's post. As for the lurking thing, I'm game with lynching our least-productive player, especially in a situation like this where claims will do us little good and waiting for a scumslip is, well, anti-productive.
My vote was on Shuhan.
Well I'm sorry if moving into my apartment slowed my activity down, but I really am trying to get on.
Ah, right.~ Sorry, I'm horrible at reading lately.
Let's see…going by the Day One's post number of Janurary 14, 12:10 (HAST), the day ends 48 hours later, so January 16, 12:10. It's January 15, 8:46 right now, so Day One ends in 27 hours and 24 minutes. I think.
-Lynch Status: With eight alive it takes five to lynch. Shuhan [1]: trappedolphin
trappedolphin [1]: vorlianis
Koh [1]: Waffles Waffles [3]: Koh, Harvady Alumnus Kitsune Inferno [1]: Shuhan
Not Voting [2]: Kitsune Inferno**, xasjjx**
Sorry, KI. I'd assumed you'd voted someone for MVP before xasjjx and wanted to change your vote.
No unvoting huh? Wonder what the deal is with that…
A lot more time then. That's good. In regards to the criteria of the lynch, there are things that are universally agreed upon as 'bad', but I believe a more specific angle should be taken. I understand that discussing what drives you to vote can feel counter-productive, but it's either that, or staying silent until someone fails a reaction test. That could take a very long time, and most people aren't convinced by the same things that convince others. Intentions need to be made clear early on, otherwise you end up looking like an opportunist.
Opportunists are always very high on my list, but again, the problem lies in whether people agree on what is opportunistic.
! xasjjx - vorlianis
vorlianis - trappedolphin
Waffles - Harvady Alumnus
Waffles - Koh
xasjjx - Shuhan
Koh - Waffles
Harvady Alumnus - Waffles
Shuhan - Kitsune Inferno
Kitsune Inferno - Harvady Alumnus
xasjjs - Unvote
trappedolphin - Shuhan
Kitsune Inferno, why do you think no one has voted xasjjx?
Because I'm adorable…
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Let's see…going by the Day One's post number of Janurary 14, 12:10 (HAST), the day ends 48 hours later, so January 16, 12:10. It's January 15, 8:46 right now, so Day One ends in 27 hours and 24 minutes. I think.
-Lynch Status: With eight alive it takes five to lynch. Shuhan [2]: trappedolphin, xasjjx
trappedolphin [1]: vorlianis
Koh [1]: Waffles Waffles [3]: Koh, Harvady Alumnus Kitsune Inferno [1]: ShuhanNot voting: Kitsune Inferno
Sorry, KI. I'd assumed you'd voted someone for MVP before xasjjx and wanted to change your vote.
I unvoted as well.
@#8468: No worries, I was referring to xas's unvote.
@#8470: Honestly, my answer was going to be xas's :P
But seriously, it's a very good question. He hasn't done anything particularly lynchworthy, but the likewise is certainly true as well.
Yesh why is everyone so quiet…..I hate silence.....
Fine. You've forced me to be the one to break the silence. I want everybody to ask me as much questions as possible, I don't care what just ask. I will answer with 100% honesty I'm actually probably gonna lie on everyone so ha! It's not like anyone will highlight this text anyways…..
Yeah….so ask away hopefully it'll get some discussion going. Oh and Xas is this the real you? You've spoken more in this mini then any of your previous games combined! Oh and I like Mcnuggets too just don't tell anyone....
Yeah….so ask away hopefully it'll get some discussion going. Oh and Xas is this the real you? You've spoken more in this mini then any of your previous games combined! Oh and I like Mcnuggets too just don't tell anyone....
I only lurked in the two games I played with you, and the end of Shu's game…
@xasjjx:
I only lurked in the two games I played with you, and the end of Shu's game…
Just messing with ya buddy not serious
Do you have any questions for me?
What do you think about no one lynching me?
Because your adorable
I think it's cause early on we want people to talk and you've been pretty aggressive so far, first one to post and vote etc. I think people aren't worried at this moment in time. The real question is why doesn't Harvady have a vote on him.