More on Gerri:
I think Gerri's done a pretty good job of contributing to find the mafia, and questioning others. Gerri was first to post in the game, and first to start Hypo-Cop, but I don't think either of those point to him as being mafia or town.
I think the possibility of Waffles and Shuhan both being in the mafia is indeed an interesting thought. However, in posts 5237 and 5241, Shuhan sounded as if he suspected Waffles more than TMWNN. As he apologized for voting against TMWNN, I wonder, Shuhan, do you plan on unvoting TMWNN?
I think your other points against Shuhan (him saying that he'd vote Waffles or TMWNN, and, though it's been said before multiple times, the "only" case) are weak, but I or someone else has already talked on those.
When you talk about Foolio defending Waffles, are you referring to this post?
Also, Waffles does have a point. I'll have to re-read some stuff more carefully before I comment further on that matter though.
Aside from that, I don't see where Foolio defended Waffles. And I don't really think this is defending, because Foolio's not saying anything specific.
I can't really comment on xasjjx voting to lynch Gerri because I don't know how Gerri has played in the past… and besides, making judgements based solely on the past seems kind of like cheating. But I'd like to note that Gerri admitted before xasjjx had voted against him:
First, I'm not usually a quick voter but I became upset by some people acting like this day 1 will be any different from the other days ahead of us.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@Gerri:
Gunkan, if you ever read some of the earlier games you will realize that he died very early in a lot of them (once even twice). So often infact that him not being killed was half-jokingly referred to as a scumtell on him. My post was a reference to that. If you ever play with him and start as badly as this game, you'll understand.. (-;
Oh. That makes more sense now, thanks. And I'm going to look again at Foolio's posts because I think I might have forgotten about them.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I didn't notice this from Waffles:
@Waffles:
Mind you this flip did not occur an hour or two later where maybe more evidence is at your disposal no this flip occured literally minutes after your first vote with the exact same evidence you had prior to your first vote, I ask again what made you change your mind so suddenly? Also you seem to be calming people's suspicions about TheMan, the same guy who you felt so compelled to vote for. Why the sudden change in attitude? Hmm could this be some sort of elaborate plan hatched by two Mafia buddies…I wonder....
You're not really one to talk about quick responses:
5:30– I vote to lynch NoName
5:47-- (17 minutes elapsed) You vote to lynch NoName too
6:10--(23 minutes elapsed) I switch to vote you out
If anything your response was faster. Your fast (even by your standards) reaction made you more suspicious to me than TMWNN, and since TMWNN hasn't done anything alarming to me.