Right now Nico Robin is 38. Gold Roger was executed 20 years ago right? 38-20=18. So Robin would have been 18 when Roger died. It's possible that Robin could have been a part of Roger's crew. Don't go saying she was to young back then because right now Luffy is 17, Zoro is 18, Sanjji is 18, and Nami is 17. So it's POSSIBLE that she could have been part of his crew at the time.
Nico Robin- Former Member of Gold Roger's Crew!?
-
-
She was eight, cuz she's actually 28 now! =)
-
Nico Robin is 28 years old. I don´t know where you´ve got the 38 years from. And Gold Roger was exectued 22 years ago. So this means that she was the age of 6 when Roger was executed.
-
yeah, there's no way she was a member.. but I think she met him once… ôo
-
I hoped this would be a "Robin-former crew of the Straw-Hat pirates?" topic
==
Right now Nico Robin is 38. Gold Roger was executed 20 years ago right? 38-20=18. So Robin would have been 18 when Roger died. It's possible that Robin could have been a part of Roger's crew. Don't go saying she was to young back then because right now Luffy is 17, Zoro is 18, Sanjji is 18, and Nami is 17. So it's POSSIBLE that she could have been part of his crew at the time.
You mess up the age, Sanji is 19 years old, Zoro is 19 years old also, Nami is 18 years old.
Here's the list of ages (oldest to youngest)
Franky: 34
Nico Robin: 28
Sanji and Zoro: 19
Nami: 18
Luffy and Usopp: 17
Chopper: 15 -
This post is deleted!
-
franky is 34?! holy crap…i guess he is...
-
Yep. IIRC he was twelve when Roger was executed; that makes him 34 in the present time.
-
Robin couldn't have been a part of Roger's crew because of age… also, Roger had been to Skypiea. Robin had never been there before.
-
Chopper's 15? He seems a lot younger to me - like pre-teenish.
-
If anyone alive was on Gold Roger's crew, those people would be Kureah (the doctor) or Dragon (the mad prophet).
-
If anyone alive was on Gold Roger's crew, those people would be Kureah (the doctor) or Dragon (the mad prophet).
Don't forget Crocus.
-
I think it is safe to say that Robin wasnt on Roger's crew but could her parents have been on his crew? Or one of her relatives. Considering how much Roger got around and given he undoubtably could read or knew a good deal about the ancient text and whatnot maybe there is a link between Roger or someone on his crew and Robin.
-
-
@joekido:
I hoped this would be a "Robin-former crew of the Straw-Hat pirates?" topic
==
You mess up the age, Sanji is 19 years old, Zoro is 19 years old also, Nami is 18 years old.
Here's the list of ages (oldest to youngest)
Franky: 34
Nico Robin: 28
Sanji and Zoro: 19
Nami: 18
Luffy and Usopp: 17
Chopper: 15Chopper is 15!? Where'd you find that.
-
-
As most people have mentioned I don't think Robin was part of Gold Roger's crew. Well, that's what I think
Hmmm…..maybe Roger spent a few months living with Robin's clan (the Ohara) which made it possible for him to learn ancient language.
-
Robin couldn't been part of Gold Roger crew, do you remember the quote of vol 32, where Robin said she should came to Raftel? Roger was the only one, whit his crew, to came there.
-
I think it is safe to say that Robin wasnt on Roger's crew but could her parents have been on his crew? Or one of her relatives. Considering how much Roger got around and given he undoubtably could read or knew a good deal about the ancient text and whatnot maybe there is a link between Roger or someone on his crew and Robin.
Thats a very plauible idea. It could explain why Rodger could read the pologhrahs whatever you call em things.
Oh and is Robin the sole suviour of the people she is a person of (the ohara i think?)?
-
@Ace:
Thats a very plauible idea. It could explain why Rodger could read the pologhrahs whatever you call em things.
Oh and is Robin the sole suviour of the people she is a person of (the ohara i think?)?
-*- What's sole suviour. The thing I know (but not sure if it answer the question) is that Robin is the only one left alive from Ohara, making the government to somehow think she's the person who destroyed Ohara. Is that answer your question, or no? :mellow:
-
It's more likely Shanks and Buggy were apart of Roger's crew
-
Nah, we saw their old captain remember? Nothing like Roger
-
Nah, we saw their old captain remember? Nothing like Roger
I thought we only saw him in the anime but was never seen in the manga, but if not then OK not to bothered
-
Yeah, he's tall and skinny with light hair and he's got glasses. I always wanted to know more about him, but we never do get to find out much :P
-
Yeah, he's tall and skinny with light hair and he's got glasses. I always wanted to know more about him, but we never do get to find out much :P
I just read the chapter where you see them on the same ship. I don't think the guy you were talking about was ever mentioned as the captain.
-
-*- What's sole suviour. The thing I know (but not sure if it answer the question) is that Robin is the only one left alive from Ohara, making the government to somehow think she's the person who destroyed Ohara. Is that answer your question, or no? :mellow:
well…. when I read the manga, the first thing that come to my mind is that: Robin is the sole survivor of her clan/Ohara clan (poor Robin sniff). but the goverment didn't think she is the one who destroy her own clan, instead they put bounty on her head because she destroyed several marine ships (6 or 8, I forgot). later on (as the story progress) I don't think the 'destroying ships' is the real reason for her bounty, but it's more because she is the only one who can read ancient text. but then again... that's just my point of view... could be wrong
oh, and I don't think Robin is a part of Roger's crew, but maybe..... Roger once met her when she is still a little girl, or maybe Roger have some connection with Ohara clan?? just a guess
-
if i'm not mistaken her island was destroyed by the Buster Call right? Also on the other thigns that make me confident she wasn't in Rogers crew is:
The age.
So far everybody we've seen that are more than likely to have met Gol D. Roger reffered to him as Roger (Crocus,Logue bartender). In Skypea Robin reffered to him as Pirate King. That's one giveaway, IMO. Another one was her suprised look to find writings from Roger in Skypea. If she was on the crew (even if joined after skypea) she should've heard of the Sky Island that Roger visited.Also just to point out: i don't think either Shanks or Buggy were from Roger's crew. IMHO, we have those two listed above, Kureha and Dragon as most likely former members of his crew. Maybe someone from Luffys family (grandpa) if there is no direct link between him and Roger.
-
I think Gol D. Roger is Nico Robin unknow father he had a case with one of the Ohara girls and a few months after Nico Robin was born :laugh:
Wasn't Gol D. Roger the only one to reach Raftel (not sure if is crew set foot on the island too)
Nico Robin couldn't be of Gol D. Roger's crew but she could be daughter of one of the crew members or a friend of Gol D. Roger (just like Kargara and Montblanc Norland where friend)
But maybe Gol D. Roger was one of the Ohara and that is his connection to Nico Robin
And also it was Buster Call that attacked Ohara
-
-blinks- I never remember seeing this in the manga about her being the last of her clan? which chaps were they?
-
try reading the sea train part when blueno gets her. i don't have access to it here but i'm sure blueno says shes THE/A survivor from the Demons of Ohara or something like this.
-
Ah ok… I'll go back and read those... I just wasn't to into the eps with CP9..
-
@Bad-Beat:
I just read the chapter where you see them on the same ship. I don't think the guy you were talking about was ever mentioned as the captain.
The guy has a captains colar. That thing paired with the fact that he is the one to order the others around is enough evidence for me to take him as their captain.
-
The guy has a captains colar. That thing paired with the fact that he is the one to order the others around is enough evidence for me to take him as their captain.
Fair enough.(wastes 20 characters)
=) -
Maybe one of the 7 members of the Shichibukai was once a member of Gol D. Roger's crew.
-
how old is shanks anyway?
maybe shanks was a part of Gol.D. Rogers crew and when he died, he asked shanks to take care of his grandson Luffy??
i really wanna know how old all the other characters from One Piece are…
like Shanks, Buggy, Aokiji.. any suggestions?
-
I think Shanks was in his late 20's when he was in Luffy's hometown. So he would be in his late 30's now in the story so far.
-
37 t'be specific. Robin gets deeper and deeper as I learn more about her. I like the idea of Robin's family possibly being one of the Gol D. Roger pirates. Could someone fill me in on what happens to Robin in Water 7. I'm a bit confuzzled.
-
@Cap'n:
Maybe one of the 7 members of the Shichibukai was once a member of Gol D. Roger's crew.
Until now the only ShichiBukai that could have been on Gol D. Roger's crew in my opinion would be Mihawk
And for Shanks to be Gol D. Roger's crew member Buggy would also be (remember Buggy and Shanks were of the same crew when young)
But the Captain of the ship Buggy and Shanks where in doesn't look like Gol D. Roger
And wouldn't Buggy go directly to the One Piece treausre if he knew where it was?
My guess is that Buggy and Shanks where WhiteBeard's crew members
Anyways I still think that Gol D. Roger and Nico Robin have something that bonds them together maybe because the two know (knew in Roger's case) the ancient language
Something that for what was been told till now isn't a easy task
-
@Bad-Beat:
It's more likely Shanks and Buggy were apart of Roger's crew
Possibilty. Though the chances of they being former members is like 5%. Unless that man of course is Roger. He didn't look like Roger, so it's not likley. But also don't forget that we never complatley saw Rogers face. Still thought the possibilty is very late. It's safe to assume however that their old captian is/was no small fry. Also did anyone notice the similarties between Gaimons captian and Roger? Or was he only shown in the anime?
-
Originally Posted by Darkariel
Anyways I still think that Gol D. Roger and Nico Robin have something that bonds them together maybe because the two know (knew in Roger's case) the ancient languageI think that Gol D. Roger knew Nico Robin's parents who might of been low rank marine officials as well as archaeologists. Maybe Nico's parents were close of discovering the true history of the world, so the maybe the commander of chief back then didn't want the true history to be discover so he could of order them to be killed. And before they died, Nico's parents could of gave what info they learn about the true history's whereabouts to Gol D. Roger since he must of show some respect towards them. So since Nico's parents help Gold Roger, the commander in chief back then must of thought that Nico's parents also told her what they told Gold Roger. So the commander in chief back then frame Nico for destroying the marine ships to cover up everything. That's what I think.
-
@Octogon:
Possibilty. Though the chances of they being former members is like 5%. Unless that man of course is Roger. He didn't look like Roger, so it's not likley. But also don't forget that we never complatley saw Rogers face. Still thought the possibilty is very late. It's safe to assume however that their old captian is/was no small fry. Also did anyone notice the similarties between Gaimons captian and Roger? Or was he only shown in the anime?
No he was shown in the manga…..but he didn't look like roger at ALL. I think they must have changed him for the anime...
-
Robin was Gold Roger's wife.
-
Steve? Steve? You need to chill a little steve….
-
Maybe Robin could of been Gold Roger's cabin girl.
-
At age 4, 5, or 6? I dont think so.
-
-
For my self if robin have something to do with Gold D Roger, it would probably be in an adventure of GDR when maybe he stop on the island of the ohara.
I don't think that she was in his crew, but if they have meet this could be the reason of her high bountie when she was 8 (with the destruction of 8 navy ship etc) (or could have been the start of it)
-
maybe Robin is Roger's god-daughter.
-
I still think there exists the possibility that Shanks and Buggy were either a part of Gol D Rogers crew or White Beard. As for the fact that the captain of the ship was neither Roger or White Beard we should remember, at least for White Beard and if you consider Shanks 90mil berri rookie, that there are other ships under the same flag where someone like Ace will be in command of The captain's, White Beards, crew.
-
I dont think that she ever met Gol D. at all. If anything I belive that maybe like someone stated earlier: Someone of the Ohara group may have been apart of the crew, not neccisarily Robin. Although her facial expression is kinda weird when she reads Rogers quote on the polyglyph in skypiea.