Absolute Faves: Crocodile and Robin.
Big favourites: Enel, Dofla, Law, Usopp.
Other favourites: Auger, Smoker, Noland, Ivankov, Kuro, Bon Clay.
I went through the thread and did a quick, messy count-up of who got mentioned the most! Due to how people all posted lists and picks differently and were kinda vague about how much they liked who or who, I wont rely on exact numbers, instead, tiers which characters sit on:
40+ Mentions: ZORO (he's the king XD)
30-40 Mentions: Luffy!
25-29 Mentions: Crocodile, Robin, Law.
20-24 Mentions: Usopp.
15-19 Mentions: Sanji.
10-14 Mentions: Buggy, Nami, Enel, Dofla, Whitebeard, Franky, Smoker.
7-9 Mentions: Aokiji, Bon Clay, Ace, Shanks, Kizaru, Blackbeard, Chopper, Brook, Marco, Perona, Garp, Hancock.
4-6 Mentions: Inazuma, Magellan, Cavendish, Coby, Sentoumaru, Moria, Wiper, Rayleigh, Kaku, Drake, Gin, Lucci, Ivankov, Sabo, Mihawk, Kuma, Dragon.
2 or 3 mentions: Tashigi, Hawkins, Mr. 3, Doctorine, Hattori, Hannyabal, Akainu, Bartolomeo, Kumadori, Shiryu.
There are tonnes with only one mention, lmao. I just wanted to see generally how much certain individual charas were mentioned, this isn't a definitive list by any means >v> Still, interesting results, interesting to have a picture of what charas get chosen as faves most often…