Overated 45% of the time is more of a reference to something that's so good some people can't accept it.
iPod? Many people say it's over rated too.
Truth is unless it's blantanly obvious that it is given more credit than it should be, it's brushed off and the personwho says it's overrated looks stupid.
I thought it was a very good game, I enjoyed the gameplay, and could follow the interesting plot up until jsut past halfway through. I'l ladmit, looking back it's less exciting than when you are actually there. Like the difference between riding an airplane or a car, and watching a video of the same thing. The video is boring but actually being there helps.