I've thoroughly enjoyed most of the movies, but a few have been less than good. Here's my take:
Movie 1: This was the first One Piece thing I ever watched, and because its animation style was literally DBZ like in some sections, I was hooked on the series. That being said, story wasn't really there for me most of the time. 7 out of 10
Movie 2: 3rd best movie out of the bunch. Every crewmember including Usopp got his own chance to showcase their skills. The Zoro and Sanji fights were especially sick! Story was also interesting but somewhat predictable. 9 out of 10
Movie 3: Kind of strange story but the fights were good, especially Zoro and Sanjis (movies seem to like these guys). I liked the focus on Chopper, but no Vivi kind of disappointed me. 6 out of 10
Movie 4: 2nd best movie and probably has the most rewatchability for me. The Gasparde fight was VERY similar to crocodile was still enjoyable for a lot of the extra ideas it used. The race idea was great, but I wish they had played that idea up a little bit more. 9.5 out of 10
Movie 5: Boring as shit except for the end fight and a little past between Saga and Zoro. I had high hopes for a Zoro related movie and I feel really let down. 5 out of 10
Movie 6: @iMustang - youre thinking of the ART is bad, not the animation. The animation is how the characters in the actual movie flow and move. So yes the animation was INCREDIBLE. The art SUCKED. :getlost:But, I find this animation much impressive due to its expressiveness. (Is it just me or is apforums the only people in the One Piece community that doesn't like this art style. I've seen more haters for this art style than the shitty animation we normally get for episodes.)
Anyway, Movie 6 is easily the best out of all of the movies, animation aside, it a very welcome change to the happy go lucky crew we have all been used to. The story was there in spades, and most of the time, it felt like a much more darker, demented version of the Davy Back Fight. The slow annihilation of the crew was also intense and it made keep watching to see what was going to happen. I think the Baron is the only person Luffy's killed. Therefore this movie peaked my interest. 10 out of 10:wub:
Movie 7: BOOBS!!!!! :blink:The story was great, but the action was far too short and could have been left out for just a mystery. Gear Second was nice to see in this movie though. 6 out of 10
Movie 8: SUCKED!!!!! :getlost:The only way I watch this movie is by watching the Funimation dub which was Fucking INCREDIBLE!!!
Japanese: 3 out of 10 Funimation: 7 out of 10
Movie 9: Absolutely amazing style of art. Story, although a retelling, was very cool and the inclusion of Franky and Robin and Mushul was far too awesome. Geaer Second blew my mind at the end. Gear Three felt weak.
8 out of 10
Movie 10: CAN'T WAIT!!!!!!