It would be sporadically updated - and the person would probably just finish the Manga in a week and try and go via memory for most of the events. Unless they're an experienced blogger - sounds like this guy has been watching Doug Walker's Avatar series and thinks it would translate well to a 700+ Manga with well established theories and analysts spanning many many years. This guy and his friend are free to do what they want of course but unless they're an experienced blogger it might just end up being yet another abandoned project on the net.
I might be too cynical too but this thread sets off my Troll Bait alarm - there are so many buttons you can push with readers of one piece and get reactions 99% without even trying.
I'm the friend that rereboy has been talking about and it annoys me that you judge me without knowing the first thing about me. I'm not some idiot who just jumped on the bandwagon without knowing what he's getting into. I've read plenty of other manga and watched plenty of other anime and I knew how big and successful a series One Piece is.
The fact that you immediately point out that I may know nothing about the series because I've "been watching Doug Walker's Avatar" says a lot about you and really annoys me, at least make a judgement when you know more about me.
It is also disappointing that you expect me to be a troll. rereboy can tell you, as I have been updating him personally on my progress, that I am taking this seriously. It seems that a lot of you don't think this is a good idea and considering how I've been judged so early on, I don't think this is for the best for me either.
So thank you for having me, even though it was brief, I will continue to enjoy One Piece and keep my thoughts to myself,
RZJezter