What's up with the modding here?

Fanservice

http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=10036 –> I made this thread.

Then, bevin (I think) closed my thread because, apparently, he says it's the same as this thread: http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=7268&highlight=Piece

Er…do you guys read? My thread got closed because some posters thought that I was actually ASKING for actual theories about what One Piece is and started posting stuff like "I don't think One Piece is blah..blah because...". I can't believe you guys never took the time to actually understand what I was asking for in the first post?

READ the thread. It's clearly a joke thread. There's a big difference between the lines "What is One Piece?" and "What are the theories concerning One Piece that make you barf?"

I've moderated on other forums before and I tend to read first and actually see if there are similar threads before closing them. At times, I even leave the repetitive threads alone because they're all gonna be deleted eventually. I just thought it was wierd that the mod who closed it thought it was the same thread as the one he posted when it's clear as sunlight that it is not.

Polygon

Yeah, those two threads were completley different.

psolaras

totally agree with you fanservice,my "when i see you the wound that bastard gave me aches" thread was closed cuz 434 is still open according to bevin

then why "what weapon does BB have?" is still open? it was based in statements 434 as well as mine

why even threads exist? since all occurs in the chapters there is no need for extra threads

i shall go post in the 434 thread and wait eternally for someone to answer cuz nobody goes in the previous chapter thread when the new is up and if a person sees it by mistake i shall pray he is interested in what i wrote and then answer

HELP ME GOD!!!

and not mention about my other thread about roger being caught cuz he was betrayed by one of his nakama

5 weeks ago the first page was filled with franky threads: franky joining,franky's power,franky or paulie,franky making the new ship,where did franky spent the money?,and none of these threads was made less than 3 times and almost none was closed

well what do i need to say

now i shall pray to god for bevin not read my threads when he is pissed about something!!!

HELP ME AGAIN GOD!!!1

CosmicDebris

Bevin probably made a mistake, it's happened before. Nobody's perfect. I'll let her make the call of what to do though since I'm not the one who closed it.

However, making a thread about it, particularly in the manga forum, is the WRONG thing to do. Next time, please just PM Bevin and ask her why she closed it…most likely she would have just kindly reopened it, but making a big stink about it doesn't really make anyone happy.
At the very least, if you want to adress a global problem with mods (it doesn't seem that way, you just are mad about your thread) then go to the suggestion forum, not here.

Fanservice

I'm not mad about the thread. I'm just saying it was closed incorrectly. And the fact that I'm perturbed that it's really a different thread and even if you only read the topic, you would have known that they were completely different. I'm like…"did she get an itchy finger or something or did she not read the thread?"

I apologize for not posting it in the proper forum or PMing the mod first.

CosmicDebris

She might have, she has more of a life than I do (I think ) and may have just seen a bunch of threads pop up that looked repetitious. I agree that they're different threads. But maybe she had a reason, so I'll just wait and let her make the call on that, I don't really like undoing other mod's decisions.

psolaras

well i hope she will reconsider opening my thread's too

CosmicDebris

@psolaras:

well i hope she will reconsider opening my thread's too

Sorry, couldn't resist. ^^;

Zulen

Mod's aren't perfect….. (DON'T BAN ME FOR SAYING IT!!)

bevin

@Private:

Mod's aren't perfect….. (DON'T BAN ME FOR SAYING IT!!)

Why would we, we say that more than anyone else, I'm willing to bet.

As for the threads, it's certainly possible that I misjudged them. I'm pretty much buried in schoolwork these days and under a lot of stress, so I've come down with a pretty bad case of The Stupid. I have a really important test that I'm not remotely ready for tomorrow, so I don't really have the concentration to go through all these and make a call, so Cosmic, I'll totally trust your judgement on them. Hopefully after a holiday my brain might come back online.

Oh, and yeah, if anyone has a problem with a call I (or any of the mods) make, it's best to PM us directly instead of ranting in the forum. Best to start things off on the right foot. ^^

CosmicDebris

Alright then, I will reopen Fanservice's thread. Although I will also move it to General One Piece since it belongs there more than manga.

I hope you do well on your test Bevin, don't let the forum give you extra stress. ^^;