Manga to Anime edits

Throes

I am basically wondering what Toei changes from the One Piece manga to air in the anime. I did a search, and didn't find even a similar thread, and I'm really curious on this topic.

One change I found was during Little Garden. In the manga, Mr. 3 creates wax swords to hold down Brogy's hands and feet, and in the anime, Toei decided to tone down the violence and make it wax spikes, while at the same time covering his hands and feet with added wax. I've compiled images to illustrate my point.

I basically am curious as to what else Toei has changed from the manga to put it into anime form.

EDIT: I am not interested in transitions into fillers, or the fillers themselves either.

--MRED--

Falling from the sky
and into a military base

But that edit just seems to do the same basic thing, just keep the blood from going everywhere

Cinder

Some from the top of my head:

Rock -> Tomato (Conis, Young Robin)
Situation with Zeff's leg
Young Luffy and his scar (anime kind of made it so that he got it from Higuma)
Crewmembers that went to Gaimon's island

scratches head

TakinawaTonfa

Ace's Tattoo comes to my mind. It was changed from a manji (卍) to a cross.

I honestly wouldn't be all that surprised if Viz made the respective change as well.

RomanGod

Viz'll proboally change his tattoo to what you see in the anime.

Buuhan1

Cinder listed all the changes I noticed.

goty

Kid Sanji trying to smoke was cut.

Kaos

http://www.xkstation.com/everyonepeace/difindice.html

Kazu-kun

@RomanGod:

Viz'll proboally change his tattoo to what you see in the anime.

Well Viz has changed something like that. In the manga of naruto Neji has a manji seal while in the anime he has a cross, same case as Ace

In Bleach, in the manga Ichimaru Gin cut off Jidanbou's entire arm, while in the anime Gin created a huge gash

GearSecond

anyone know how to make google translate a site?

Buuhan1

I did that myself, but don't bother. I just learned that Google isn't even close to perfecting spanish translation. -_-

But here, don't try and read what it says too hard. I already got a headache.
http://64.233.179.104/translate_c?hl=en&sl=es&u=http://www.xkstation.com/everyonepeace/difindice.html&prev=/search%3Fq%3Deveryonepeace/difindice.html%26hl%3Den%26lr%3D%26safe%3Doff

--MRED--

Most of the differences just look like angles
and maybe a replacement of a knife or two

D:

Sekum GoldenPirate

I understand it…. 16 characters, I WILL HAVE MAH REVENGE

Roz

Wow. That Spanish site is pretty thorough! It had everything that I was going to point out on it (Namely Bon's coat and the chefs pointing giant silverware as opposed to guns).

And now all of those years of learning Spanish finally pay off.

Zulen

Let's not be forgetting Chapter 155, in which Usopp, Chopper, and Carue were "fishing" and Nami beats them up.

And in the Anime, Sanji mashes their heads together (Episode 91).

Roz

I think I found one that wasn't on the Spanish site. Just an extremely minor position change, nothing exciting.

Buuhan1

@Private:

Let's not be forgetting Chapter 155, in which Usopp, Chopper, and Carue were "fishing" and Nami beats them up.

[qimg]http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j64/Glitzfighter/12.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j64/Glitzfighter/13.jpg[/qimg]

And in the Anime, Sanji mashes their heads together (Episode 91).

[qimg]http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j64/Glitzfighter/vlcsnap-2040810.png[/qimg]

That was on the spanish site.

Zulen

@Buuhan1:

That was on the spanish site.

Hahah, sorry about that. Didn't bother reading the whole thing.

Dr. Casey

The wax spikes used to pin down Brogy actually seem more brutal to me than the swords do.

Anime Master

…No one mentioned the Eneis Lobby scene with Usopp looking manly instead of cowering?
That was HUGE in the Raw thread.

kryptonite

@Dr.:

The wax spikes used to pin down Brogy actually seem more brutal to me than the swords do.

Let's ignore the blood flowing out…

Another one would be the appearance of Don Krieg's shuriken bomb... >_> Oh, and the appearance of Mr. 3's swords, of course...

Off Topic:

Err- Is that the pisture 4kids used on their forum? >_>;

Sekum GoldenPirate

yeah, pretty much

Kaos

Pff, it's the first image that appears in Google when you search "going merry" images.

captain usopp

@kryptonite:

Another one would be the appearance of Don Krieg's shuriken bomb… >_> Oh, and the appearance of Mr. 3's swords, of course...

what shurikin bomb? :)

Kaos

A fake MH5 bomb that was skipped in the anime.

He has that attack in Grand Battle RUSH though.

Book Shonen

About the wax swords, in the manga Luffy wraps his arm and spins around one of them to smash the candle service set pillar. In the anime he grabs onto one of the horns on his helmet.

kryptonite

I can't imagine what kind of pain he would be in with a wax spinning sword in his arm… >_>;

Book Shonen

It's ok, Luffy apologized for it :happy:

Mavado

No mention of Foxy getting impaled upon his own spike trap?

http://groups.msn.com/OnePieceMangav-2/chapter315lq.msnw?action=ShowPhoto&PhotoID=7485

Buuhan1

@Anime:

…No one mentioned the Eneis Lobby scene with Usopp looking manly instead of cowering?
That was HUGE in the Raw thread.

What scene was this? Sorry, I haven't really watched the anime since 257.

Book Shonen

Young Robin getting the "Conis-treatment". Oh-noes anything but tomatoes!

Sakonosolo

In the fight between Gear Second Luffy and Blueno, in the anime they added a couple of attacks that weren't in the manga.

Buuhan1

Just noticed another.

During the beginning of Long Ring Long Land, we are introduced to Foxy after he shot Cherie in the leg, chopper then treated her. Well, in the anime, Foxys gun becomes a net gun, and instead of Cherie actually getting shot her legs just get tangled in a net.

Its kinda funny how everyone was overreacting do to a net. XD

captain usopp

maybe it was just easier to animate?

Ubiq

Two I can think of off the top of my head:

The Blackbeard crew is reordered during the sequence where they're all shown together; Doc Q is originally next to Teach, but is moved over on the opposite side of Burgess for whatever reason in the anime.

All of Crane's lines are reassigned to someone else in the anime, mostly Sengoku, or deleted entirely. She just sits there and does nothing for that entire episode as a result.

Buuhan1

@captain:

maybe it was just easier to animate?

Oh yeah, huge nets are soooo much easier to animate than a bloody horse leg.

captain usopp

no, the horse being shot would be easier than the net. isn't that what you said. the anime had the gun shot?looks above oh..DAMN. I saw net"GUN" an got confused. (great wording buu) :P

Throes

I noticed during Robin's short flashbacks in the more recent episodes that Toei cut out the short flashbacks of the people telling her to die before going to Saul's inspiring words.

Senshi Mizaka

I think they also cut the scene of Robin trying to get on the escape boat, but gets kicked off.

Buuhan1

I haven't seen the anime since 257 so I wouldn't know about all that, but it seems Toei doesn't like to show kids being treated cruely.

Dr. Casey

@kryptonite:

Let's ignore the blood flowing out…

Eh, it's just blood. Doesn't really faze me.

King Calamari

The spikes don't even look like they've actually been stabbed through his hands and feet. The original scene is still more brutal and it seems like even Toei thought so or else the wouldn't have changed it.