Avatar/Signature Rating: The Next Generation

[ITSALION]

The ending of our last round was brought to a well-deserved end by an Act of Mod. SO we're going into extra innings!

http://apforums.net/showpost.php?p=273563&postcount=9
@ocean:

… I don't know other mods' opinion, but I'll give this thread one more chance. Some suggestion/requirement from me:

• Put your avatar and signature in post itself. Use Photobucket. Do not direct-link the avatars from this forum since it'll change when you change it. After looking back old posts, people wouldn't know which avatar/sig that was rated because people keep changing their ava/sig. And that is VERY meaningless.

• Give constructive opinion on your rating. "I like Naruto so I give you 10/10" is NOT constructive. "You did a good job on shading" is constructive. "The object (main character) is too much to the left. You should balance it more" is constructive.

• If you already commented the person above's ava/sig, do not post. Wait until someone else post. Rating same person twice for same ava/sig is meaningless. (Alternatively, you can rate the person two posts above yours, I guess...)

If above three conditions are not kept, this thread will be closed again.

IT'S A LION!, next time when you want to create a new thread of a closed thread, make sure to ask mods first. Threads were closed for a reason and if you keep doing that, there's no meaning for us being around. Same apply to everyone; next time when we see this, you'll receive a warning.

[Ms. Suave Debonair]

This post is deleted!

[ITSALION]

Why not? It was a long thread, enjoyed by many, and it had to be closed! So why not start a new one?
OH! I forgot.
Bad-Beat's Avi: luv teh Luffy 9/10
Sig: o_O 8.5/10

[Creeping_Wrath]

Avatar: 7/10, kinda plain to me but it goes well with the screen name.

Sig: Hmm, manga image…It's somewhat amuzing. 7.3/10

I think that if we add SOME description rather than JUST ratings, it'll be ok.

[ITSALION]

Creeping Wrath…
Avi: It's skinny! But I think it makes a good avatar. 8/10
Your sig is too green. But it fits. 8.9/10

[nguyen]

@IT'S:

Why not? It was a long thread, enjoyed by many, and it had to be closed! So why not start a new one?

Because a mod'll lock this.

[Duce of Transilvania]

The mod's said that such threads promot no discussion, that was the reason for them beeing closed, not their length(althought that was also a factor).
This is going to get closed. Or we could try do talk about the ava/sig, why we picked them etc.. not "rate" them, if that still does not suit the mod's, then I surrender!

[Bounty1Berry]

My new signature I got from something I doodled (see my fanart thread). That's the merit of a bubble power, you can go away and hormoneball Sanji will never notice the difference.

Duce: I like the sig graphic, although I wish I knew what it was from. It could be wider though– 8/10.

Avatar: If you removed that white line at the edge, it would be a lot cleaner. It's also a bit "nondramatic" for the subject matter. 7/10.

[oceanizer]

… I don't know other mods' opinion, but I'll give this thread one more chance. Some suggestion/requirement from me:

• Put your avatar and signature in post itself. Use Photobucket. Do not direct-link the avatars from this forum since it'll change when you change it. After looking back old posts, people wouldn't know which avatar/sig that was rated because people keep changing their ava/sig. And that is VERY meaningless.

• Give constructive opinion on your rating. "I like Naruto so I give you 10/10" is NOT constructive. "You did a good job on shading" is constructive. "The object (main character) is too much to the left. You should balance it more" is constructive.

• If you already commented the person above's ava/sig, do not post. Wait until someone else post. Rating same person twice for same ava/sig is meaningless. (Alternatively, you can rate the person two posts above yours, I guess...)

If above three conditions are not kept, this thread will be closed again.

IT'S A LION!, next time when you want to create a new thread of a closed thread, make sure to ask mods first. Threads were closed for a reason and if you keep doing that, there's no meaning for us being around. Same apply to everyone; next time when we see this, you'll receive a warning.

Bounty1Berry:
Ava: I don't like the font you used, but rabbit always get extra point, so 9/10.
Sig: Ha ha ha, we can make a lot of jokes from Calipha's soap, can't we? 10/10.

Mine:
Ava: made by e1n.

!
Sig:
Bitch, don't mess with me.
It's ocean, not Ocean. … .__.

[GoAnderson]

Oh… again? Alrighty. Let's try it.

oceanizer

Avatar: As it was made by e1n, the drawing itself is lovely, as is the shading. Penguin-you is for-the-win, and penguin-Pell-you is even more so, so I guess 7.5/10.

Signature: What is there to say? Don't mess with him, bitch. He's fuckin' ocean! Pimp-daddy penguin of the Park, yo! (I have no idea what I'm doing)

My Set

Ava:

Sig:

[ITSALION]

Sorry for the n00bishness, I'm fresh from a different forum. There, when popular threads were closed at the 500 post limit, we would start a second one. Sorry.
GoAnderson
Avi: What can I say? It's nice! 9.9/10
Sig: It's GoAnderson! Very well put-together! Nice links, too. 10/10
Adding set…
Avatar

Sig

[Daisuke CP9]

Its a Lion-
8/10 Lions amuse me XP
10/10 Got to love Ace.

Now my set..Note, GFX credit goes to someone else. Got it from a request.

Ava

Sig

[Duce of Transilvania]

Ok let's see if round 2 will last just as long.

Daisuke, because your avatar and Sig are almost the same i will rate them together. They are preaty good, i don't know the anime, if it is from the a anime. I like how it is made, it's cute and adorable. So i will give it a 8/10.

Avatar, form Wikipedia, the Exterminatus Order of the Imperium.

Sig, Bounty1Berry it is from the Animatrix, i hate that "anime" i thought it was crap, but i always loved that image with the two soldiers praying.

[Ms. Suave Debonair]

Duce 8/10 for the avatar. Looks strange but all the same looks good!

Sig: 6/10 I dunno about that one, something about the purple and orange doesn't look nice and the guy kneeling infront of a tree, dunno…

Avatar:
Sig:

[Sano]

Well for the ava I give it a 9.4/10 because I thought that is very good deatail ink picture of Luffy. For the sig I give it an 9.0/10, since I like the designs for the robots.

Well for my new ava is Clare in her Gatekeeper outfit from Power Rangers Mystic Force.

Ava:

For my sig, it's also Clare from PRMF.

Sig:

[captain sogeking]

Your ava is to plain, it just shows her face and nothing else so I give it a 6

the sig is a little better but you've got a third face in the middle that interrupts the image it gets a 7.

here is my ava:

And the sig

[lxn]

captain sogeking:i dont really like people getting hit but I give it a 7/10 and I love the sig.9/10

here it goes:

avatar:

Signature:

"Dont you dare make my navigator cry"-Luffy kaizoku ai
My_Da_site

[kiksq]

Well lxn ava chibi nami FTW 9.9/10 it is cute

sig well i think bleach is cool so that adds 10 points so 10/10

ava

sig

[Casusby]

kiksq: The avatar is a well looped gif and while it's obvious that you have a Crocodile theme going on, I think the repeated use of the gif in your sig can be a bit distracting. At the very least it reduces the impact of the avatar. I don't really know which you prefer and hold favour over, or wither you'd listen to me. The non-moving part of the signature though looks good, with the clean overlapping and all. I don't like the number rating system, so I'm going to opt out of it.

Oh well, my avatar:

Sig : I'LL SCOPE ARES / CLOSE AS PERIL / LEAR SPEC SILO which makes no sense if you haven't seen Broken Saints.

[Taleran]

I like the new rules since it was kinda stupid 3 people going round in circle

and I haven't seen Broken Saints so N/A on both

Avatar:

Sig:"Ubo-san. Can you hear it? This is…..
....our Requiem to you."

both are from same point in series

EDIT: still looking for a good Hunter X Hunter Sig Pic

[taboo]

Casuby: Avy is cool. It reminds me of something like The Ring (which I can't say I've seen, except through commercials). It's really different, in a good way, so I give it an 8. The sig I don't understand, but it has a sort of mystery to it. Also an 8.

Taleran: Avy seems kinda plain. It's a cool pose, but it seems off-center. 7/10 The sig is simple, but does fit the picture. 7.5/10 ;)

Not changing my av or sig anytime soon, so….

[nguyen]

Avy: 7/10 drool I've gotten used to it. It's kind of boring now but hey! It works!

Siggy: 10/10 Mostly the expresion on usopp's face. It's… Fitting.

My Avy:

My sig:

My DA site Please leave comments to help improve my crappy art.

Sogeclub Because Sogeking deserves it…

Kaizouku Ou Rpg The original

Oda Rpg The sister of KO. Different growth style but just as good.

I need a good sig…

[ITSALION]

nguyen
Avi: Looks good, the picture is in profile, it ain't blurry, it's original…10/10
Sig: Some good links. 6/10
My avi:

My sig:

[Duce of Transilvania]

OMG after ages you don't have a lion avatar, that need's special atention.
I realy like your new one, Shanks is so kick ass, but still the picture is nothing world shattering, so i think in my book it is a 7/10
As for the sig, Norland is nice, but i don't really get/find it funny, the idee with the "It's not a tumour" so i get's 5/10

Ava:

Sig:

[Pepsi]

**Duce of Transilvania

Avatar:** I like it. ^_^ Love the matching colours. 8/10

Signature: Looks really pro. The right planet doesn't fit as good with the background light as the left one, though. 7/10

[ITSALION]

Pepsi!
Avi: nothing extraordinary, but it is a good fit 8/10
Sig: 10/10 for the "f–-ing crow" line! :biggrin:
My avi:

My sig:

[hyakamaru]

Ava: Very nice. The colors are well distributed. 9/10
Sig: Funny, but the white bg is a bit bright for me. 7/10

Avatar:

Signature:

both are made by me.

[Pepsi]

**Hyakamaru

Avatar:** I love those glittery moments. xD
I like the gif. It doesn't get cut off when it repeats, so I will give it a 10/10 for that. ^_^
Signature: :o Love the fading to black, and the white text intop of the red one looks good. You would be able to read it if you could read it, which I can't. xD

[Senshi Mizaka]

So, here's my new avatar. It's drag queen Kon!

[ITSALION]

Avi: Freaky. Freaky. 6/10
Sig: Nice Chopper rap. But I HATE RAP!! Still very creative, though. 7/10
Avi:

Sig:

[Senshi Mizaka]

@IT'S:

Avi: Freaky. Freaky. 6/10

Well, you'd better get used to it! ^_^ Kon's one of my favorite Bleach characters.

[LobStar]

IT'S A LION!

Ava: 8/10 A little small, but a nice image. The R.I.P is very fitting XD
Sig: 7/10 The text is a little… offsetting. I think it's the color. But it's still pretty funny.

Ava:

Sig:

[ITSALION]

Yeah, the text is bright; but I only did that so it could be clearly read.
Lobstar:
Avi: a little sketchy..is that Luffy? 7/10
Sig: OH MY FREAKIN' HECK WOW. Except Luffy looks slightly Jack Skellington-ish. :blink: Nice, though. 9.9/10
My avatar:

My signature:

[Taleran]

Avatar 8/10 (although if shes actually dead or not)
Sig 10/10 (even though it is a copy of a bad Fad its so much better)

I don't plan on changing either of mine anytime soon so i'll refrain from reposting them

[verbatim]

Avatar - 7/10 - Well, I dunno what it is but it looks kinda cool so I'll leave it with that.
Sig - 8/10 - Nice quote of Tom, but grammar is off in some parts.

My avatar:

I got the original image from a DVD cover by my fav skate brand, Zero, and then I photoshopped it a li'l bit.

Siggy:

I did the siggy in photoshop after hours of image-questing for the pics. Btw, here was the original that I made, which looks like total crap.

[myogatheflea]

Avvy - It's hard to tell what you actually photoshopped, honsetly. 4/10
Siggy - The best one on the boards. Period. 10/10

Avatar

I didn't make that avatar, I shottied it from the OP gif thread about two months or so back.

Signature

I saw X3 today, so I was compelled to make this. Plus, that freaking dubover owns. :laugh:

[The_green_samurai_ranger]

ok I'll play,

check out a few of my creations, I just linked them because I don't want to waste space in a post. Plus they a quite big.

Remember RATM _Current Signature:
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/forum%20signatures/9f824195.png

The Legend of Zelda_Twilight Princess Signature:
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/forum%20signatures/c07a8daf.png

One Piece_Worship Nami Signature:
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/forum%20signatures/de441a16.png

Original GSR Signature used on my home forum:
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/forum%20signatures/7ed2e648.png

Yea go ahead and say that they are simple, I know, mainly because I like to keep signatures simple. Personally I give my talent probably a 4 out of 20.

Also I made a few Nintendo Wii related wallpapers, what do you guys think of them? I consider them some of my best photoshop work so far, which isn't saying much actually, but you get the idea.
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/other%20pictures/WiiWallpaper_Version1.png

http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f331/SamuraiStar/other%20pictures/WiiWallpaper_Version2.png

[Taleran]

anything Power Rangers after Mighty Morphin = FAIL 3/10
Rage against the Machine = win 10/10

EDIT: had to remove the 1st verse of sig since sig size is limited

[The_green_samurai_ranger]

@Taleran:

anything Power Rangers after Mighty Morphin = FAIL 3/10
Rage against the Machine = win 10/10

EDIT: had to remove the 1st verse of sig since sig size is limited

What? It's just a bloody nickname that I got from a past forum. Plus the original ranger series sucked major arse.

Also thank you for the RATM comment.

What did you mean aboot the sig edit thing?

[Taleran]

its the theme song from the CN show Freakazoid's Huntsman character and the whole thing was too long so I cut the 1st verse

and Mighty Morphin >>>>> you

[Advent]

Avatar: 1/10
Sig: well, there really is no sig now is there.

[taboo]

Advent: Avy: I can't quite tell what's going on, but I like it. The colors match real nice~! 8/10

Sig: It's ok. Not to extravagant, but the colors are nice. 7/10

Testing a new avy. I really liked my old one but…

[Mr. All Sunday]

7/10 It's a tad creepy.
100/10 Best sig ever;I laughed hard at it for a good while. You should get one with that freaky ass Eneru picture.

[Sanji]

Ava 10/10
Sig 10/10 Best Robin sig I've seen yet.

[Taleran]

@Advent`:

Avatar: 1/10
Sig: well, there really is no sig now is there.

if there was no sig there wouldn't be anything there but there is so yeah

[ITSALION]

Sanji:
Well, since you are Sanji, a Sanji avatar just seems appropriate. Well done! 10/10
Sig: you're supposed to put it in your post.

Very nice. Sanji's Achilles' Heel. 9/10

My Avi:

My Sig:

[The_green_samurai_ranger]

It's a lion, I love the chuch norris/ rob lucci comparison.

I give it a 9/10

[ITSALION]

Well, GSR, I give your well-made avatar a 10/10 and your Rage Against the Machine sig an 8/10
BUT YOU MUST put them in your message.

[The_green_samurai_ranger]

@IT'S:

Well, GSR, I give your well-made avatar a 10/10 and your Rage Against the Machine sig an 8/10
BUT YOU MUST put them in your message.

Check the second page Lion, I posted all of my signatures there.

Thanks though for the good ratings of my current signature and avatar

[ITSALION]

Well it doesn't get any better than your avatar (a well-made GIF with your username in it).