So far all the main strawhats have had Precious people in their lives, Like Shanks was to Luffy, or Zeff to Sanji, my question is
Who is Robin's Precious Person? is it Saul or Oliva?
Precious People
-
-
and why not both of them?
-
Why not include Clover? She only knew Sauro for like a few days. :sleep:
WHY DOES CLOVER NOT GET PRIORITY!1!1! :sleep:
-
how about this: mugiwara pirates -.- .. she did sacrificed herself for them didn't she? :p
-
I am sorry I did not think Clover would be it because the other two have helped robin more than he has.
-
Who says it only has to be one person?
It could be all the archaeologists of Ohara and what about Clover? the person who taught her about being an archaeologist. Saul, Olvia and Clover were all close to Robin in some shape or form.
Clover- The person who she grew up learning about archaeology
Saul-Her close friend for a few days who taught her to laugh again
Olvia- Her mother who left her when she was only a baby, who came back years later, only to be snatched away again by the power of the buster call. -
Okay, that makes since to me.
Thank you for answering my question.
-
Well, Robin is the one with the worst background, so, I would say both Clover, Olvia and Saul.
Old school lurker.
-
I don't see why it can't be all 3 myself, I mean, Nami had pretty much the whole village important to her background so…
-
Nami's was Bellemere, Gen AND Nojiko. but everyone remembered Bellemere more because she gave a memorable sacrifice for her daughters. Robin however, had everyone sacrificing for her. I don't know why but I'm probably gonna remember Saul more than the others. XD
-
Come to think of it, who is Usopp's precious person? His mom or his dad? Kaya? Probably Kaya, I don't think he was old enough to have precious people when his parents left. :hmm: But Kaya didn't sacrifice anything for Usopp, in fact it's probably more likely that Usopp is HER precious person. :laugh: /30% off topic
I'm going to go with Olivia on this one, simply because she was her mother and Robin had no family before hand.
-
Off topic: Ussop's past wasn't sad at all.
All 3 of them are Robin's precious people.
Clover is the oen that taught her I believe.
Olivia is her mother that she had no memory of, andthey just got to know each other.
Saul was her first and only friend.
-
Off topic: Ussop's past wasn't sad at all.
Unless you count watching your mother die and growing up all alone…
  -
Unless you count watching your mother die and growing up all alone…
yeah, little things like that <_<
Riding a Rhino is safer so we Ride a Hippo for Adventure!
~Bobobobo BO-bobo~
PS: I am a big fan of kittens:love:
-
Off topic: Ussop's past wasn't sad at all.
watching your mother die and pretending that people are coming with medicine, which, you know that really, no-one is coming but you do it because you don't want to see your mother die. Sounds pretty damn sad to me.<_<
-
IMO you can´t put one above the others. Everyone of them gave Robin something special that she didn´t get from anyone else.
Clover was her mentor. He passed down his views about the duty that archeologists carry out to her.
Saul gave her the gift of happyness and friendship.
And her mother gave her that what she always wanted to have ever since she left her. Herself.It´s all precious gifts Robin received and I don´t think they should be compared to each other.
BTW, Chopper also has two precious persons with Hiluluk and Kureha. Hiluluk just shines a bit more because he died his tragic death.
-
Lessee…..Luffy-shanks
Usopp-his mother
Nami-Belle-mere, Genzo?
Zoro-Kuina
Sanji-Zeff
Chopper-Hiluluk, Kureha
Robin-Clover, Saul, Olvia'
Franky: tom, Iceburg.I really wrote that out more for myself, but overall the split seems 50-50 in regards to having multiple precious people and not.
Riding a Rhino is safer so we Ride a Hippo for Adventure!
~Bobobobo BO-bobo~
PS: I am a big fan of kittens:love:
-
You mean it wasn't Sanji-Patty, Carne?
-
-
Lessee…..Luffy-shanks
Usopp-his mother
Nami-Belle-mere, Genzo?
Zoro-Kuina
Sanji-Zeff
Chopper-Hiluluk, Kureha
Robin-Clover, Saul, Olvia'
Franky: tom, Iceburg.I really wrote that out more for myself, but overall the split seems 50-50 in regards to having multiple precious people and not.
Just wanted to point out that Usopp's mother is less of his precious person and more of his tragedy. If you think about it, Luffy's trying to model his life after Shanks, Zoro made his resolve because of Kuina, Nami's doing what Bellmelle wanted him to do, Sanji's following Zeff and his dream of all blue, Chopper wants to be a great doctor because of Hiluluk, he just used Kureha to get that knowledge. Usopp's is not his mother. His mother promted nothing but the lying. Usopp's is 100% his father - he wants to become a great pirate warrior, just like what he thinks his father is. I think when the crew meets up with Shanks crew, it'll be a major plot point that maybe Yasopp isn't as great as Usopp thought. I know we've seen him in action in a filler arc, but it IS a filler arc.
I guess all I'm saying is Usopp = Yasopp , even though they really never met.
-
I guess all I'm saying is Usopp = Yasopp , even though they really never met.
I kinda agree. For every 'special person', there was a sacrifice. Shanks-an arm, Zeff-his leg, Bellemere/Hiluluk-their lives… (Kuina died and even though she didn't sacrifice anything, Zoro felt the need to carry out his promise and become the best for the both of them.)
Yasopp sacrificed Usopp himself, and because of that Usopp admires him. Even though he doesn't know his father, he idolizes him. Yasopp would probably be the exact opposite of a 'precious person', or perhaps the manliest of them? If you think about what Yasopp gave up compared to the others, it probably took a hell of alot.
-
I think when the crew meets up with Shanks crew, it'll be a major plot point that maybe Yasopp isn't as great as Usopp thought. I know we've seen him in action in a filler arc, but it IS a filler arc.
I Seriously doubt this. I mean we've got mention of his skill as he was 10 years ago,from Yassop himself. I have little doubt in my mind that Yassop is more than what Ussop expects.
I guess all I'm saying is Usopp = Yasopp , even though they really never met.
Now this, I can agree with.
-
Usopp's precious person is his dad, because it's his role model.
Is Daddy the Father Filler? I never read the Loguetown arc in the manga, only saw the anime, but if it's not, it's stories like the one Daddy told that make Usopp proud to be Yasopp's son.
Luffy has several role models, actually, not just Shanks. Shanks is his main one, because he saved his life, but Gol D. Roger is also a big one in Luffy's life, as well as Ben Beckman, Makino, and possibly even his grandfather.
Zoro doesn't just have Kuina to fall back on. Kuina's father was also a big influence to him (His flashback while fighting Das Bones), and so is Mihawk. Mihawk is the best, and respects Zoro. To anyone, the top ____ telling you to "Strive to surpass me!" is a big motivation.
Robin-chwaan also may respect Kuzan as a role model, somewhat, because Kuzan is semi-protecting her and watching over her. With her mother dead and her father unseen (Except in shilouette in flashbacks), he's essentially her surrogate father.
-
Is Daddy the Father Filler? I never read the Loguetown arc in the manga, only saw the anime, but if it's not, it's stories like the one Daddy told that make Usopp proud to be Yasopp's son.
Yes, it was filler.
-
Yes, it was filler.
But wasn't it also part of a Novel? Which I assume would have been written by Oda himself…
paptschik and the quest for the lost signature…
-
I thought that novel was for dead end adventure? Maybe i'm just confused
-
But wasn't it also part of a Novel? Which I assume would have been written by Oda himself…
But even then it isn´t main plotline manga cannon.
-
But even then it isn´t main plotline manga cannon.
But it's still Oda, isn't it?
I know we don't count WANTED! or Romance Dawn or anything as cannon, but I always considred Daddy the Father somthing Oda just couldn't fit in before chapter 100, but Toei had plenty of time for.
I could be horribly wrong, though.
-
But it's still Oda, isn't it?
You´re right but being from Oda and being manga cannon are two different things.
-
what's a manga cannon? I'm sorry for my ignorance
-
what's a manga cannon? I'm sorry for my ignorance
That's when we load all 41 volumes of OP into a cannon and shoot it into the face of people who ask stupid questions:XD:
No seriously, a "Cannon" is actually a list of published works that you need to understand a culture, and when reffering to a specific series it essentially means "Things that really happened in the story."
-
-
Even if we were to say that the circumstances in the filler were Canon, the Yasopp was a flashback by a extra - All of the circumstances behind it could have been left out. I mean, if you were to cut and paste certain points of Usopp's life, you'd think he was the bravest on the crew. Just because he stood up once to another sharpshooter and won, doesn't mean he's exactly as pictured.
I figure Usopp got his kind feelings from his mother, and the rest from his father. We already know Yasopp's a bit of a bragger, so I'd have to say that he's probably and extreme version of Usopp, just without the drive.
I could be totally wrong. Just voiceing my opinion. -_-
Also, since this is in the Manga board, I just assumed we were already using Manga Canon, that's why I said what I did.
-
I would assume Yasopp is quite powerful and great, considering he's on Shanks' crew, one of the most powerful crews on the Grand Line, and Shanks doesn't seem like one to fall for someone's braggings and tall tales. That's why I think Usopp's final fight of the series will be against Yasopp - not a bitter fight, but a noble match of the snipers.
Also, I could be wrong, but wasn't Daddy the Father sort of a throwaway idea by Oda that he couldn't fit in the manga but Toei decided to go ahead and animate it? I think I read that somewhere, but I could very easily be wrong.
-
To me, everyone's last battle is Obvious: Mugiwara vs. the 4 admirals and Blackbeard's Crew.
Think about it: Everyone has a doppleganger within Blackbeard's Crew, or with the 4 admirals.
Luffy: Blackbeard
Chopper: Doc Q
Zoro: Jesus Burgess
Sanji: Akainu (I'm beginning to think that He's called Red Dog for the same reason Zeff was called Red Leg, not because he ate a Lava Devil Fruit)
Ace: Kuzan (Obviously)
Usopp: Van Auger
Nami: Lafitte (Part of his abilities are apparently stealth and infiltration, as he got into the Seven ARmed Seas meeting without being seen)
Robin: Kizeru (We don't know what his power is, but I have a feeling it's someone Robin has met before, because Oda hasn't revealed him yet, and you know how he is about things like that…)
Franky: Sengoku (Goats eat metal, and there's no one else to pair him with XD)
OP 
