Arlong Park Forums

    • Register
    • Login
    • Search
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Users
    • Groups

    Scales of Justice - a Mafia Game

    Community Games
    13
    269
    37860
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Shuhan
      Shuhan
      last edited by
      Shuhan
      spiral
      Shuhan
      spiral

      I honestly chose not to kill just to cause confusion, the actual strategy came after I decided that. To be honest, I was having so much fun that if we ended up not lynching, I was going to abstain from killing again.

      I was determined to not bloody my hands until the end. Had my Godfather status to uphold you see.

      Huschel kmohyudin Xasy 3 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • Huschel
        Huschel @Shuhan
        @Shuhan last edited by
        Huschel
        spiral
        Huschel
        spiral

        @Shuhan:

        I honestly chose not to kill just to cause confusion, the actual strategy came after I decided that. To be honest, I was having so much fun that if we ended up not lynching, I was going to abstain from killing again.

        I was determined to not bloody my hands until the end. Had my Godfather status to uphold you see.

        I 100% respect that. I also would have hated it a lot. 😛

        Does the tricky trick to use extra spaces to get around the character limit not work anymore or did I forget how to do it?

        How original is it to still have this in my signature 6 years later?

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • Kirbycide
          Kirbycide
          last edited by
          Kirbycide
          spiral
          Kirbycide
          spiral

          It works.

          Huschel 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • Huschel
            Huschel @Kirbycide
            @Kirbycide last edited by
            Huschel
            spiral
            Huschel
            spiral

            @Kirbycide:

            It works.

            I see. It doesn't work they way I want it to when quoting somebody. Never noticed that.

            How original is it to still have this in my signature 6 years later?

            Kirbycide 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • Kirbycide
              Kirbycide @Huschel
              @Huschel last edited by
              Kirbycide
              spiral
              Kirbycide
              spiral
              This post is deleted!
              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • kmohyudin
                kmohyudin
                last edited by
                kmohyudin
                spiral
                kmohyudin
                spiral

                cool

                Will give life altering advice for a cup of frothy cappuccino

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • starlalilymoon
                  starlalilymoon @Kirbycide
                  @Kirbycide last edited by
                  starlalilymoon
                  spiral
                  starlalilymoon
                  spiral

                  Yes, I was a vanilla townie all along. I was reading in the mafia chat of how my little ploy made them think what if I'm really the power role or not? So, guess that sorta worked!

                  Yes, I really did fall for Kitsune's ploy as cop, it's mainly because my first game we had evidence, and I thought why would anyone false claim. Though Kitsune's claim actually made me suspect Shuhan more. I did see that he was really sus of kmo at one point, but then didn't investigate him. I guess I was too gullible. Lesson learned for next time!

                  I actually thought we lost the game when Kitsune got lynched, but he turned out to be mafia! I'm glad lynching myself actually gave people pause! But I still got the wrong person lynched! Well, I get better xD

                  I had a lot of explaining to do with defending Kitsune, but yeah it was just gullible old me. That's why I was like well to prove I'm town I lynch myself, but then I forgot if I lynch myself at MYLO that that could have cost the game. A bad move but it helped sorta prove my innocence, though looking at the graveyard chat, people felt like it was a ploy xD

                  I also learned the importance of being vanilla. I thought it was a pointless role, that's why I hinted at it. (I hinted at it because that's what others did in the last game.) Though when I made the post I didn't realize everyone was vanilla at that point in the game. It's my fault for not reading over the link.

                  Now, I know it was bad to claim, and I should have not. But at least my little trick sorta helped in taunting the mafia to kill me xD

                  I had fun though! It was a learning experience! Though I was a little too hard on myself for falling into Kitsune's trap, sorry about that! ><

                  I guess the first game just threw me off guard and I thought there has to be evidence before you lynch someone. Till Huschel mentioned it doesn't work like that.

                  Also, question for all, is it harder to be mafia or town? I think mafia maybe? As you have to trick people well, and I'm not sure how good I am with that to be honest.

                  @Shuhan:

                  Starla, you did great for your second game! You had me in your sights for most of the game, just gotta have the gut feeling to follow through, even if things get turned around on ya. I was glad to play with ya~

                  Yeah, I had a feeling you were mafia because of Day 2! But then kmo didn't suspected you, so I was like well if he is the power role and trusts you, hence why I went after Huschel. Though you got me too in the end. Well played o:

                  @Huschel:

                  Can't believe we actually had a cop. And a godfather XD

                  Well, I did theorize the mafia probably had a godfather since everyone wanted a cop except kmo who wanted random. Sorry for mislynching you! >.<

                  @Kirbycide:

                  I suspect that playing in my "homebrewed" game for their first time probably confused Starla a little about how everything works… my apologies!

                  Yes, it did! But it's okay! It's a learning game! Now, I know better for next time! :happy:

                  –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                  @kmohyudin:

                  cool

                  By the way, you had killing power? O.o I was confused about your post in the graveyard chat. 0.0

                  I thought cops could only investigate unless we had items around?

                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • kmohyudin
                    kmohyudin @Shuhan
                    @Shuhan last edited by
                    kmohyudin
                    spiral
                    kmohyudin
                    spiral

                    @Foolio:

                    kmo I think that just like the last game we played together, you have really good ideas and leads but you always change your mind or second-guess yourself at the very end!

                    Lol, that's true. It's hard in the moment, you really want to make the right decision, but, there is pressure… I am sure you know.

                    By the way kmo, did you intentionally claim in post #237? Seems counter to what you were trying to accomplish.

                    Yeah, that was a miss, but probably not in the way you might think. I was kinda referencing Huschel's "safe strategy" post which mentioned Cop, so I reflexively did too. I realized later that someone might misinterpret it in the worse way, and I SOOOOOOOOOOOOO wanted to edit that. In the end it didn't really matter, because the game was to end either way.

                    Anyway good stuff, thanks for hosting it Kirby!

                    Indeed, it was awesome!

                    @Kirbycide:

                    The funniest part for me is that each player who kmo investigated in the first couple nights was the same one who the mafia decided to kill. Must have been frustrating not to come back with any additional information, as a power role.

                    YOU HAVE NO IDEA!!

                    @Shuhan:

                    I honestly chose not to kill just to cause confusion, the actual strategy came after I decided that. To be honest, I was having so much fun that if we ended up not lynching, I was going to abstain from killing again.

                    That was a smart move. Me not dying kinda sealed your townie status in my head. Because, I couldn't fathom YOU being a mafia and NOT killing me after Huschel and Starla had both claimed vanilla.

                    –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                    @starlalilymoon:

                    By the way, you had killing power? O.o I was confused about your post in the graveyard chat. 0.0

                    I thought cops could only investigate unless we had items around?

                    I didn't have killing powers. It was just some weird cosmic coincidence that everyone I targeted kept dying, lol. So, I never had anything to report…

                    Will give life altering advice for a cup of frothy cappuccino

                    starlalilymoon 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • starlalilymoon
                      starlalilymoon @kmohyudin
                      @kmohyudin last edited by
                      starlalilymoon
                      spiral
                      starlalilymoon
                      spiral

                      @kmohyudin:

                      I didn't have killing powers. It was just some weird cosmic coincidence that everyone I targeted kept dying, lol. So, I never had anything to report…

                      Oh wait! It's because I didn't die and everyone else you checked died beforehand! Oops XD

                      I guess I had the power of the stars, since you know starla xD

                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • Shuhan
                        Shuhan
                        last edited by
                        Shuhan
                        spiral
                        Shuhan
                        spiral

                        I figured out kmo had the role because of his outburst when Kits claimed cop. I wish I could say it wasn't meta that tipped me of, but kmo gets extremely explosive when he catches someone in a lie, so I played with that in mind…wasn't expecting to actually have a cop tho lol. If it had been a doctor, this game would have vastly different

                        starlalilymoon 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • starlalilymoon
                          starlalilymoon @Shuhan
                          @Shuhan last edited by
                          starlalilymoon
                          spiral
                          starlalilymoon
                          spiral

                          @Shuhan:

                          I figured out kmo had the role because of his outburst when Kits claimed cop. I wish I could say it wasn't meta that tipped me of, but kmo gets extremely explosive when he catches someone in a lie, so I played with that in mind…wasn't expecting to actually have a cop tho lol. If it had been a doctor, this game would have vastly different

                          I didn't know that about kmo. That is very good to know for future games! :ninja:

                          I figured he had the role since it seems he hinted at it somewhat throughout the game. (After I learned that Kitsune was mafia)

                          kmohyudin 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • kmohyudin
                            kmohyudin @starlalilymoon
                            @starlalilymoon last edited by
                            kmohyudin
                            spiral
                            kmohyudin
                            spiral

                            Oh wait! It's because I didn't die and everyone else you checked died beforehand! Oops XD

                            I guess I had the power of the stars, since you know starla xD

                            Nope, you actually had the power of distraction…

                            @Shuhan:

                            I figured out kmo had the role because of his outburst when Kits claimed cop. I wish I could say it wasn't meta that tipped me of, but kmo gets extremely explosive when he catches someone in a lie, so I played with that in mind…wasn't expecting to actually have a cop tho lol. If it had been a doctor, this game would have vastly different

                            @starlalilymoon:

                            I didn't know that about kmo. That is very good to know for future games! :ninja:

                            Whaaaaaaaaat?? I didn't know that about me either!!

                            Will give life altering advice for a cup of frothy cappuccino

                            starlalilymoon 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • starlalilymoon
                              starlalilymoon @kmohyudin
                              @kmohyudin last edited by
                              starlalilymoon
                              spiral
                              starlalilymoon
                              spiral

                              @kmohyudin:

                              Nope, you actually had the power of distraction…

                              Oh yes, true. I do put attractive One Piece characters as my avatar, so makes sense! o:

                              Whaaaaaaaaat?? I didn't know that about me either!!

                              Very interesting. Guess you might catch yourself for future games xD

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • Xasy
                                Xasy @Shuhan
                                @Shuhan last edited by
                                Xasy
                                spiral
                                Xasy
                                spiral

                                @Shuhan:

                                I honestly chose not to kill just to cause confusion, the actual strategy came after I decided that. To be honest, I was having so much fun that if we ended up not lynching, I was going to abstain from killing again.

                                I was determined to not bloody my hands until the end. Had my Godfather status to uphold you see.

                                I was really hoping that was what happened and I applaud you for it. Although it did leave me about 90% sure you were the remaining mafia.

                                That was a fun read. I'm looking forward to joining next time.

                                ———————————————————————————— she/her ————————————————————————————

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • Kitsune Inferno
                                  Kitsune Inferno
                                  last edited by
                                  Kitsune Inferno
                                  spiral
                                  Kitsune Inferno
                                  spiral

                                  I'm a little upset at myself for not being able to come back and try and sell my cop lie, but it looked like it worked for a long time and we would have won. :B I'm glad Shuhan brought it home in the end.

                                  I'm sorry for being so erratic schedule-wise. I had so much fun in the previous game that I thought "ayyy let's do it again", but then my schedule got so busy.

                                  [[Follow me on Twitch!]](http://twitch.tv/kitsuneinferno/)

                                  [[Concerto di Ali: The Battle of Solocima]](showthread.php?t=33896 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 33896") - [[Spirit Wolf]](showthread.php?t=33362 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 33362")

                                  [[D.U.R.I.A.N.]](showthread.php?t=32416 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 32416") - [[Short and Sweet Writing]](showthread.php?t=30536 "Arlong Park Forums - Thread 30536")

                                  starlalilymoon 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • Kirbycide
                                    Kirbycide
                                    last edited by
                                    Kirbycide
                                    spiral
                                    Kirbycide
                                    spiral

                                    No worries, life takes priority, of course!

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • starlalilymoon
                                      starlalilymoon @Kitsune Inferno
                                      @Kitsune Inferno last edited by
                                      starlalilymoon
                                      spiral
                                      starlalilymoon
                                      spiral

                                      @Kitsune:

                                      I'm a little upset at myself for not being able to come back and try and sell my cop lie, but it looked like it worked for a long time and we would have won. :B I'm glad Shuhan brought it home in the end.

                                      Well, you did good! You got me! I actually fell for it really hard! xD blames first game thinking I need evidence

                                      I'm sorry for being so erratic schedule-wise. I had so much fun in the previous game that I thought "ayyy let's do it again", but then my schedule got so busy.
                                      It's okay! I hope you got things figured out in life! If you ever need to talk, shoot me a PM, I'm always here to listen! ^^

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • No swords style best style
                                        No swords style best style
                                        last edited by
                                        No swords style best style
                                        spiral
                                        No swords style best style
                                        spiral

                                        Despite my early expiration, that was still a lot of fun and really interesting following things to the end. Good game guys, and congrats to Shuhan and Kitsune!

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • starlalilymoon
                                          starlalilymoon
                                          last edited by
                                          starlalilymoon
                                          spiral
                                          starlalilymoon
                                          spiral

                                          Yes, I forgot to mention! Congrats to Shuhan and Kitsune! You may have gotten me this time, but next time I will not fall for it! Maybe. :ninja:

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0

                                          • 1
                                          • 2
                                          • 3
                                          • 4
                                          • 5
                                          • 6
                                          • 6 / 6
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          Powered by NodeBB | Contributors