@kmohyudin:
I really want Huschel to explain WHY they suggest you and Kitsune as a possible pairing. I also want to go back and reread Huschel's and Kitsunes exchange with the new information in light.
Alright, let's see. I think the biggest thing for me is Shuhan's vote for Kitsune on Day 2. Basically the whole Town had already decided to no lynch which was clearly the only right choice to make because of mylo and the existence of power roles. But Shuhan thought it necessary to vote for KI. I am saying that he could be almost entirely certain that the day was going to end with a no lynch. So creating distance between himself and Kitsune came at no risk. Now I'll be honest. I think my further reading of Shuhan may have been tainted by this one action. But I also didn't really see him scum hunting all that much. And I know what's coming up in my own post, so let me add this now: I asked Shuhan why he decided not to go for a no lynch on Day 2. He never answered. I did not ignore his explanation.
@starlalilymon:
Huschel was really quick to vote out kev, while I was super hesitant. Would have been great if we didn't vote out kev, it was too risky
Would have sort of sucked if we hadn't voted off the inactive player, actually.
As for me I was hesitant about kev and didn't want to lynch till there was enough evidence:
Your first game was an odd one. You did have all the evidence in the world to vote off people. But that is not the norm and for the most part you can't wait for a report to tell you what to do. There is 'never' enough evidence.
@Shuhan:
Huschel adamant about voting out Kevo rubbed me the wrong way too considering we could have just no lynched and gotten to the night with more townie bodies.
You are allowed to disagree with my reasoning. But it would be really nice if you acknowledged that I have explained (a few times) why I did what I did. Respond to that instead of making the same claims again and again making it seem like I randomly voted for kev. 'We could have just no lynched and gotten to the night with more townie bodies.' kev could have been mafia. Unfortunately, I wasn't privy to that information. Acting like it was 100% confirmed that lynching kev would kill a Townie is results-oriented thinking and misleading.
Here's my latest explanation again.
@Moi:
3. I don't like that literally nobody can see that my eyes are brown, well I mean, in the right light they sorta green maybe my vote on kevo was entirely reaonable [sic]. I literally said in my post that I had forgotten about kevo being in this game. And I cannot make it any clearer that I always, always, always want to lynch inactive players.
Now tell me that you have a differnet opinion on no lynch/lynching inactives. That's fine. And also tell me why you voted for Kitsune on Day 2, please.
That's that for now. I don't think there was really any other question aimed at me. I'll make another post about what happened last night.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@starlalilymoon:
Good luck in DnD! o:
Thanks. It was pretty good. :)
Nobody died. I wasn't expecting that. It's been mentioned, but I am basically thinking out loud here. There's two options: a doctor protected the kill target or the mafia decided not to kill. The night was short so nobody ran out of time.
If there is a doctor who prevented a kill last night, then they would know one confirmed Townie. But, alas, the potential doctor can't know for sure that they protected a Townie. There might have been no kill at all! That's a dilemma.
Why would the mafia decided not to kill?
If the mafia is a Godfather, they might want to no kill and hope for the cop to clear them. In that case, we could just keep no lynching until the cop has cleared everybody. Won't really help us and would be exceedingly tedious. But it would be the safe strategy.
If the mafia is a Ninja, they wouldn't be afraid of the watcher and the tracker. There's a 50% chance that there is one of those roles in the setup that could screw them. The fact that mafia didn't kill sort of makes me think that they aren't a Ninja. But I suppose there's a lso a 50% chance that there isn't :P
If the mafia is a Strongman, they evidently chose not to kill last night.
So…I'm not sure that helped. Maybe somebody else can get something from it though. But I think it is more likely that the mafia decidedly did not want to kill anybody last night. Even purely based on statistics. 25% of a doctor and a sort of 33% chance of targeting the right player.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
@Huschel:
If the mafia is a Ninja, they wouldn't be afraid of the watcher and the tracker. There's a 50% chance that there is one of those roles in the setup that could screw them. The fact that mafia didn't kill sort of makes me think that they aren't a Ninja. But I suppose there's a lso a 50% chance that there isn't :P
This part barely makes any sense, does it? I rewrote it one time too often. It was supposed to be something like this:
If the mafia is a Ninja, they wouldn't be afraid of the watcher and the tracker. There's a 50% chance that there is one of those roles in the setup that could screw them if they AREN'T a ninja. The fact that mafia didn't kill sort of makes me think that they aren't a Ninja. But I suppose there's a lso a 50% chance that there isn't :P