@Robby:
But grow up on a thing and I guess anything can be nostalgic.
Even the DBZ dub which was never good, you're just used to it.
Nothing gets on my nerves more when someone says "X dub sucks!" (usually one piece because well look at the thread your on) "the only good dub is dbz!" when… god pretty much every dub nowadays is leaps and bounds better than it it isn't even funny.
I can understand the nostalgia and there are some genuinely good things about it, but largely it is super unfaithful and cheesy. A lot of their mistranslations have become so iconic that they're the only ones americans accept, and are still used in the otherwise good modern dragon ball dubs. I think often about how made fun of the dude was commentating on the first macys thansgiving parade goku was in because he pronounced "saiyan" wrong... when that was aways how it was pronounced in the original lmao.
Like if you say that without a hint of self awareness or irony I'm honestly just not interested in what you have to say. These same people then proceed to complain about the one piece dub just has "dbz actors" which even the ignoring the ignorance of the industry and generalization of that statement... it literally is not even true. Like I think when people say this they're just referring to like the main cast, but half the straw hats where cast in one piece before dragon ball anyways.
Colleen- both luffy and gohan, was luffy first
sabat- both zoro and... everyone in dragonball. dragonball first
luci- nami and a minor character in the tournament of power i think, obviously nami first
sonny- krillin and usopp, was krillin first
eric- trunks and sanji, was trunks first
brina- chopper and chiaozu, was chopper first
stephanie- robin and from what i can find she voices like one character in a dragonball game
seitz- franky and jiren, was franky like a decade before lol
ian- brook and whis, was brook first.
baugh- jimbei, isnt in a ton of stuff in the first place so nobody in dragonball
Only 3 of the 10 straw hats so far reused someone who played a notable character in dragonball, although 2 others were given one piece and dragonball roles around the same time.
Even if they did have a point here, everyone clearly has more expierence and way better direction in newer dubs, especially one piece. Besides I fail to see why it would even be a bad thing since they hold the dbz dub in such high regard in the first place.