AP Character Popularity Poll

RobZilla

Hey Guys,

As we now know, it's almost time for Shonen Jump's 5th One Piece Character Popularity Poll!

In the spirit of things, we'll be doing our own Arlong Park version too.

So in this thread you can discuss your favourite characters and their respective rankings, as well as submitting your own choices for calculation.

So basically the rules are;

Post your 15 favourite One Piece characters, numbered from 1 to 15 (this isn't Bleach, I'm locking down the number system).
Only use normal naming conventions, please. Any Doula Monga's and the like will not be calculated.
Combos will be accepted, within reason. For example, Abdullah & Jeet.
Characters must be canon (no anime or video game exclusive characters).
No specific forms of characters. ie If you want to pick Sabo, you gotta have all of him, not just the kid version.
The usual stuff concerning no slagging off other people's choices applies.
The above rule doesn't apply to posters with Zoro as their top choice. It's open season on those guys.
Any other rules that occur to me I'll add as this goes along.

Anyway, have at it!

Jabra

Is this just for fun? Or will we submit it in some way or another?

ARTEMlS

So the order of these 15 characters does matter?

Please, please say no… Because there are way too much awesome characters for me to make such a ranking otherwise.

RobZilla

@Jabra:

Is this just for fun? Or will we submit it in some way or another?

Eh, I was planning to just do it for fun and see how far we are from the real poll.

But submitting it in some way would be cool too, for sure.

BarclayBull

This post is deleted!

RobZilla

@Bartholemew:

So the order of these 15 characters does matter?

Please, please say no… Because there are way too much awesome characters for me to make such a ranking otherwise.

Yep.

For me to calculate the most popular characters, I need your favourite characters, in order of preference from 1 to 15.

…just try and push through, Barty!

--- Update From New Post Merge ---

@BarclayBull:

Doula Monga ?

Terrible old translation for Doflamingo that floats around the AP lexicon.

Jabra

Hm, there is already a thread like that in the general section, with a tool even. I did it a while back, took ages. But the results are more or less spot on.

http://forums.arlongpark.net/showthread.php?t=41057

Devil G.

@RobZilla:

Hey Guys,

As we now know, it's almost time for Shonen Jump's 5th One Piece Character Popularity Poll!

In the spirit of things, we'll be doing our own Arlong Park version too.

So in this thread you can discuss your favourite characters and their respective rankings, as well as submitting your own choices for calculation.

So basically the rules are;

Post your 15 favourite One Piece characters, numbered from 1 to 15 (this isn't Bleach, I'm locking down the number system).

Only use normal naming conventions, please. Any Doula Monga's and the like will not be calculated.

Combos will be accepted, within reason. For example, Abdullah & Jeet.

The usual stuff concerning no slagging off other people's choices applies.

The above rule doesn't apply to posters with Zoro as their top choice. It's open season on those guys.

Any other rules that occur to me I'll add as this goes along.

Anyway, have at it!

!
! 'Kay.

I suck at making rankings, but I'll try.

DynamiteShikoku

1. garp (and sengoku if allowed)
2. whitebeard
3. rayleigh
4. dadan (and her gang if allowed)
5. luffy
6. buggy
7. jimbei
8. hannyabal
9. bartolomeo
10. kinemon (and kanjuro if allowed)
11. ceasar clown
12. fujitora
13. kizaru
14. perona
15. redfield - from the game UW RED (if not allowed then kid sabo, if i must choose adult sabo as well then change to franky, i dont like adult sabo)

there must be some names that i forgot but oh well. i wish there is a list of ALL one piece char ever created.

RobZilla

@Jabra:

Hm, there is already a thread like that in the general section, with a tool even. I did it a while back, took ages. But the results are more or less spot on.

http://forums.arlongpark.net/showthread.php?t=41057

That seems a lot more complicated than what I was planning to do, tbh.

I was thinking of a way simpler addition system that just kind of mimics the official popularity polls.

Like you've got all these matches and stuff going on (which is awesome btw) but I think this could be a be different and have some merit.

Especially to compare with the results of the official SJ poll.

Devil G.

Seems different enough to me, I'm fine with this.

Jabra

Yeah, the tool is still useful though.

RobZilla

@DynamiteShikoku:

1. garp (and sengoku if allowed)
2. whitebeard
3. rayleigh
4. dadan (and her gang if allowed)
5. luffy
6. buggy
7. jimbei
8. hannyabal
9. bartolomeo
10. kinemon (and kanjuro if allowed)
11. ceasar clown
12. fujitora
13. kizaru
14. perona
15. redfield - from the game UW RED (if not allowed then kid sabo, if i must choose adult sabo as well then change to franky, i dont like adult sabo)

there must be some names that i forgot but oh well. i wish there is a list of ALL one piece char ever created.

Garp and Sengoku are waaaay separate, as are Kine and Kanjuro.

Dadn is only character of real importance there, her gang can be implicit with her. It'll just go down as Dadan, though.

I updated the rules for no non-canon or partial characters lol things would get out of hand.

–- Update From New Post Merge ---

@Jabra:

Yeah, the tool is still useful though.

Oh absolutely, I'm not trying to step on your toes here, Jabs.

DynamiteShikoku

@RobZilla:

Garp and Sengoku are waaaay separate, as are Kine and Kanjuro.

Dadn is only character of real importance there, her gang can be implicit with her. It'll just go down as Dadan, though.

I updated the rules for no non-canon or partial characters lol things would get out of hand.

no probs. my last char is franky then.

Jabra

1. Jabra
2. Jinbe
3. Crocodile
4. Enel
5. Magellan
6. Robin
7. Bon Kurei
8. Caesar Clown
9. Diamante
10. Apoo
11. Kureha
12. Kumadori
13. Kaku
14. Buggy
15. Franky (would have been 3. if not for last weeks chapter. There goes his post TS clean slate :sad:)

Funny. Pre TS my list would have been full of Straw Hats, pretty much filling rank 4-10.

DynamiteShikoku

ah i forgot bon chan. oh well.

.access timeco.

Ranking, huh? It would be hard for me to identify my 15 top characters, much less in order, but I will try.

Buggy
Doula M… Doflamingo
Kaku
Jabra (actually Jabra and Kaku would be on 3rd, depending on the day I like one or the other more and that's how it goes)
Usopp
Enel
Ivankov
Franky
Brook
Hannyabal
Tonjit
Bon Kurei
Hogback
Crocodile
Kizaru

Wow, not a single woman.

Jabra

@.access:

Wow, not a single woman.

Right??

It's super difficult to find a female character worthy to be considered top 15. Not because there aren't any awesome female characters, it's just that the males dominate too hard.

@Robzilla:

No specific forms of characters. ie If you want to pick Sabo, you gotta have all of him, not just the kid version.

Ahahah

I think [pre-Thriller Bark] Sanji would destroy everything. At least for me.

MetaMario

I have always had trouble making a favorite list, and if I were considering One Piece as of right now, gosh it'd be tough. Let me try…

edit: nope, can't do it. :X

.access timeco.

@Jabra:

Pre TS my list would have been full of Straw Hats, pretty much filling rank 4-10.

I relate to that. Usopp and Brook are still holding their places in my list based on pre TS, but if nothing changes in their current selves I believe Franky will be the only one to remain there in the future.
(EDIT: Well, to be fair, old good Usopp is back in the current arc, so…)

Luffy used to be pretty high in my list, but since Impel Down he is on a free fall.

Wooden_Giraffe

Oh why not
1. Kaku
2. Doflamingo
3. Franky
4. Enel
5. Jaguar D. Saul
6. Kureha
7. Garp
8. Basil Hawkins
9. Monkey D. Garp
10. Bartolomeo
11. Brook
12. Gedatsu
13. Wapol
14. Jinbei
15. Eustass Kidd

Lao G

I'm all in for it!
1. " Heavenly Demon" Donquixote Doflamingo.
2. "The Straw Hat" Monkey D. Luffy
3. Lao G
4. Eustass "Captain" Kidd
5. Señor Pink
6. "Devil's Child" Nico Robin
7. "Cyborg" Franky
8. "Blackbeard" Marshall D. Teach
9. Tonjit
**10.**Kumadori
**11.**Kanjurou (Even though he's been just introduced I love him already!!)
12." Will of the Wisp" Kinemon (Here goes Triple K)
**13.**Bartolomeo "The Cannibal"
**14.**Borsalino "Kizaru"
15."Whitebeard" Edward Newgate

Kishido

Sanji
Bartolomeo
Luffy
Dragon
Zoro
Enel
WhiteBeard
Shanks
Rayleigh
Kuzan
Crocodile
Zeff
DoFlamingo
Kidd
Jinbe

Furisu

1. Buggy
2. Gekko Moriah
3. Scratchmen Apoo
4. Borsalino
5. Monet
6. Caesar Clown
7. Sakazuki
8. Rebecca
9. Franky
10. Chopper
11. Koala
12. Wapol
13. Donquixote Doflamingo
14. Dellinger
15. Suleiman

A Boy and his Kraken

Here you go (Sorry about the format; can't get 'enter' to work for some reason): 1. Kuzan (Aokiji); 2. Brook; 3. Monkey D. Luffy; 4. Roranoa Zoro; 5. Boa Hancock; 6. Buggy; 7. Madam Shyarly/Shirley; 8. Monkey D. Dragon; 9. Silvers Rayliegh; 10. Charlotte Linlin (Big Mom); 11. Donquixote Doflamingo; 12. Violet; 13. Smiley; 14. Daz Bones (Mr. 1); 15. Sanjuan Wolf

Vectorkov

Very difficult after the top 5

1. Robin
2. Dragon
3. Luffy
4. Doflamingo
5. Crocodile
6. Aokiji
7. Zoro
8. Bartolomeo
9. Law
10. Jinbe
11. Rayleigh
12. Sanji
13. Franky
14. Kizaru
15. Kaku

kcity

Pretty crazy that it's even difficult to make a top 15(changes again after I click reply):

1. Chopper
2. Bartolomeo
3. Chimney(and Gonbe if allowed)
4. Luffy
5. Robin
6. Kuma
7. Usopp
8. Zoro
9. Blackbeard
10. Rayleigh
11. Doflamingo
12. Bentham
13. Garp
14. Kuzan/Aokiji
15. Marco

The Franky Tank

Damn you Robzilla, my character thread is having a hard enough time without another character thread to compete with.:blink: I'll post my results later though. I need to think about it, and I need some sleep.

Kondo

Lock on
1. Sogeking
2. Dr. Hiluluk
3. Chopper
4. Bon Kurei
5. Luffy
6. Bartolomeo
7. Saul
8. Buggy
9. Gedatsu
10. Doflamingo
11. Garp
12. Whitebeard
13. Hancock
14. Zoro
15. Kizaru

Penultimate

1. God Usopp
2. Luffy's Mom…

Naw, I'm just kidding. Here's my real list:

1. Usopp
2. Brook
3. Robin
4. Franky
5. Bentham
6. Perona
7. Tashigi
8. Kokoro
9. Vivi
10. Chopper
11. Nami
12. Sanji
13. Foxy
14. Caesar Clown
15. Gekko Moria

MugiMikey

Man, this was hard… but here goes:

1. Monkey D. Luffy
2. Sabo
3. Emporio Ivankov
4. Marshall D. Teach
5. Usopp
6. Roronoa Zoro
7. Trafalgar Law
8. Brook
9. Portgas D. Ace
10. Franky
11. Jimbei
12. Dadan
13. Franky
14. Gekko Moriah
15. Bon Clay

SquallL

1. Nami.

The end.

Black Leg

1. Franky
2. Crocodile
3. Brook
4. Luffy
5. Sanji
6. Bellemere
7. Bartolomeo
8. Tom
9. Zoro
10. Nami
11. Arlong
12. Wiper
13. Usopp
14. Miss Goldenweek
15. Kuma

Man this was pretty difficult, I was tempted to answer Franky for all 15 places. It's weird assortment of characters and there are probably plenty of other characters that could have taken these spots but these are the ones that came to mind to mind when I tried remembering each arc. It's funny to see how far Usopp has fallen on my list, he used to be my favourite but I kind of just fell out of love with the guy.

Rivaille

1. Zoro
2. Sir Crocodile
3. Zephyr-sensei
4. Issho-san
5. Vergo
6. Luffy
7. Robin
8. Law
9. Mihawk
10. Marco
11. Akainu
12. Garp
13. Shiliew
14. Bartoloméo
15. Gladius

D.aelthasaar

Geez I made a mess, will try to sort it while editing

1 - Sanji
2 - Silvers Rayleigh
3 - Shanks
4 - Luffy
5 - Wiper
6 - Ben Beckman
6 - Leo
7 - Trafalgar Law
8 - Gin
9 - Johnny & Yusaku
10 - Cavendish
11 - Crocodile
12 - Mihawk
13 - Franky
14 - Basil Hawkins
15 - Van Auger

Dododo

huh

1. Usopp
2. Luffy
3. Sanji
4. Franky
5. Zoro
6. Smoker
7. Blackbeard
8. Robin
9. Bartolomeo
10. Jinbe
11. Buggy
12. Mr.2 / Bon Kurei
13. Whitebeard
14. Zeff
15. Kizaru

Nolus

1. Captain T-Bone
2. Doberman
3. Garp
4. Kuzan
5. CobyMeppo
6. Sakazuki
7. Tsuru
alright, fine, you get some non-Marines

8. Bellemere (hah, but she was a Marine at some point!)
9. Hercales'n
10. Dalton

Kay, managed to not fill the whole list with Marines.

It was harder than you'd think.

Persian

Oh well… I should do it too. Behold my weird list of fav characters
1. Buggy
2. Usopp
3. Sir Crocodile
4. Smoker
5. Doflamingo
6. Scratchmen Apoo
7. Bartolomeo "The Cannibal"
8. Arlong
9. Jabra
10. Spandam
11. Kumadori
12. Captain Kuro
13. Bentham "Mr. 2"
14. Jewelry Bonney
15. Cavendish

Of course, Buggy is first. I'm the resident crazy Buggy's fangirl after all...

Clessenur

1. Luffy
2. Robin
3. Sanji
4. Ivankov
5. Franky
6. Kureha
7. Bell-mere
8. Sabo
9. Zoro
10. Usopp
11. Crocodile
12. Senor Pink
13. Smoker
14. Monet
15. Hiluluk

Dark-King

Roronoa Zoro.

Usopp.

Franky.

Brook.

Nuff said.

RamistaR

15-Richie
14-Figthing Lion
13-Sea Lion
12-Sphinx
11-Sunny
10-Shiki
9-Kumadori
8-Absalom
7-Pekoms
6-Ace
5-Wiper
4-Jinbe
3-Brook
2-Sanji
1-Luffy

Admiral Issho

1. Jinbe
2. Sanji
3. Bartolomeo
4. Issho
5. Crocodile
6. Franky
7. Usopp
8. Bentham
9. Smoker
10. Jabra
11. Kaku
12. Luffy
13. Moria
14. Garp
15. Hiluluk

zeff redleg

1. Blackbeard
2. Luffy
3. Sanji
4. Jinbe
5. Cavendish
6. Mihawk
7. Garp
8. Crocodile
9. Monet
10. Zeff
11. Shanks
12. Zephyr
13. Marco
14. Zoro
15. Robin

I suppose zephyr is canon

Naochaaa

My top15

1.- Trafalgar Law
2.- Roronoa Zoro
3.- Monkey D. Luffy
4.- Eustass Kid
5.- Nico Robin
6.- Donquixote Doflamingo
7.- Jinbei
8.- Mihawk
9.- Sanji
10.- Kizaru
11.- Shanks
12.- Coby
13.- Crocodile
14.- Bartolomeo
15.- Sabo

REDSUN1914

| 1-
| Whitebeard
|
| 2 | -Kuzan
|
| 3 | -Garp
|
| 4 | -Blackbeard
|
| 5 | -Kizaru
|
| 6 | -Zoro
|
| 7 | -DonFlamingo
|
| 8 | -Akainu
|
| 9 | -Rayleigh
|
| 10 | -Magellan
|
| 11 | -Mr 2
|
| 12-
| Mihawk |
| 13 | -Kuma
|
| 14 | -Crocodile
|
| 15 | -Senor Pink
|

heart_diode

@RobZilla:

Characters must be canon (no anime or video game exclusive characters).

Someday Shuraiya will get a chance :ninja:

This is gonna take me forever, though. I know my favorite characters, just not sure how to rank them.

Trafalgar Law
Sanji
Zoro
Kaku
Rob Lucci
Spandam
Conis
Enel
Robin
Usopp
Eustass Kid
Paulie
Franky
Crocodile
Norland

…I think that's pretty accurate. Maybe switch Spandam and Lucci around depending on how I feel, though. I'm not sure if Kaku is my steady #4, too. Problem is that I love mainly all these characters around the same, so aside from picking a #1 who's not Shuraiya, I got no idea.

A Boy and his Kraken

@Mikey:

Man, this was hard… but here goes:

1. Monkey D. Luffy
2. Sabo
3. Emporio Ivankov
4. Marshall D. Teach
5. Usopp
6. Roronoa Zoro
7. Trafalgar Law
8. Brook
9. Portgas D. Ace
10. Franky
11. Jimbei
12. Dadan
13. Franky
14. Gekko Moriah
15. Bon Clay

Might want to edit that buddy…........unless you like him so much he takes up those 2 spaces.

Trafalgar Zoro

Here goes:

Zoro
Robin
Luffy
Sanji
Bartolomeo
Whitebeard
Law
Brook
Kyros
Kuzan
Norland
Ace
Smoker
Franky
Nami

Darth

15, huh? Well, at least first place is easy.

1. Fleet Admiral Sakazuki "Akainu"
2. Bentham "Mr 2 Bon Kurei"
3. Ex-Chief Warden Magellan
4. Ex-Shichibukai Crocodile
5. Current Chief Warden Hannyabal
6. Straw Hat Pirates Shipwright Franky
7. Marine Captain T-Bone "Ship Cutter"
8. Marine Admiral Borsalino "Kizaru"
9. Marine Admiral Issho "Fujitora"
10. Straw Hat Pirates Musician Brook
11. Ex-Marine Admiral Kuzan "Aokiji"
12. Ex-Marine Vice-Admiral Garp "The Fist"
13. Straw Hat Pirates Cook Sanji
14. CP-9 Agent Kaku
15. Yonkou Marshall D. Teach "Blackbeard"

Damn, the last few were quite difficult.

MrPecans

01.) Usopp
02.) Robin
03.) Blackbeard
04.) Franky
05.) Crocodile
06.) Zoro
07.) Luffy
08.) Chopper
09.) Buggy
10.) Bentham
11.) Kizaru
12.) Magellan
13.) Hiriluk
14.) Arlong
15.) Bart

Shout out to Sanji and Brook, and to Belle-Mere - who were all cut last second.