I'm going to try to make a thread.
Basically, what if a mangaka wrote someone else's series?
For Example: If Oda wrote Bleach then Shikai Zangetsu would be a giant sashimi knife with sushi puns.
If Mangakas wrote another Mangaka's series
-
-
This isn't a horrible idea, except that it requires everyone to know both the manga to get the jokes so it kind of limits the scope to only manga most everyone would know.
Anyway:
If Naruto was written by CLAMP, Naruto and Sasuke would have already worked out their differences in bed by this point.
Edited addendum: Only they'd be all coy about whether or not this is actually gay because either Naruto or Sasuke would be gender ambiguous and they'd refrain from ever saying he or she.Edit: Wait thought of another one:
If One Piece was written by the guy who did Gunslinger Girl, halfway through the series the writer would realize he actually doesn't like pirates very much and therefore would unceremoniously nix one character after another to clear the cast for an all new cast in an all new genre. After a few volumes suddenly One Piece would be a hard-boiled teen romance and only Chopper of the old crew would be left alive.
-
If Hara Yasuhisa (Kingdom) wrote Naruto, the war wouldn't have sucked so bad. Would have been awesome even.
Oh and if Kubo wrote One Piece, we'd be reading, like, chapter 154 now.
-
If Kishi wrote One Piece, Luffy would defeated all his enemies by only talking to them.
-
If Matsuena Syun wrote Naruto, women would have more adequate clothing.
-
If ONE wrote Naruto, Naruto would have complete control over Kyuubi's Chackra from the start, wouldn't give a damn about Konoha despising him, wouldn't want to be Hokage, and would call bullshit on each boring villain monologue (mainly Sasuke's).
-
If Oh!Great wrote Naruto the entire series would be a bunch of over-the-top memorable fights punctuated by insanely long stretches of boring exposition and flashba-… wait a minute.
-
If ONE wrote Naruto, Naruto would have complete control over Kyuubi's Chackra from the start, wouldn't give a damn about Konoha despising him, wouldn't want to be Hokage, and would call bullshit on each boring villain monologue (mainly Sasuke's).
Oh, man, now I want to see this.
-
If Miura wrote HxH we would actually get regular releases after three months.
-
If CLAMP wrote HxH they'd come back from one of the hiatuses and abruptly try to tie up every loose end in the series, leading to an ending that clearly shows they had no idea where they were going when they started it.
-
If Oh!Great wrote Naruto the entire series would be a bunch of over-the-top memorable fights punctuated by insanely long stretches of boring exposition and flashba-… wait a minute.
Remove the "memorable" part and you're onto something.
-
If Oda wrote Naruto, the Kage would be similar to One Piece's Yonkou in terms of strength and significance. And we'd still remember Tenten.
-
If FMA's Arakawa wrote Nardo, the final battle would have the entire ninja alliance contributing in a meaningful way.
-
-
Remove the "memorable" part and you're onto something.
I was trying to figure out which series you were dissing and then I realized you were right on both counts so it didn't matter.
-
If toriyama wrote naruto the final arc would have been simple, with sasuke and naruto constantly powering up and going against a crazy uncontrolled madara. It would conssit only of fighting, but it's the same right now anyway, and it would have ended a long time ago.
To support Viz and SHUEISHAs MANGA Plus service hosting all Jump manga for FREE, WORLDWIDE and day of release, Arlong Park will now support the official release.
Official chapter discussions now start Sundays at Noon, EST.
Please do not post threads when scan sites release their version.
-
If Hiroyuki Takei wrote Naruto, there would be a break from the battle. Everyone would just go to a hot spring to relax and talk a little, before they continue fighting.
Maybe there would even be a coffee break.
-
If Sorachi wrote Berserk, then it would be the same, because Sorachi is Miura
-
If Kubo wrote One Piece, the marines would capture Nami as soon as the Strawhats enter the Grand Line. Then Shanks appears out of nowhere and offers Luffy and the rest of the crew to train them and send them to Ennies Lobby. There Luffy defeats everyone up to admiral rank while Zoro, Usopp and Sanji are useless.
After rescuing Nami, Luffy becomes friend with the marines, he's offered the title of shichibukai and the rest of the series consists of Luffy doing his duty any time the marines are too useless. Every saga is about a yonko or rogue shichibukai invading Marineford and Luffy ultimately defeating it.
The rest of the crew just stay with Shanks training in some island.Wash your hands.
-
If Kubo wrote One Piece, the marines would capture Nami as soon as the Strawhats enter the Grand Line. Then Shanks appears out of nowhere and offers Luffy and the rest of the crew to train them and send them to Ennies Lobby. There Luffy defeats everyone up to admiral rank while Zoro, Usopp and Sanji are useless.
After rescuing Nami, Luffy becomes friend with the marines, he's offered the title of shichibukai and the rest of the series consists of Luffy doing his duty any time the marines are too useless. Every saga is about a yonko or rogue shichibukai invading Marineford and Luffy ultimately defeating it.
The rest of the crew just stay with Shanks training in some island.You're forgetting about Sengoku betraying WG and coming back with an army of fishmen to take over Mariejoia.
-
If Hiro Mashima wrote One Piece… well, you already can make an idea yourselves.
-
If Kubo wrote One Piece, the marines would capture Nami as soon as the Strawhats enter the Grand Line. Then Shanks appears out of nowhere and offers Luffy and the rest of the crew to train them and send them to Ennies Lobby. There Luffy defeats everyone up to admiral rank while Zoro, Usopp and Sanji are useless.
After rescuing Nami, Luffy becomes friend with the marines, he's offered the title of shichibukai and the rest of the series consists of Luffy doing his duty any time the marines are too useless. Every saga is about a yonko or rogue shichibukai invading Marineford and Luffy ultimately defeating it.
The rest of the crew just stay with Shanks training in some island.You're forgetting about Sengoku betraying WG and coming back with an army of fishmen to take over Mariejoia.
Not going to lie to you…this actually sounds interesting
-
if Kishi wrote One Piece all characters would be as weak as the weakling trio except Luffy and Blackbeard
-
If Oda wrote Attack on Titan, nobody would die, instead surviving countless lethal blows etc.
-
@The:
If Oda wrote Attack on Titan, nobody would die, instead surviving countless lethal blows etc.
There probably wouldn't even be fighting, giants would be friendly.
-
C'mon guys, let's not most of the replys be about Oda, Mashima, Kubo, or Kishi. Let's see…
Got it! If Rumiko Takahashi wrote One Piece, the Luffy harem would be an actuality. Every island, some girl would fall for Luffy, naturally Nami, Robin, and Hancock would be the front runners. Luffy would be unable to pick (or too dumb to notice)
Zoro would double as Luffy's direction-challenged rival that would be tsundere for Nami but would later settle for Vivi.
Oh, and Brook would steal panties and teach kung fu.
EDIT: I'm bored today.
-
Yeah I think Naruto & Bleach should've been the only two exclusions of this thread.
I've often wondered about that myself; seems like being supported by people who only want you there so the world can end in fire (with you going to Hell in the process) would be somewhat off-putting
3DS Friend Code 0044-2806-5284
-
Yeah I think Naruto & Bleach should've been the only two exclusions of this thread.
Yeah, but at least with OP, Naruto and Bleach, you know most people have read it. If you include some other, less popular authors and titles, there could be potential spoilers.
-
If anyone else wrote Hunter X Hunter there would be good background art and it wouldn't be on hiatus
Steam Friend Code ---> 48796480
-
If Gantz's creator wrote One Piece we would get chapters like Gantz 265 but with Robin instead.
-
If anyone else wrote Hunter X Hunter there would be good background art and it wouldn't be on hiatus
Not if it was Kubo
[And if the band you're in starts playing different tunes
I'll see you on the dark side of the moon] -
Kubo and Togashi dream team.
Kubo handles the backgrounds, Scribbly Togashi handles the character art.
-
-
Yeah, but at least with OP, Naruto and Bleach, you know most people have read it. If you include some other, less popular authors and titles, there could be potential spoilers.
Don't most of the people who shit on Naruto & Bleach simply not read it?
-
Don't most of the people who shit on Naruto & Bleach simply not read it?
Not here in AP.
At least not in this section.
We read what we diss.
-
If Togashi wrote One Piece he would be hooked on Disgaea instead of Dragon Quest.
If Naoko Takeuchi wrote Naruto, Kakashi would always be eating bread while arriving late and he would knock into Gai.
-
If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles. - _Sun Tzu, The Art Of War
-
C'mo
Got it! If Rumiko Takahashi wrote One Piece, the Luffy harem would be an actuality. Every island, some girl would fall for Luffy, naturally Nami, Robin, and Hancock would be the front runners. Luffy would be unable to pick (or too dumb to notice)If One Piece was written by her it'll have ended after the same time it originally did (whenever that happens) but the ending wouldn't even be a real one because none of the main plots got any closure and it'd only count as an ending because it's the last chapter. Ala Urusei Yatsura, Ranma 1/2, and Inuyasha's endings.
But it'd be a fun ride even though it'd be unsatisfying.
-
If Oda wrote Fairy Tail….
I'd still be reading it right now.
-
Shitting on it without being up to date would be just bias without any arguments to back it up. Nothing one should strive to achieve in a discussion.
We here at AP strive to be the very best in quantifying how large is and what inherent qualities there are in a big pile of shit.
-
If Kenta Shinohara wrote Gintama it would play out in high school instead of the edo period… wait a moment...!
-
If Togashi wrote in the Death Note, then no one would die.
-
If Shimabukuro wrote One Piece the New World would've been reached within 250 chapters, and the fans would be wondering when Luffy would get an infusion of personality
-
If Hiroki Endo wrote One Piece, all the magic powers would be explained scientifically and most of the Straw Hats would have died by the end. So would most of the members of all the other major groups in the series.
-
If Toriyama wrote One Piece Crocodile would be both a thousand times stronger than Arlong and a million times weaker than Enel.
-
If Kiyohiko Azuma wrote One Piece, it would be about tourism instead piracy and the Strawhats would be all teenage girls. The humor and craziness would be the same, though.
If Tsugumi Ohba wrote One Piece, Luffy would be a chessmaster manipulating psychologically his crew (through their tragic pasts) to become the Pirate King. Or Blackbeard would be the main character.
-
If Suzuki Nakaba wrote One Piece ,Luffy would have started his journey already knowing Haki , Gear 2 and Gear 3.After that he would simply develop his Strenght so each of his punches can at least destroy 5 islands with each swing.
If Matsui Yuusei wrote One Piece , Luffy and Blackbeard would be the most sadistic people on the world just torturing and killing people both psyhcially and emotionally. -
-
If Ryuhei Tamura wrote One Piece, it would be a comedy/adventure manga then after about 200 or so chapters it would become a cliched drama/fighting manga with characters being forgotten and characters being hyped as powerful with their powers being shown off-panel with nothing but stereotypical pirate cliches and attacks with readers begging for a return to its original genre.
-
If Bleach guy wrote Shaman King, when they put around the vote to see if people wanted to see the last volume everyone would have voted no and it would have forever been a cliffhanger.
