One Piece Mafia: Part III
-
Merry Christmas, everyone.
-
Same to you Boggy, on that note anyone wanna host a game~
-
Merry Christmas!
-
Happy holidays amici.
And I'd love to make another game, but I won't have time for that anytime soon…--- Update From New Post Merge ---
btw trapped i'm confused, who is that man, that's not hugh laurie
-
Why, is't not Signior Benedick, loved of all ladies?
!
I remember signing up for something a while ago. Maybe I died…
-
Happy New Year to all.
-
Happy New Year! :D Someone less lazy than me should make a game. I'll most likely play.
-
Happy New Year. Hopefully we can fit a Mafia game in this one.
I was reading through the old Mafia games and…I have the most inconsistent playstyle. Sometimes I know how the hell to play, and then sometimes I turn into a buffoon of a person (When I was Monet, the 1322 incident). -
Yeah you've definitely had some great moments in mafia games before :) I think I remember remarking on you holding your own well in past games.
Ahhh, the 1322 incident… Oh gosh XD
-
I remember being totally thrown for a loop when I found out Monet was you. Very well played that game. Too bad the entire mafia got away with lurking that game.
-
I still remember busting a well-played serial killer Woody <3 hehe
And getting my own make-out room with Kitty in the same game
-
You would have died so early in that game if not for the broken town protect.
-
Nearly three months of nothin'. Anything happening soon?
-
1. Foolio
2. Mrs. Iceburg
3. Shuhan
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.Game starts Friday regardless of player count.
-
I'm always up for a game.
-
As am I! Count me in.
-
sneaks in
I'll join
sneaks out
-
The Spirit of Mafia
3 Players
Standard Mafia rules and voting system applies.
Townie 1 is told who is mafia. Townie 2 is told who is mafia. One of these two were lied to. Mafia told nothing.Bonus Round
If mafia is lynched, one of the two town randomly becomes mafia. Ex-mafia is now confirmed town. Final showdown.If mafia is lynched again, Spirit of Town wins. Player who was never mafia wins.
If town is lynched even once, Spirit of Mafia wins. Player who was mafia at the time wins.
Can you destroy the Spirit of Mafia?LYNCH STATUS: It takes 2 votes to lynch.
Not Voting [3]: Mrs. Iceburg, Shuhan1288, FoolioYou have 1000 hours to lynch.
-
Hoo hoo hoo!
Okay guys, on three…
-
e_e
-
!! Can I join ?
-
!! Can I join ?
Well, you're too late for this one. But you can definitely join the next one!
-
Come on guys, let's play!
I'll start. My PM said Foolio is the Mafia!
-
I was kind of hoping Shuhan would show up so I could see him react to the fact that my PM singled him out… plus a 3-person game is plain enough, let alone playing it without someone. I mean how do you set up something that small and STILL get a lurker? XD
I'm going on vacation in just under a week so we better kill someone by then XD.
-
I'm sure that was exactly what you were waiting for.
And the lurking's no biggie at this point, because we know what he would say if he were here. He'd say: "My PM said Mrs. Iceburg is the Mafia!"Well, glad you could make it Shuhan. Let's see what we can do with your statement.
Assuming you're Town, you're the misled one. Making me the correctly informed one, making Foolio the Mafia.
Assuming you're Mafia, I'm the misled one, making Foolio the correctly informed one, making you the Mafia.So hey. What do these two scenarios have in common.
-
The thing is, it's always going to come down to one person's word against another. All three of us can make similar deductions, but they all make the assumption that we ourselves are town. That's why reactions are the only thing we really have to go off of, and why I thought it was so important.
What I find interesting is your taking for granted that Shuhan will claim his PM named you. The way I see it, the only way that's guaranteed is if you're scum. Mine says Shuhan (false), his says you (true), yours says me (made up). This is the only scenario where it's a given. But if Shuhan is the scum, on the other hand, he could point at whoever he wanted. Claiming you would create the circular chain you described.
But he could also claim me. In that scenario, I'd be cleared automatically by having two people say the same thing (wouldn't that be awesome), but as for which of you two was scum, there'd be no way for me to tell. Obviously I presented this theoretical assuming Shuhan was scum, but of course it works if you are too, and you just made up your claim on me. Same end scenario. That's wishful thinking though, methinks, because I doubt Scumhan would want to leave the decision up to me.
So basically regardless of what Shuhan says, he could still be scum, AND you could still be scum.
-
This post is deleted!
-
I deleted your post benjammin. If you're not playing, you're absolutely not allowed to talk about an ongoing game.
-
Of course, we don't have anything to go on other than our words.
And of course I take that for granted. I'm not saying his PM says I'm Mafia, I'm saying that's what he's going to say. The reason that I'm sure about that, is because I know I'm not lying. And in my defense: I was the first person to come forward with what my PM said.
Now, the other option for Shuhan would be to say his PM named you (Foolio). (He can't say his PM named himself obvs). He could name you to make it look like I was lying.
However, that would imply the following scenario:Mrs. Iceburg is Mafia.
Foolio is Town, who was incorrectly informed that Shuhan is the Mafia.
Shuhan is Town, who was incorrectly informed that Foolio is the Mafia.Do you see what I'm getting at there.
So, Shuhan has no option other than to say I was named in his PM. Which will either be true or false. So it's you versus him here.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Okay obviously it's been you vs him for me from the start :p. I'm also assuming everything based on the fact that I know I'm Town.
But the above theory still stands... -
Yeah, I see what you're getting at, but I sort of wish you hadn't said that XD. I figure the more possibilities/scenarios the better right now, because townies don't have to worry about anything other than what our PM actually said whereas scum has to make a decision. Once all 3 of us have put that information forth, it's sort of locked.
Well, not quite. Townies can still lie about PM contents. But that seems like quite a gamble. So the question to Shuhan is, do ya feel lucky, potential scum?
-
Yeah I know, sorry. But it just seemed counterproductive, especially since Shuhan isn't showing.
Your reaction to my post seems pretty genuine, but the suspicion towards me you mentioned earlier seems to have melted like ice in the sun. What's up with that?
-
The suspicion I was casting on you was part of my argument thread that was entirely contingent upon Shuhan naming me being a valid scenario (wow that is a mouthful). The same one you destroyed by pointing out that if Shuhan were scum and he did name me, it would spell his immediate doom. So I mean, your assumption that he's going to name you sounds pretty solid now, given your previous post… though it still doesn't consider the possibility I mentioned where you or I are lying about who our PM named.
That's not to say I don't suspect you, though. Just not for what I said earlier. That said, a mafia being the first claim would also be immensely ballsy.
-
You have 1000 hours to lynch.
Hah.
-Bogart logs onto IRC
-Shuhan is not there
-Bogart fixes a "typo" in his opening post.In all honesty, after this Friday I'm going to be on vacation for 2 weeks, and the thought of a 3-person game dragging for a month is cringe-worthy.
-
LYNCH STATUS: It takes 2 votes to lynch. Mrs. Iceburg [[COLOR=#ff0000]2]: Shuhan1288, Foolio ****Not Voting: Mrs. Iceburg
Lynch has been achieved.
Mrs. Iceburg, the Townie, has been lynched.
Game Over. Mafia Wins.****
-
head desks sorry guys, completely forgot about this game and really haven't been on the site in a while.
PM said Mrs Iceburg is Mafia. gimmie a sec to read over the thread…shouldn't be too long
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
At this point, I am leaning more towards what my PM said is true.
Also, if we want to be ballsy,
Vote Lynch: Mrs. Iceburg
Scum/Townie, your move.
-
Vote Lynch: Mrs. Iceburg
I'm now expecting some plot twist because that was too easy.
-
can we at least confirm this saying yu are scum then?
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
just gonna twirl...gonna twilr...gonna twirl...
-
Well I think if the game isn't over then I'm pretty screwed regardless. So sure I'll confirm it, as if it wasn't obvious. <_<
-
well, what else is new…I manage to screw up spectacularly as per usual.
I'm nothing if not consistant...
-
Aw don't feel bad!
Though to be honest in retrospect it would have been fun to put my vote on you instead of ending the game immediately. I would've easily gotten Icy-chan to vote for you too, given that common sense says if I were scum I'd have ended the game the way I did in actuality. So she'd vote you thinking the town was victorious… only to face bitter defeat.
Ahhh if only I'd thought of it earlier.
-
If nothing else, Ben, this game is a perfect microcosm of pretty much all my mafia games. Study it well.
-
Bogart's avatar fascinates me so much that I stayed in the thread an extra few minutes just to stare at it and now I have this strange and probably misplaced urge to offer myself up for a game.
-
Well hell Foolio, I was totally going to vote for you. That was not fun >:c.
-
If you wanna sign up again, please bring a friend. We shouldn't start another one until we get at least fifteen people.
! 1. Kaitouu
2. Sky
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11. -
How experienced people are here because I am very rusty at Mafia.
And wait…you guys put all your Mafia games into one?
In my 5 years of playing Mafia, this is a first for me.
EDIT: Nevermind...I guess Mafia is dead here, just like any other forum. Sad.
-
How experienced people are here because I am very rusty at Mafia.
And wait…you guys put all your Mafia games into one?
In my 5 years of playing Mafia, this is a first for me.
EDIT: Nevermind...I guess Mafia is dead here, just like any other forum. Sad.
It's not really dead, it's just that we don't have any friends…
-
@Kaitouu
I have play around 18 Mafia games, and I am still crummy.
I would play another Mafia, certainly, but I can only access internet for about an hour or two a day.
Mafia may be dead, but there are still many people who enjoy playing. -
It's understandable.
I'm in for any future games. -
C-could I sign up for a future game?
-
Skyyyyyyyyy hiiiiiiiiii!!!!