I vote on 19, 37 and 49!
Vote your favorite ideas for bonus manga sketches!
-
I vote on 19, 37 and 49!
-
89. Beverages
91. Chess pieces
104. What if Luffy never wanted to be a pirate? -
92-evil.
50-pretending.
5-marines. -
13-Cavemen
32-Astronauts
99-Marvel/DC Heroes -
23-election, 48-school teachers and 135-Blackbeard's Davy
-
13, 60 89
16charactersoflazypost -
5. Marines, because Robin's outfit during the G8 filler arc was classy and I want to see Luffy impersonating Garp - with a Monkey head, of course.
59. Mechas; this should be obvious.
130. Magical girls, because I want to see Beri beams, Gumo Gumo love spells and Zoro's magical swordwand of love and bloodshed. The fun one can have with such a crossover…I'd love to have a metal/punk version of the Strawhats, but it would be without a chance against this competition anyway.
-
28
84
108Oh yeah. I like those with eights in them.
-
5 - Just for Luffy impersonating Garp or some other marine, or in general how the crew would look like as marines.
30 - Would be interesting to see with the animal themes.
129 - Could be pretty cool. -
I like:
91. Chess strawhats
58. Mad scientists
94. Bone time -
49 and 129 are the same thing aren't they? I'd like to see that so. And 63 for the everyone as Chopper. Third choice will be for the Hardcore Gamers one (78)
Damn. I was gonna suggest everyone in regular jobs that is pretty much your scope as a child (Butcher, Baker, Policeman, Mechanic etc)
-
1
129
91ljkidsmlkjsiongb mo8ruho mvydstg nyvk ugtviousevg fbofvg notktgegu rirbtuotrudhuubbrubwsurfseryivawuirvuwyrviuvhfshdifhiuwvriv
-
49 and 129 are the same thing aren't they? I'd like to see that so. And 63 for the everyone as Chopper. Third choice will be for the Hardcore Gamers one (78)
Damn. I was gonna suggest everyone in regular jobs that is pretty much your scope as a child (Butcher, Baker, Policeman, Mechanic etc)
I pointed out the differences on previous page, 49 is specific to old school style, 129 is open to gerneral and modern RGPs
-
I pointed out the differences on previous page, 49 is specific to old school style, 129 is open to gerneral and modern RGPs
Wouldn't it be better to merge those 2 ideas into one? Considering that the options are so broad, its not too good if votes are divided between the same "genre"/"general idea" just because one is old school and the other is wide open. Though that`s only my opinion.
-
I pointed out the differences on previous page, 49 is specific to old school style, 129 is open to gerneral and modern RGPs
THere's really no difference. Especially since this is up to Oda's interpretation, and you can bet that either way it'd be a parody of dragon quest. The only case you could make for them being different is if you count stuff like skyrim, but those are all wrpgs that really don't have a huge following in Japan
-
About 49 and 129: the difference is a logical one and obvious, which is category/case. Katzztar pointed it with great detail. If I would merge both ideas into one related to RGP old school fashion, someone could complain against a decision that rules out RGP new school fashion. There is no way to satisfy all interpretations, so better to copy/paste both ideas and to let community rule.
-
About 49 and 129: the difference is a logical one and obvious, which is category/case. Katzztar pointed it with great detail. If I would merge both ideas into one related to RGP old school fashion, someone could complain against a decision that rules out RGP new school fashion. There is no way to satisfy all interpretations, so better to copy/paste both ideas and to let community rule.
Thank you,
Just in case someone wants to argue more on this, I went surfign to see if there was a better way to explain it. I mean people are able to see the difference between=
2= Cowboys (all be cowboys)
11=Cowboys/pioneers and Indians (Crew has more varity of roles)
71= Native Americans (all be NA and since doesn't include Cowboys can be fore Europeans came)Those differnces are easy to see so no one is arguing over it, but some are still confused why
49= old school RGP & 129= fantasy RGP are different.
After surfign, I'm kicking myself for forgetting a BIG difference. If I said this before, maybe it owuld have cleared things up.One big difference is that 49 includes the table top and live versions of RGP, when most people think of RGPs they think of the massive player games now online. Though there ARE comp games that are old school, it generally does NOT include the mass players.
SHs Old school RGP would have them gathering together, either arould a table or dressing up and acting out the roles (this is what I reffered to before when mentioned about playing DnD). OR they could playing some old comp games…but the games would be single player. This would still have them as old school RGP characters....esp if they dress up LOL
-
I think of the two top choices, the Elections would be more unique and gets my vote. (23)
I also vote for my own idea of Manga Artists/Editors. (81)
-
Thank you,
Just in case someone wants to argue more on this, I went surfign to see if there was a better way to explain it. I mean people are able to see the difference between=
2= Cowboys (all be cowboys)
11=Cowboys/pioneers and Indians (Crew has more varity of roles)
71= Native Americans (all be NA and since doesn't include Cowboys can be fore Europeans came)Those differnces are easy to see so no one is arguing over it, but some are still confused why
49= old school RGP & 129= fantasy RGP are different.
After surfign, I'm kicking myself for forgetting a BIG difference. If I said this before, maybe it owuld have cleared things up.One big difference is that 49 includes the table top and live versions of RGP, when most people think of RGPs they think of the massive player games now online. Though there ARE comp games that are old school, it generally does NOT include the mass players.
SHs Old school RGP would have them gathering together, either arould a table or dressing up and acting out the roles (this is what I reffered to before when mentioned about playing DnD). OR they could playing some old comp games…but the games would be single player. This would still have them as old school RGP characters....esp if they dress up LOL
Did tabletop rpgs ever take off in Japan? Regardless though, I doubt thats what Oda would think of. I feel like people here are also looking from too much of a western lens. I guarantee you that if you say either of those things, it'll end up being a Dragon Quest parody. Simply because in Japan, DQ is THE roleplaying game franchise. Especially since it would be familiar to the readerbase.
-
It was really hard, there are too much funny ideas but I'm voting for 23, 115, 119.
-
Once again, why haven't you removed the options that were already done before? I pointed them all out, so you can't use ignorance as an excuse
-
Once again, why haven't you removed the options that were already done before? I pointed them all out, so you can't use ignorance as an excuse
Thanks a lot for providing me that link. I didnt know there was a page about Omakes in wikia. I had a look at it, and I realized it is a lot of matterial to read. I didn't have the time to read before poll's death-line.
Although, I think the poll has just worked! Please correct me if I'm wrong: there are no already done options in the top 11 (more than 3 votes). So we would be able to have a clear choice in 90 minutes when poll will be closed.
Now, I would appreciate it so much if someone can provide the url of options already done and proposed in the list.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Poll closed. Results in some minutes.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
69 ideas didn't get a vote.
So, top 3 ideas:
| 5. Marines, |
| 23. Election Time. Each of The Strawhats run for President of the Grand Line and outline their policies. Nami will raise taxes, Usopp will lie about his opponents, Sanji and Brook will be involved in scandals… |
| 129. fantasy RPG charactersCCC will translate those ones. I will ask him about the possibility to translate ideas with 6 or more votes. |
-
Hell, I'll send as many ideas as you guys want (well, not 136 of them, but…).
This isn't my feeble attempt to beat out millions of Japanese schoolchildren at their own game. It's _ours_. -
Thanks a lot CCC.
Maybe Mods could change the title of this tread to: If you were Oda, what would you do for next omake?
-
Whoo, one of my ideas (Marines) got in.
When are you sending this out by CCC?
-
2 of the top three were ones I wanted, so I'm happy. If we want more ideas, why not make a 2nd poll exempting ones with no votes or that are definitely in (like the top 3)?
-
I`m loving this ammount of input and ideas.
There being a possibility to send a higher number of them to ODA is definitely a + because of the great number of ideas out there which would be put to waste if they
re ditched. Ukimix
s proposal of translating the ones that go over a certain treshold of votes is great, and if CCC helps then everything is magnificent.YOU GUYS ROCK!!!!!
-
When are you sending this out by CCC?
Could do it as soon as tomorrow, but if we want to do a second poll or something, I see no harm in waiting a bit longer.
-
second poll please! maybe collect all the popular choices and we can discuss realistically the chances of certain ideas to work in a jap/OP context
-
About second poll, I have no time for organize it. But I can participate and to offer some support to the organizer.
I think it would be better to discuss possible developments for certain well defined features or problems, than discuss any kind of possible development for OP. I mean, think about this two topics:
- What would you do for next Omake?
- What would be interesting plot developments for One Piece?
The first one is much more precise and promotes more discussion than the second one, which is wild open and doesn’t call common interests easily. Some more specific topics could be chapter covers, or argument for a movie.
There could be contests to select the best idea. In such a case the selection method has to be well defined. In this occasion we have two threads: the first one to recruit ideas, the second one to vote recruited ideas. But you can notice that we have much more participation in the first one: in 54 hours recruiting thread reached 124 posts / in 74 hours voting thread reached just 71 posts. So we had more people proposing ideas than people voting ideas. Maybe ppl likes much more to discuss topics or to create their own ideas than to vote others ideas. Anyway, selection method should have to be designed in a way that makes the most of all that potential showed by users in the first thread.
Those are some thoughts to help eventual organizer to create a good discussion topic. ;-)
-
The Marines and RPG one seem to be the ideal. They have the most votes, but the other one they're tied with probably won't work out. The Strawhats running for president would be too confusing in such a limited space, there's no easy way to get any of their campaign platforms across without adding walls of text.
-
the marines idea is great. i also hope he will include the position/title for each straw hats. vice admiral luffy sounds cool.
-
The Strawhats running for president would be too confusing in such a limited space, there's no easy way to get any of their campaign platforms across without adding walls of text.
I don't think it'd be 9 fully detailed manifestos for each of the Strawhats, i think it'd more along the lines of what they stand for in one gag or a debate with all 9 at podiums :D
-
Y'all misunderstood my Supernova idea…
[/sighs]
Oh well…
23 and 129 both look rather amusing out of the top three X'D -
1. Hattori (the only thing we'd know we were responsible for.)
31. Shichibukai.
81. Manga artists and editorsNia should put together a montage image of all the OP toris she has. I did a rough count the other day. Not counting outside works there's nearly 400 of them, she could do a 20x20 grid!
-
@RobbyBevard:
the OP toris
What are those??
-
-
1, 17, 61 Pokemon strawhats :D
-
Can we get a rough tally of all votes?…I'm losing track of who is voting which. :S
-
Can we get a rough tally of all votes?…I'm losing track of who is voting which. :S
The voting was over last sunday. Please read the first post of this thread; there you will find final results. At the moment, CCC is traslating top ideas.
-
Okay, here's a translation of the letter:
Oda sensei,
As a representative of a certain group of international One Piece fans on the internet, I am sending you some of the ideas for the omake manga that were chosen by all of us. The members of our group are from a number of countries all around the world, and with English as a common language, we discuss One Piece to death. I'm sorry for the long introduction, but here are our ideas:
1. RPG Time (If the crew were fantasy characters like in DQ)
2. Election Time (Let's choose the president of the New World! If the crew were all politicians)
3. Kaigun Time (If the crew were marines)
4. Mecha Time (If the crew were giant robots)
5. Hato Time (If the crew were…. pigeons!?)
6. Magical Girl Time (...hmm. Right.)
7. Chess Time (If the crew were chess pieces)
8. Kubukai Time (If the crew were like the Shichibukai with animal themes)If you were to end up using one of our ideas, I'm sure we would all go insane with happiness.
Please treat us favorably!
P.N. 久々太郎
-
Thanks CCC for writing the letter, i really hope one of these gets chosen, preferably chess time.
-
@CCC:
Okay, here's a translation of the letter:
Oda sensei,
As a representative of a certain group of international One Piece fans on the internet, I am sending you some of the ideas for the omake manga that were chosen by all of us. The members of our group are from a number of countries all around the world, and with English as a common language, we discuss One Piece to death. I'm sorry for the long introduction, but here are our ideas:
1. RPG Time (If the crew were fantasy characters like in DQ)
2. Election Time (Let's choose the president of the New World! If the crew were all politicians)
3. Kaigun Time (If the crew were marines)
4. Mecha Time (If the crew were giant robots)
5. Hato Time (If the crew were…. pigeons!?)
6. Magical Girl Time (...hmm. Right.)
7. Chess Time (If the crew were chess pieces)
8. Kubukai Time (If the crew were like the Shichibukai with animal themes)If you were to end up using one of our ideas, I'm sure we would all go insane with happiness.
Please treat us favorably!
P.N. 久々太郎
With out your help and work this couldn't be possible. thanks a lot CCC
-
Thanks for the translation CCC!
-
Thank you as always, CCC!! :D
-
Aw, no Shojo Time. Oh, well…
Great job with the letter, CCC.
-
This Omake will be translated next to the regular chapter releases, right? I won't miss it if I read them weekly as usual?
-
This Omake will be translated next to the regular chapter releases, right? I won't miss it if I read them weekly as usual?
You would miss it. It will be out in one of current logs. Chapter 684, requests again for ideas. Read mangastream version of the cover.
-
You would miss it. It will be out in one of current logs. Chapter 684, requests again for ideas. Read mangastream version of the cover.
Ok, so where could I find it once it's published? Will someone put up scans if Oda picks our idea?
-
Letter sent out yesterday, btw. Now we wait.