Apples and oranges, which unsimilar thing is better??

Robby

This is a weird thread idea I've had for a while, it probably won't work out, but…

Take two things that are sort of similar, but so different that they normally wouldn't invite comparison, and compare them, to try and determine which is better.

For example, compare Cats Don't Dance with Big 0.

One is a western animated movie, one is an anime. One has Scott Bakula as a tapdancing musical cat, the other has Steven Blum as a psuedo-Bruce Wayne that pilots a giant robot. One has a an evil version of Shirley Temple, the other has a girl with a cd drive in her head. One has a giant gorilla manservant with a booming voice, the other has a butler that carries around a semi-automatic rifle. One has glitzy musical song and dance numbers, the other has giant robot battles. Both have an awesome soundtrack.

Which is better?

Okay, mostly I've just been wanting to get people to compare Cats Don't Dance and Big-0 because they're so different. But I thought as a thread idea it could lead to other interesting stuff.

Nobodyman

Haven't seen Big-O (commence stone-throwing) so I can't compare. But Cats Don't Dance was pretty good.

Which is better? Doctor Who or Hunter x Hunter?

Pochipochi

Big O's usage of the theater in its narrative frame was really great and I don't think Cats Don't Dance's similar appropriation of the stage was very interesting in comparison. Like it was so literal. They were performing on stage and there was no symbolism or anything, it was just broadway! However in Big O, it is like some kind of long performance, still going, with no one watching, and because shows are meant to be watched, in Big O it is very interesting.

that is very sad and Cats Don't Dance was largely happy, although Big O also had some happy moments like its intro which was very uplifting and powerful.

I think if Cats Don't Dance had Schwarzwald that would be one thing but it doesn't.

Kitsune Inferno

Cats Don't Dance, I feel, was such a brilliantly produced love letter to Broadway that Big O doesn't really compare. Like, Darla Dimple is exemplary of how to make a good villain that isn't overdone or anything, and I don't think any work of fiction can ever really compare, you get me?

I do agree that Cats Don't Dance was a bit more happy go lucky than Big O but that's what makes it better.Big O's "show that nobody watches" thing just feels convoluted and Square Enix-esque in comparison to Cats Don't Dance's very warm and timely message of inclusion.

KageKageKing

Which is better, Gravity Falls or My Little Pony: Friendship is magic?

Kitsune Inferno

I want to invite comparisons between Monkey D. Luffy and John Locke.

CaptainAppleJack

@KageKageKing:

Which is better, Gravity Falls or My Little Pony: Friendship is magic?

I watch both shows (although I haven't seen any episodes of the 3rd MLP:FiM season yet) and I think Gravity Falls is the ones with the better plots and jokes overall.
Not saying that MLP:FiM is a bad show, but I just don't think it's as good as GF. Also the fandom can be annyoing sometimes (not meant in relation to this forums though).

What's better: Pizza or the Nintendo Wii?

Kitsune Inferno

See, I'm eating pizza and playing the Wii as we speak, so I'm quite familiar with both subject matters. I love pizza and I love the Wii, but neither is my favorite thing in either category: There is better food than pizza, there is better console than Wii. However, what makes a pizza? Toppings! What makes a game console? Toppings! (Games!) I'm a fan of anything on pizza. Pepperoni, ham, sausage, cheese, onions, mushrooms, chicken, spinach, anchovies, tortilla chips, bacon, apple slices, you name it. But the Wii is filled with bland, uninspired, phoned-in toppings I mean, who would go out of their way to order a pizza with Wii Sports Resort? I know I wouldn't.

But, the Wii has the best topping of all: Xenoblade Chronicles. In fact, these past couple of years, the Wii upped its topping game pretty fierce. And pizza with Xenoblade Chronicles as a topping would probably lead to cutting my espohagus on the disc shards. If you consider the best of what Wii and pizza have to offer, canadian bacon and pineapple (or chicken alfredo and mushroom pizza) has NOTHING on the Monado. If you consider the variety though, I'd say pizza wins this hands down.

Mastello

@Kitsune:

I want to invite comparisons between Monkey D. Luffy and John Locke.

They don't want to be told what they can't do.

KageKageKing

@Nobodyman:

Haven't seen Big-O (commence stone-throwing) so I can't compare. But Cats Don't Dance was pretty good.

Which is better? Doctor Who or Hunter x Hunter?

Yeah, Daleks are cool, but Chimera Ants are AWESOME!

No Maam

Cats Don't Dance has Max. Beyond that there's nothing realy memmorable about it. I liked it, don't get me wrong, but that's the only thing caught my eye.

Never seen Big-O.

Nobodyman

@KageKageKing:

Which is better, Gravity Falls or My Little Pony: Friendship is magic?

Are these really that dissimilar?

Well, anyway, both are great shows, but I gotta go with MLP. Yes, I will admit the writing for GF is (so far) better than MLP, but I like the animation style of MLP better and I like the characters more. And yes, I love the comraderie of the MLP fandom.

@CaptainAppleJack:

What's better: Pizza or the Nintendo Wii?

I'll be honest, once it was all said and done, I felt kind of disappointed with the Wii. Not that it was a bad system and didn't give us some great games, but there were quite a few dry spells throughout its run where there weren't any games I was really interested in. And quite a few games I played/bought turned out disappointing. Plus, the motion control gimmick got old.

Pizza, on the other hand, is always great. And it has the added bonus of fulfilling the bodily need of hunger. So yeah, gotta go with pizza.

Which is better: Radiohead's OK Computer or the soundtrack to Beauty and the Beast?

Demonicpoodle

@ Pizza or Wii. Now, being as OCD about comparisons as I am, I've been doing this for a long time - comparing food to series or other things and have been surprised with the results. Now I'm assuming it doesn't refer to a single SLICE of the pizza, right? Just pizza forever? If pizza forever then… probably pizza. I'm not much of a gamer admittedly but I don't think even if I was if a game system would replace a staple of food and enjoyment for me like pizza. (but I could be totally wrong on that... I've been behind on the modern gaming front for years now).

Wish I could do the Doctor Who vs Hunter X Hunter one but I'm just now starting on the former.

1PceXperience

@Kitsune:

I want to invite comparisons between Monkey D. Luffy and John Locke.

The comparisons between Monkey D and John Locke is mainly one of:

**1) Old School (John Locke) trying to stay useful to in a new society

VS

2)Youth (Luffy) claiming their rightful position as societies' new leader.**
Throughout the show Locke goes through the tribulations that many older people eventually must face: trying to remain relevant in a new society. When John does something his motives extend past just trying to help; he's also trying to prove his worth.

Proving one's worth is something that Luffy also tries to do; however, in Luffy's case he must prove to the current leaders of the OP society that he deserves to be acknowledged as a higher echelon in his world.

Which is better? (as far as this concept of proving one's self is concerned)

I commend both of them for their persistence in trying to prove their worth; however, I'm going to give this one to John. He shows that even when you're old that you can still BE great. He lives everything out to the fullest (something I can see Luffy doing as he gets older….if he does get older)

MetaMario

Very….interesting thread idea, I'd say. We're almost literally comparing to apples and oranges here.

@Robby's post:.....I unfortunately have not seen either.

@Nobodyman:

Which is better: Radiohead's OK Computer or the soundtrack to Beauty and the Beast?

…..Never heard of the former. But the latter! Beauty and the Beast's soundtrack is such.....so magnificent, so well orchestrated......I mean, you can take away the animation and writing for the movie, and still hit a masterpiece with the music alone.

zachri

Interesting thread idea.
Still a little confused but yiss…
Which is better - Osmosis Jones (the movie, of course - the animated cartoon was terrible seriously it made me want to falcon punch the creator of it in the face for trying to milk such a good movie by making such a shizzy cartoon) or BBC Sherlock (the one with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, not the Robert Downey Jr and Jude Law version)?

KageKageKing

@zachri:

Which is better - Osmosis Jones (the movie, of course - the animated cartoon was terrible seriously it made me want to falcon punch the creator of it in the face for trying to milk such a good movie by making such a shizzy cartoon) or BBC Sherlock (the one with Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman, not the Robert Downey Jr and Jude Law version)?

**Osmosis Jones.**There wasn't a Movie that could teach the human body with such a awesome way like this. By the way, I still remember those great avatars of yours.

King Cannon

Apples or Oranges?

Seriously. It was bound to happen.

Sorikai33

@King:

Apples or Oranges?

Seriously. It was bound to happen.

I don't like peeling oranges. So apples it is.

Hmm, let's see…

Everybody Loves Raymond or Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends?

Sniper King

@Sorikai33:

I don't like peeling oranges. So apples it is.

Hmm, let's see…

Everybody Loves Raymond or Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends?

I'm not qualified to answer most of these questions here, but this, I can!
Everybody Loves Raymond! That's a show I watch with my dad and sister and we always laugh.
Thomas the Tank Engine creeps me the hell out.

Densuke

Oranges! All that peeling and anticipation rewarded with citrus-y delight.

MetaMario

@Sorikai33:

Everybody Loves Raymond or Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends?

Without my bias?

Hm…..Everybody Loves Raymond is funny, but the characters are a little droll.....

Thomas & Friends is a timeless, fun series for all ages. Thomas it is.

@King:

Apples or Oranges?

Seriously. It was bound to happen.

I can't peel oranges, even if they're delicious.

Apples are equally as delicious, yet they're easier to eat. I choose apples!

Which is better…..Mario Party or Crash Bash?

Sniper King

And I choose apples. They are sweet and they are red.
I don't like touching oranges.
And they have the least creative name ever.

1PceXperience

@MetaMario:

Which is better…..Mario Party or Crash Bash?

Sure, Mario Party did it first… but Crash Bash is the SHIT!! Especially the crate throwing games!!!

KageKageKing

@MetaMario:

Which is better…..Mario Party or Crash Bash?

Mario Party, Permanently Mario Party. Crash Bash was just…just Crashin.
Now, which is better... Morgan Freeman or Bruce Lee.

King Cannon

@MetaMario:

Which is better…..Mario Party or Crash Bash?

Mario Party. Much more content and German Wario.

Which is better? Donkey Kong Country 2 or Final Fantasy VI?

MetaMario

@KageKageKing:

Now, which is better… Morgan Freeman or Bruce Lee.

Hm…..on one hand, Morgan Freeman is a rewarding presence in films. From playing a prisoner to God to Nelson Mandela to a leader of an assassin group.....I enjoy his movies. And when he narrates....prepare to be blown away. I mean, he made March of the Penguins really alluring to the ear.

But Bruce Lee....his movies are full of great kung fu action. He's a legend.
….Both are flim greats, but Freeman's got that narrating edge. Morgan Freeman!

@King:

Mario Party. Much more content and German Wario.

Which is better? Donkey Kong Country 2 or Final Fantasy VI?

Never played Final Fantasy VI.

But I still have DKC2 for my old SNES and it's still an amazing game. Donkey Kong it is.

1PceXperience

@KageKageKing:

Mario Party, Permanently Mario Party. Crash Bash was just…just Crashin.
Now, which is better... Morgan Freeman or Bruce Lee.

Both will go down as legends.

Both have encouraged the world to reach down into themselves to be better people.

Morgan Freeman's voice will be remembered forever. Bruce Lee's athleticism will be remembered forever.

But….. Bruce Lee is better! He kicks ass and has progressed humanity's standards of what full physical capabilities can be reached.

DarkFalcon

@Kitsune:

I want to invite comparisons between Monkey D. Luffy and John Locke.

When I've read John Locke, I've immediately thought about him

!
Father of Classical Liberalism
then I've read 1PceXperience answers, and I realized you hadn't probably meant him, but the other one.
However, I can try to compare Luffy and Father of Classical Liberalism if you want me to.

King Cannon

Which is better? Light Salmon or Pale Turquoise?

Nobodyman

@King:

Which is better? Light Salmon or Pale Turquoise?

Well, I would say Light Salmon at moment because I can at least read it.

But seriously, I'm gonna go with Pale Turquoise. I just prefer that part of the color spectrum (blue is my favorite color).

Chandeliers or Lawn Gnomes?

KageKageKing

@Nobodyman:

Chandeliers or Lawn Gnomes?

Lawn Gnomes, of course, they help keep our gardens safe.

1PceXperience

@Nobodyman:

Well, I would say Light Salmon at moment because I can at least read it.

But seriously, I'm gonna go with Pale Turquoise. I just prefer that part of the color spectrum (blue is my favorite color).

Chandeliers or Lawn Gnomes?

Chandeliers, definitely.

You know how many epic scenes have occurred where heroes hang off of Chandeliers while in the middle of a battle? You're not a true vigilante in till you've hung off a chandelier. Everyone knows this!

Sorikai33

@Nobodyman:

Chandeliers or Lawn Gnomes?

[hide] [/hide]
Chandeliers

DarkFalcon

@Nobodyman:

Chandeliers or Lawn Gnomes?

There is movement dedicated to liberation of Lawn Gnomes, I haven't heard of movement fighting for freedom of chandeliers…

Densuke

@KageKageKing:

Lawn Gnomes, of course, they help keep our gardens safe.

Sorikai33

Nico Robin or GLaDOS?

Robby

I'll try to do the HxH/Doctor Who one when I have more time.

@Sorikai33:

I
Everybody Loves Raymond or Thomas the Tank Engine & Friends?

Did George Carlin ever do a cameo on ELR? If not, he was the conductor on Thomas, so it wins by default.

trappedolphin

Lawn gnomes are creepy Chandeliers!

Doctor Who vs. HxH is a tough one. I'm only up to the beginning of the third season for the former. Both have mindblowing moments as well as mediocre ones. I reserve judgment based on the excuse that I'm not done with Doctor Who yet.

I also pick Thomas the Tank Engine because of how timeless it is. I saw a 3-year-old girl clutching it tightly just a few weeks ago.

valiantt

Hmmm….
(1) Oranges (always prefer citris)
(2) ELR (Crossing my fingers for a spinoff with Rob)
(3) Lawn gnomes (for lawn defense purposes)

Here is one:
Leave it to Beaver or Angry Beavers?

trappedolphin

Angry beavers

King Cannon

Chocolate or Youtube? Which is better?

Densuke

Can't we just settle for Chocolate Youtube?

DarkFalcon

Chocolate, chocolate never failed me

Nobodyman

@King:

Chocolate or Youtube? Which is better?

Probably not best to ask that right after Youtube made another bogus web design change. But anyway…

Chocolate is forever. Youtube is good until the next best thing.

Chocolate it is.

King Cannon

Ok. Let's try something else…

Batman or Hot Pockets?

TheCrystalShip

Batman. More indispensable in popular culture.

Sniper King

Hot Pockets for me. I can't eat Batman.

Nobodyman

@King:

Ok. Let's try something else…

Batman or Hot Pockets?

I actually didn't start eating Hot Pockets until recently. They're good, but Batman is a priceless cultural icon. Definitely the Bat.

Let's see, Twilight by ELO…

!

..or Heart Shaped Box by Nirvana.

!

m00n

I'd have to say Twilight. Not just because it's a really nice song but because it is for me the beginning of AMV making. Heart Shaped Box is cool but it hasn't inspired a new form of art.