The mere fact mosquito girls and blizzard are so high proves japanese readers care only for (.)(.)
Onepunch-Man (redrawn version)
-
-
This post is deleted!
-
Chapter got translated
-
Please do not link entire chapters as images in threads, even under spoiler tags, as the images will still load whether or not a spoiler tag is pressed
http://bato.to/read/_/323606/onepunch-man_ch47_by_nerieru-scans
-
Stain and Garou should team up in a crossover or something.
-
If only Garou has to ability to steal the heroes powers.
I lold how Saitama was mocking TTM, most of the content didnt happen in the webcomic but it was done well.
-
The villain ask the child fan where's the objective.
That's the way!.
-
The mere fact mosquito girls and blizzard are so high proves japanese readers care only for (.)(.)
Well, Mosquito Girl is pretty memorable and Blizzard got a ton of paneltime lately. The only surprise is the S class zombie dude. Watchdog man should have taken his place!
-
If only Garou has to ability to steal the heroes powers.
! He copies the fighting styles of people he beats up. Does that count?
-
Aren't the s-class humans? Because it sure is strange to see so many dismiss the threat posed by Garou because he is a human. I appreciated TTM spirit in his battle and I'm looking forward to his fight with his old master. Until then good hunt to him.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
stuff
Isn't that spoiler?
I wonder how useful that can be. Aside from bang and the swordsman the heroes seems to rely on other tools than technique to be successful.
-
Isn't that spoiler?
Not really? I mean it's been implied he goes around crushing dojos and stealing their techs, right? I think Bang said his former student(which I assume means Garou) was going around doing that. He even did that to those guys that showed up at Bang's dojo while Genos and Saitama were having hotpot.
-
It will better to not visit the thread since ppl keeps posting spoilers about what we still don't know for real.
-
Not really? I mean it's been implied he goes around crushing dojos and stealing their techs, right? I think Bang said his former student(which I assume means Garou) was going around doing that. He even did that to those guys that showed up at Bang's dojo while Genos and Saitama were having hotpot.
I'm sure he only mentioned destroying dojo or I must have miss something since that info surprise me.
-
Not really? I mean it's been implied he goes around crushing dojos and stealing their techs, right? I think Bang said his former student(which I assume means Garou) was going around doing that. He even did that to those guys that showed up at Bang's dojo while Genos and Saitama were having hotpot.
It is said Garochan is a genius; holds technique, power and life philosophy. Entirely human-like measures… not a spoiler has been mentioned if you ask me. This will continue until suppose he confronts Saitama or Tatsumaki, the latter would be nice. A slap to that bitch is worth to see and i'm eager just to think of it.
-
This post is deleted!
-
new chapter have been scanlated
http://bato.to/read/_/325173/onepunch-man_ch48_by_nerieru-scans
-
Viz is going to be releasing physical volumes of the series starting in September
Then I know what manga I will be buying starting from September..
new chapter have been scanlated
http://bato.to/read/_/325173/onepunch-man_ch48_by_nerieru-scans
I dont like it at all.
Murata should stick to drawing what One drawn, not to make up fillers like what we just gotten. Absolutely meh for me.
-
I dont like it at all.
Murata should stick to drawing what One drawn, not to make up fillers like what we just gotten. Absolutely meh for me.
Then you want Murata to make the pacing as bad as Kubo does?
Last chapter was also "filler" but very enjoyable.
Im a big fan of tourneys, Im interesting how Murata will handle it, we might expect some guys with some haxx martial art techniques.
-
I think some character development cannot hurt. One's transitions feel a little bit abrupt at times.
-
A martial arts tournament?
This had to be Murata's idea. I love his artstyle but I agree that he should stuck to ONE's writing.
-
Then you want Murata to make the pacing as bad as Kubo does?
Last chapter was also "filler" but very enjoyable.
Im a big fan of tourneys, Im interesting how Murata will handle it, we might expect some guys with some haxx martial art techniques.
What Kubo has to do with Onepunch Man ?
Ones OPM is pretty great with all of its imperfections(beside art) and nothing beside art should be changed in my opinion.
I need remade content and not some shitty fillers about matrial art contest that has close to zero to do with what Ones OPM was all about.
Murata should stick to do what he is best at - drawing - and not try to add too much of his own as it will destroy how consistent OPM was.I think some character development cannot hurt. One's transitions feel a little bit abrupt at times.
That is part of its charm.
I am super unhappy about that filler stuff that will take away some chapters and that will make wait for interesting stuff prolong…
I fear that Murata would like to add his own ideas to making OPM now and its pretty terrible idea imo.
-
The main problem here is that Murata doesnt have a grasp of Saitama as a character.
He is trying to make Saitama more heroic and shonen-like, the very thing that the original series is parodying. He has done this in the extra episodes and now in the hospital. ONE's Saitama has a ton of flaws that make him interesting (for once he wont give a crap about visiting injured heroes) and Murata is spoiling his charisma by making him act as a goody two shoes.
-
The main problem here is that Murata doesnt have a grasp of Saitama as a character.
He is trying to make Saitama more heroic and shonen-like, the very thing that the original series is parodying. He has done this in the extra episodes and now in the hospital. ONE's Saitama has a ton of flaws that make him interesting (for once he wont give a crap about visiting injured heroes) and Murata is spoiling his charisma by making him act as a goody two shoes.
Cannot agree more.
Saitamas strength is alienating him from people in many ways and Murata is erasing that feeling of Saitama from Ones version with what he does lately.
I hope he gets criticized by many many people and that it will get to him. It might be bit cruel but he is nowehere near Ones skill when it comes to creating characters.I also dislike Murata creating his own filler heroes as he also lacks creativity and feel for quirky weirdness that One surely has.
-
I don't think it was too out of character for saitama visiting the hospital. He only visited the martial arts guy for selfish reasons, met tank-top master by chance and is friends with licence-less rider. I'll wait and see how a martial arts tourney will go. It might make good world building.
-
What if One gave his stamp of approval?
-
This, he visited Licenceless rider, someone he admires, the rest were there by coincidence.
-
Agree with the above.
I don't see what's overly heroic about Saitama visiting his bro in the hospital.
Being a good friend is very much a part of Saitama's character as per ONE's writing.
Not to mention that you're talking about a guy who assassinated his own character in front of a crowd to stop them from belittling Rider and dudes and who's response to King stealing his fame was to instantly forgive him and become buddies. All of that written by ONE. What you criticize in Murata's original scenes is very much in line with that.
And I believe that being a person occasionally capable of minor altruism doesn't make him like a shounen lead, nor does that eliminate his flaws. Maybe if Murata has him deliver lame speeches about protecting his friends or something…
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
Not sure about the tourney thing though...
-
Agree with the above.
I don't see what's overly heroic about Saitama visiting his bro in the hospital.
Being a good friend is very much a part of Saitama's character as per ONE's writing.
Not to mention that you're talking about a guy who assassinated his own character in front of a crowd to stop them from belittling Rider and dudes and who's response to King stealing his fame was to instantly forgive him and become buddies. All of that written by ONE. What you criticize in Murata's original scenes is very much in line with that.
And I believe that being a person occasionally capable of minor altruism doesn't make him like a shounen lead, nor does that eliminate his flaws. Maybe if Murata has him deliver lame speeches about protecting his friends or something…
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
Not sure about the tourney thing though...
It doesnt change that this chapter simply didnt felt right especially with tourney being hinted at the end.
-
It doesnt change that this chapter simply didnt felt right especially with tourney being hinted at the end.
i doubt you would complain so much if you didn't know it would be filler and murata proved before that he's totally capable of writing short side-stories
-
It bothers me because we are about to get to an epic part of the story, and we go to a part that can't have any impact on the plot. It bothers me, sure, but knowing saitama, he'll just sit it out or something.
-
i doubt you would complain so much if you didn't know it would be filler and murata proved before that he's totally capable of writing short side-stories
This sounds like bit longer filler than before. And those fillerish chapters werent so great, often feeling detached from Ones OPM.
-
It bothers me because we are about to get to an epic part of the story, and we go to a part that can't have any impact on the plot. It bothers me, sure, but knowing saitama, he'll just sit it out or something.
The Tournament might always happen after everything else since there's nothing saying when it's scheduled for.
Of course, it's probably later that day but it's probably not going to take up a lot of time either.
-
since saitama is going to KO everyone within seconds it shouldn't take too long
-
This is one of the top ten pages about stupid heroes ever. … also because Charango can't take the banana.
-
I fear that Murata would like to add his own ideas to making OPM now and its pretty terrible idea imo.
+1
Save the tedious filler for the anime, he needs to stick to the source material.
-
He brought bananas, but is the only one shown eating them. That is Saitama to a T if you ask me!
I didn't remember this from One's version, but I don't think that this filler seems wrong. It looks like Murata has tried to introduce the fat kid a little earlier, and I really like how he is writing Garou's character.
-
One good thing from last chapter is that it added a lot of value to matrial arts techniques being dangerous weapon even if somebody does not have absolute strength.
That bit was pretty cool. -
Despite my defence of Murata earlier, I will agree that this tourney stuff feels off.
There time and place for Murata filler and it's not in the middle of mah long awaited Garo stuff.
-
I don't get it all of you say filler just think about it if the story by One himself.
-
^This.
You know Murata doesn't write his manga, right.
-
^^^ This is what I'm saying Murata just drawing this manga unless you're talking about another manga.
-
^This.
You know Murata doesn't write his manga, right.
The extra chapters, expect the prison break one, didnt have ONE's style, I find hard to believe he had anything to do with those expect giving them green light.
Same goes for the last two chapters. Its not like the writting seems off and that Saitama seems a different guy but also the page composition is not as good as when Murata sticks to the original source
-
-
Not just the credits, but the interview on bizmash! revealed Murata's role was to provide art for the remake that the both of them were working on from the start. Same with NEETSHA's interview with ONE himself.
So the assumption that Murata is actually writing all the extra is just that, entirely your assumption, not substantiated by actual facts we know, which says otherwise.
I mean, sure, you're free to believe whatever you want, but I'm gonna need a bit more evidence to claim their statements false.Especially when you know, Murata has NEVER written serialization on his own in his career. Ever. Across all three serializations.
Only time we ever saw Murata as the writer are shorts, every serialization he's ever had in his career were written by someone else. (And even talking about his one shots, half of them had other writers lol.)Does he have creative inputs? Of course he does, you can't co-produce a manga without it from the artist.
Do we have any evidence of him doing the actual writing of extra story? Not to my knowledge, no.Im not sure if sarcasm.
… are YOU? Can you provide me some source?
-
Not just the credits, but the interview on bizmash! revealed Murata's role was to provide art for the remake that the both of them were working on from the start. Same with NEETSHA's interview with ONE himself.
So the assumption that Murata is actually writing all the extra is just that, entirely your assumption, not substantiated by actual facts we know, which says otherwise.
I mean, sure, you're free to believe whatever you want, but I'm gonna need a bit more evidence to claim their statements false.Especially when you know, Murata has NEVER written serialization on his own in his career. Ever. Across all three serializations.
Only time we ever saw Murata as the writer are shorts, every serialization he's ever had in his career were written by someone else. (And even talking about his one shots, half of them had other writers lol.)Does he have creative inputs? Of course he does, you can't co-produce a manga without it from the artist.
Do we have any evidence of him doing the actual writing of extra story? Not to my knowledge, no.… are YOU? Can you provide me some source?
Sure I cannot.
Simply last chapter feels like something Murata would do on his own, not like cooperation with One. Tournament idea also feels like something that does not fit for current arc and looks "filerish" while there is enough of content from Ones OPM for Murata to draw for years to come.Though on other hand One and Murata did together that "Cockroach" one shot that was rather bad in my opinion, so maybe its not beyond One to make something just "OK" or not special at all I guess..
-
Aohige has a point, I didnt know Murata usually is in charge of art alone.
On the other hand this tournament has a reek of filler and what would be the point if ONE was the writer of it? If getting near to the original series is an issue it would be more logical to release new chapters for it instead of shoehorning new material in the story.
-
Depends. How much is Shueisha paying ONE for this serialization compared to his own serialized work? If Shueisha's paying better than all of ONE's other serializations, then it makes good financial sense for him to put his other stories on hiatus and focus on OPM. On the other hand, it's difficult to be creative on a deadline, and produce top-quality work. I can tolerate a little filler, if it means that the main story doesn't consistently read and feel like filler.
-
One adding filler means he's going to be getting paid more. I don't really see why he would want to rush through the redrawn version unless he hates money. Anyways why is it so hard to understand why a author would want to expand on his original work. Movies have director's cuts all the time. There could've been a number of reasons why he didn't include it in the original version like deadlines, skipped parts since he didn't figure the series will last as long as it did, didn't like how it originally turned out and wanted to expand on certain scenes to go give them more contexts, etc., etc.