Arlong Park Forums

    • Register
    • Login
    • Categories
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups

    Throughout this month, we will be testing new features (like search) so you may experience some hiccups from time to time. We'll try to not be too disruptive...

    One Piece Mafia: Part II

    Community Games
    63
    11370
    2203873
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • Wooden_Giraffe
      Wooden_Giraffe
      last edited by
      Wooden_Giraffe
      spiral
      Wooden_Giraffe
      spiral

      Vote Free: Mrs. Iceburg

      Right now the best thing I can think of is to put the person I most think is mafia. Honestly there are not much in the ways of facts or logic behind my #1 suspect. These days it seems like any action can be considered scummy so I found it really hard to judge in recent games unless someone becomes incredibly contradictory. But one consistent thing I've noticed is how rare it is for the mafia to let anyone go by with out at least a little suspicion, so when I see someone who has been generally left alone I become incredibly suspicious.

      Vote Lynch: trappedolphin

      H Wooden_Giraffe 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote 0
      • H
        Harvady Alumnus @Wooden_Giraffe
        @Wooden_Giraffe last edited by
        H
        spiral
        Harvady Alumnus
        spiral

        @Shuhan:

        I am incredibly sorry I havent been on for the past two days…

        for now, ill put this down

        vote free: Mrs Iceburg

        And to answer your question Trappy, I feel pretty good that Nectar is in the box, he was one of my suspects so I do want to know his alignment. At this point though, as much as I wanted to go it, its too late now. If we are truly at LYLO then I can't put myself up anymore

        There is no 'for now' the day is going to end.

        @Wooden_Giraffe:

        Vote Free: Mrs. Iceburg

        Right now the best thing I can think of is to put the person I most think is mafia. Honestly there are not much in the ways of facts or logic behind my #1 suspect. These days it seems like any action can be considered scummy so I found it really hard to judge in recent games unless someone becomes incredibly contradictory. But one consistent thing I've noticed is how rare it is for the mafia to let anyone go by with out at least a little suspicion, so when I see someone who has been generally left alone I become incredibly suspicious.

        Vote Lynch: trappedolphin

        There are seven hours left. Unless you want the day to end in a NL, hammer the wagon that already has two people on it.


        Well at least the Mafia isn't Shu/Wooden. If it was, they'd be violating the Geneva Convention with this kind of torture. They would've hammered and put an end to it.

        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • Shuhan
          Shuhan
          last edited by
          Shuhan
          spiral
          Shuhan
          spiral

          Vote lynch: Galaxy 9000

          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
          • B
            Bogart
            last edited by
            B
            spiral
            Bogart
            spiral

            Vote Count: With five alive it takes three t_____o lynch. Galaxy 9000 [[COLOR=#ff0000]3]: Harvady Alumnus, trappedolphin, Shuhan
            trappedolphin [1]: Wooden_Giraffe
            Not Voting:
            Galaxy 9000
            Release Count: Most votes at lynch secure release
            .
            Mrs. Iceburg [4]:
            _ Harvady Alumnus, trappedolphin,______ Shuhan, Wooden Giraffe Not Voting: Galaxy 9000 _**Lynch has been achieved. Day Three has ended.

            (story or something)**_ **_Braham has been hung. Now dangling by his feet high above Town, he will no longer be able to move or be heard unless someone has to collect him. He will, however, be able to hang out with Pagaya and spend some time getting to know each other.

            McKinley has returned. Perhaps there will be something for him to share?_** Night Two has begun.

            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • B
              Bogart
              last edited by
              B
              spiral
              Bogart
              spiral

              __(Story some day)

              Wooden_Giraffe has died. He was Aisa, the Townie. He had no special abilities.
              **Town can no longer gain the votes needed to incapacitate the mafia, as the Mafia now match the number of Townies left.

              Game Over. Mafia Wins.**__ Congratulations to Mrs. Iceburg and trappedolphin.

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • trappedolphin
                trappedolphin
                last edited by
                trappedolphin
                spiral
                trappedolphin
                spiral

                Whoooooooooooooooooooo~

                In spite of the inactivity, I had fun. Thank you to Harvady for keeping me company on the last day. And sorry for calling you a brat here XD

                Handsome man save me from the monsters.

                Avatar credits to rcerione

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • Mrs. Iceburg
                  Mrs. Iceburg
                  last edited by
                  Mrs. Iceburg
                  spiral
                  Mrs. Iceburg
                  spiral

                  Yay! That wasn't all so difficult as initially anticipated. Thanks Bo for hosting and thanks to the other players too.

                  Though I have to say, I'm really disappointed in the lurking players. If you sign up, you play, and if you can't, you don't.
                  This game always runs in function of how many people signed up, so if 7 people sign up but only 4 actually participate, the whole game gets stunted, and frankly, ruined for those who do want to play. It's disrespectful towards the mod who calculates the setup on the number of players, and puts time into sending out PM's and dividing roles. It sucks for other players who want to play, but get very little to work with because of inactivity of other players. I imagine it particularly sucks for active players who get killed/lynched early on, and then have to sit back and watch as activity drops close to zero in the game they would have liked to keep playing.
                  I understand that IRL stuff can come in between, and that that's obviously more important than an online game. But next time when you sign up, think about whether or not you will actually be able to take out a bunch of free time to show up and participate. That is all.

                  Nectar 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                  • Nectar
                    Nectar @Mrs. Iceburg
                    @Mrs. Iceburg last edited by
                    Nectar
                    spiral
                    Nectar
                    spiral

                    Gratz to Mrs. Iceburg and Trapped for winning AND playing. Lynching on Day 3 wasn't good for the Town and I really wanted to see if Iceburg could trick the Town. Iceburg VS Harvady would've been fun.

                    MVP to Trapped for staying off my radar.

                    @Mrs.:

                    Yay! That wasn't all so difficult as initially anticipated. Thanks Bo for hosting and thanks to the other players too.

                    Though I have to say, I'm really disappointed in the lurking players. If you sign up, you play, and if you can't, you don't.
                    This game always runs in function of how many people signed up, so if 7 people sign up but only 4 actually participate, the whole game gets stunted, and frankly, ruined for those who do want to play. It's disrespectful towards the mod who calculates the setup on the number of players, and puts time into sending out PM's and dividing roles. It sucks for other players who want to play, but get very little to work with because of inactivity of other players. I imagine it particularly sucks for active players who get killed/lynched early on, and then have to sit back and watch as activity drops close to zero in the game they would have liked to keep playing.
                    I understand that IRL stuff can come in between, and that that's obviously more important than an online game. But next time when you sign up, think about whether or not you will actually be able to take out a bunch of free time to show up and participate. That is all.

                    This or something like this should be in first post of new Mafia thread!

                    You lurkers make me hate playing this game. Get this through your heads, you are ruining the game! I know Mrs. Iceburg said all this but I recently read though the game I made and I remember how frustrating it was because of all the lurking. I worked hard on that game and wanted every player to enjoy it but the lurkers took so much fun out of it I decided never host a game here again. Thank goodness the players who actually participated were able to keep it from being a total failure and I thank you for it. And thank you Bogart for taking the time to put this game together.

                    Yeah, that happened awhile back but this game brought back those feelings.

                    One Piece Mafia need new players. To anyone reading this whose interested in playing, do it. It's fun. You don't have to post every hour and at this point posting three times every 24 hours is more than enough. You don't have to be a genius and you don't have to be right all the time, just follow your gut and play.

                    NNID: jervinnectar

                    Mrs. Iceburg 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • Wooden_Giraffe
                      Wooden_Giraffe @Wooden_Giraffe
                      @Wooden_Giraffe last edited by
                      Wooden_Giraffe
                      spiral
                      Wooden_Giraffe
                      spiral

                      @Wooden_Giraffe:

                      Vote Free: Mrs. Iceburg

                      Right now the best thing I can think of is to put the person I most think is mafia. Honestly there are not much in the ways of facts or logic behind my #1 suspect. These days it seems like any action can be considered scummy so I found it really hard to judge in recent games unless someone becomes incredibly contradictory. But one consistent thing I've noticed is how rare it is for the mafia to let anyone go by with out at least a little suspicion, so when I see someone who has been generally left alone I become incredibly suspicious.

                      Vote Lynch: trappedolphin

                      The most annoying thing is that whenever I megalurk in a game I'm always able to pinpoint the mafia but by then I've lurked so much that no one give my words any credit. My own fault I guess, sorry guys.

                      trappedolphin 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                      • trappedolphin
                        trappedolphin @Wooden_Giraffe
                        @Wooden_Giraffe last edited by
                        trappedolphin
                        spiral
                        trappedolphin
                        spiral

                        @Wooden_Giraffe:

                        The most annoying thing is that whenever I megalurk in a game I'm always able to pinpoint the mafia but by then I've lurked so much that no one give my words any credit. My own fault I guess, sorry guys.

                        Yeah you always seem to be the one I can't fool. XD

                        And thank you Bogart for hosting!

                        Handsome man save me from the monsters.

                        Avatar credits to rcerione

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • Mrs. Iceburg
                          Mrs. Iceburg @Nectar
                          @Nectar last edited by
                          Mrs. Iceburg
                          spiral
                          Mrs. Iceburg
                          spiral

                          @Nectar:

                          -Lynching on Day 3 wasn't good for the Town and I really wanted to see if Iceburg could trick the Town. Iceburg VS Harvady would've been fun.

                          I was reaally looking forward to this aswell 😛 But then it was over already.

                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • trappedolphin
                            trappedolphin
                            last edited by
                            trappedolphin
                            spiral
                            trappedolphin
                            spiral

                            Can we have the link to the thread you guys had? I'm curious.~

                            Handsome man save me from the monsters.

                            Avatar credits to rcerione

                            Nectar 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                            • Nectar
                              Nectar @trappedolphin
                              @trappedolphin last edited by
                              Nectar
                              spiral
                              Nectar
                              spiral

                              @trappedolphin:

                              Can we have the link to the thread you guys had? I'm curious.~

                              Don't think Bogart will mind: http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/QfiafLHv4iDc

                              Not much there. Us being bored with me trying to play head games but I guess she won. She hinted she was the only Mafioso to vote on Day 1, I ended up thinking it was Galaxy.

                              NNID: jervinnectar

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                              • Foolio
                                Foolio
                                admin
                                last edited by
                                Foolio
                                spiral
                                Foolio
                                admin
                                spiral

                                Here is the dead people QT. As you can see I guess the 2 mafia correctly upon my death. Good thing you killed me, trapped!

                                I'm kind of surprised trapped was off all your radars. She had this weird obsession with Red Hawk who was 95% confirmed townie the second he "answered" Nectar's original question. Hell even Nectar asking the question was a good sign he was town, though as I wrote in the QT I was still pretty suspicious of him, but in the end the kind of foresight required to ask that question as a mafioso tipped me into suspecting Icy-chan more.

                                I'm also a little surprised that nobody (including myself) was more worried about the fact that we did need a mafia in the box day 3 to keep the game going. This whole plan of swapping people out in order was actually pretty foolish (should have been purely scum hunting, releasing the least scummy-seeming person in the context of what happened since their lynch, and any reports being merely a bonus) and as we can see here, the town didn't even last long enough to get a report at all. Wooden is one of the only people who I saw expressing (brief) concern for this problem.

                                Finally, this meta assumption about mafia being on a wagon or lurking seemed risky and I found it curious that so much confidence was placed in it. Oh and lurkers suck.

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                • Mrs. Iceburg
                                  Mrs. Iceburg
                                  last edited by
                                  Mrs. Iceburg
                                  spiral
                                  Mrs. Iceburg
                                  spiral

                                  Psh. You guys always suspect me, ain't no pride in getting it right every so often.

                                  –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                                  @Foolio:

                                  I'm also a little surprised that nobody (including myself) was more worried about the fact that we did need a mafia in the box day 3 to keep the game going. This whole plan of swapping people out in order was actually pretty foolish (should have been purely scum hunting, releasing the least scummy-seeming person in the context of what happened since their lynch, and any reports being merely a bonus) and as we can see here, the town didn't even last long enough to get a report at all. Wooden is one of the only people who I saw expressing (brief) concern for this problem.

                                  Yeah, when you first described your fifo tactic, I thought it was foolproof. But I hadn't incalculated the fact that 2 boxed Townies count as 2 dead Townies. So in the end, the theory worked in our advantage. It also helped that I was boxed D1, making it unlikely that I actually was Mafia, and that people were legitimately suspicious of Nectar.

                                  It sure was difficult to shut up for almost an entire game… I wasn't allowed to talk here, or in the Maf thread, and then when Nectar came in, I had to stop fooling around in the Hangout thread too 😛

                                  1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • H
                                    Harvady Alumnus
                                    last edited by
                                    H
                                    spiral
                                    Harvady Alumnus
                                    spiral

                                    Good fun, despite the lurkers. Thanks to Bogart for hosting.

                                    …and thanks to youse mafia broads fer not killin' me.

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                    • Shuhan
                                      Shuhan
                                      last edited by
                                      Shuhan
                                      spiral
                                      Shuhan
                                      spiral

                                      I think im sitting out of mafia for a while…

                                      too much unexpected shit happening now that is screwing me up...im sorry if I ruined the game, I honestly wanted to be more vocal, but certain more important things were happening (moving out of my soon to be ex-wife and mine apartment back to my parents, me putting holes through walls because my anger is getting the better of me)...I love the game...but my IRL life came first this time...so sorry for ruining the game...

                                      ciao

                                      trappedolphin 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                      • trappedolphin
                                        trappedolphin @Shuhan
                                        @Shuhan last edited by
                                        trappedolphin
                                        spiral
                                        trappedolphin
                                        spiral

                                        @Harvady:

                                        Good fun, despite the lurkers. Thanks to Bogart for hosting.

                                        …and thanks to youse mafia broads fer not killin' me.

                                        You're welcome 😛 I actually wanted people to vote so I could get Iceburg out faster, so killing you wouldn't really have been in my favour. haha. Plus I didn't want to be all alone here 😞

                                        @Shuhan:

                                        I think im sitting out of mafia for a while…

                                        too much unexpected shit happening now that is screwing me up...im sorry if I ruined the game, I honestly wanted to be more vocal, but certain more important things were happening (moving out of my soon to be ex-wife and mine apartment back to my parents, me putting holes through walls because my anger is getting the better of me)...I love the game...but my IRL life came first this time...so sorry for ruining the game...

                                        ciao

                                        Take care Shushu dear, I hope things get better soon. 😕 And you weren't the biggest lurker so don't blame yourself. hugs

                                        –- Update From New Post Merge ---

                                        @Mrs.:

                                        Yeah, when you first described your fifo tactic, I thought it was foolproof. But I hadn't incalculated the fact that 2 boxed Townies count as 2 dead Townies. So in the end, the theory worked in our advantage. It also helped that I was boxed D1, making it unlikely that I actually was Mafia, and that people were legitimately suspicious of Nectar.

                                        This, yeah. XD I was rather surprised when I realised that the "foolproof" plan would work out for us. I think Woody and I both brought up small counterarguments to it on Day 1, but they were pretty much ignored and I quickly shut up lol.

                                        This was a REALLY interesting setup though. Definitely made everything different.

                                        Handsome man save me from the monsters.

                                        Avatar credits to rcerione

                                        Nectar 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                        • Nectar
                                          Nectar @trappedolphin
                                          @trappedolphin last edited by
                                          Nectar
                                          spiral
                                          Nectar
                                          spiral

                                          @Foolio:

                                          Here is the dead people QT. As you can see I guess the 2 mafia correctly upon my death. Good thing you killed me, trapped!

                                          I'm kind of surprised trapped was off all your radars. She had this weird obsession with Red Hawk who was 95% confirmed townie the second he "answered" Nectar's original question. Hell even Nectar asking the question was a good sign he was town, though as I wrote in the QT I was still pretty suspicious of him, but in the end the kind of foresight required to ask that question as a mafioso tipped me into suspecting Icy-chan more.

                                          I'm also a little surprised that nobody (including myself) was more worried about the fact that we did need a mafia in the box day 3 to keep the game going. This whole plan of swapping people out in order was actually pretty foolish (should have been purely scum hunting, releasing the least scummy-seeming person in the context of what happened since their lynch, and any reports being merely a bonus) and as we can see here, the town didn't even last long enough to get a report at all. Wooden is one of the only people who I saw expressing (brief) concern for this problem.

                                          Finally, this meta assumption about mafia being on a wagon or lurking seemed risky and I found it curious that so much confidence was placed in it. Oh and lurkers suck.

                                          Wow! I was so distracted on Day 2 I didn't connect those dots. Just ignored Trapp's suspicions as a bad Townie deduction.

                                          @Shuhan:

                                          I think im sitting out of mafia for a while…

                                          too much unexpected shit happening now that is screwing me up...im sorry if I ruined the game, I honestly wanted to be more vocal, but certain more important things were happening (moving out of my soon to be ex-wife and mine apartment back to my parents, me putting holes through walls because my anger is getting the better of me)...I love the game...but my IRL life came first this time...so sorry for ruining the game...

                                          ciao

                                          Least you have an excuse. We're all rooting for you buddy!

                                          NNID: jervinnectar

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • vorlianis
                                            vorlianis
                                            last edited by
                                            vorlianis
                                            spiral
                                            vorlianis
                                            spiral

                                            If everyones okay with it i'll go make the new thread in a bit.

                                            PM me or whatever if you want anything specific in it that i won't have posted.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0

                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 224
                                            • 225
                                            • 226
                                            • 227
                                            • 228
                                            • 228 / 228
                                            • First post
                                              Last post
                                            Powered by NodeBB | Contributors