@MDL:
Why do people still make a big deal about it and flip out?
1)Because the first movie was largely awful and looks frightening.
2)It splits the creative staff's energy and time. The first movies at least used up writers and animators assigned to the main show and its largely assumed to be a factor in season 3 being only half length. (Given that the run time was the equivalent of 4 episodes plus development time, it was certainly a factor and ate into the schedule of one of the better show writers.)
With it going full time there might be a full blown staff split… or it might get only newbie talent.
3)It IS fightng with the main show. Same title, character names and colors are being promoted across the board... it does eat into the main product in terms of advertising and merchandising, and pushes the more generic girly tropes (teenage crush crap in high school!) that everyone is already convinced the main show has. Damaging the genuine all ages quality the main show has.
All that said, I think most of the hate would vanish if the character designs had simply been better.
[hide]
Or any of the other thousands of fanarts with better human designs than the actual show.
About the only legitimate thing I hear about the crazy ass designs they ended up with is having the crazy neon skin tones because they wouldn't want to assign race to any of the main 6. (Asian twilight, black rarity, tanned applejack, etc) and having them be all white is… iffy.[/hide]