Okay so…
Luffy will die right before finding One Piece after fighting someone. Maybe a pirate or maybe to protect it from the marines or WG. He goes with a smile because it was worth it. Then the crew finds it for him, in his honor... Or maybe not to keep it sacred... Or not... Umm... But he does become the Pirate King! (Okay it sounded kinda good in my head... I got nothing to support this theory...)
Wait... Does this count as a dumb prediction? D:
Theories That Don't Deserve Their Own Thread v.2
-
-
Okay so…
Luffy will die right before finding One Piece after fighting someone. Maybe a pirate or maybe to protect it from the marines or WG. He goes with a smile because it was worth it. Then the crew finds it for him, in his honor... Or maybe not to keep it sacred... Or not... Umm... But he does become the Pirate King! (Okay it sounded kinda good in my head... I got nothing to support this theory...)
Wait... Does this count as a dumb prediction? D:Um, wrong thread.
-
Damn, I should have swapped over theories with kagexp since mine "what One Piece is" apparently wasn't dumb enough to exist in that thread (though I guess it's still there). And now I can't decide whether my theory of Alvida being Luffy's mother should be posted here or to dumb predictions topic.
Maybe it shouldn't be posted at all.
-
Damn, I should have swapped over theories with kagexp since mine "what One Piece is" apparently wasn't dumb enough to exist in that thread (though I guess it's still there). And now I can't decide whether my theory of Alvida being Luffy's mother should be posted here or to dumb predictions topic.
Maybe it shouldn't be posted at all.
Alright, alright I get it. FINE… I will not cry...
-
I don't know if it has already been discussed but here's the theory => http://www.mangashare.com/forums/threads/22006-The-Mystery-of-One-Piece…solved/page10
I think that everyone has already thought about the rio poneglyph = One Piece ( which I disagree somewhat… ). But the whole ( far-fetched ) "Luffy=Shandian thing" was interesting to me since I never thought about it.
To add some elements to it, I want to mention that Monkey D. Dragon has the same type of tribal tatoo the Shandian have.
-
I like this idea that all these organizations to clash. This time Oda won't hold back the fights.
Personally, I think this war will occur before Luffy reaches Raftel for the finale against the remaining BB pirates and the strongest Schibukais.
-
I HAVE ANOTHER THEORY! :D
I get it. I get why Zoro gets lost! He is doing it subconsciously! If he will ever reach his dream, then he have to train! And… That's what he is doing. All. The. Time! Both physically (training his speed and muscles 'n stuff) and mentally (because his brain didn't inform him. That way he won't loose focus and he won't let his sanity get in the way and other brain stuff). -
I HAVE ANOTHER THEORY! :D
I get it. I get why Zoro gets lost! He is doing it subconsciously! If he will ever reach his dream, then he have to train! And… That's what he is doing. All. The. Time! Both physically (training his speed and muscles 'n stuff) and mentally (because his brain didn't inform him. That way he won't loose focus and he won't let his sanity get in the way and other brain stuff).http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=12012&p=2144342&viewfull=1#post2144342
I like my ideas better.
-
http://apforums.net/showthread.php?t=12012&p=2144342&viewfull=1#post2144342
I like my ideas better.
Well the first one does make some sense…He is one with his swords and they are made of metal... Wait...
-
I think the story will advance very differently in the New world. Instead of giving us a different story arc every time the SH get to a new island we'll get large expanses of time between adventures. In between these important adventures the SH will have visited many places off-panel. So instead of days or or a small handful of weeks sailing from place to place months will have transpired before another important arc.
This way the SH will not conquer the Grand Line and defeat Kaidou, Teach, Akainu, etc. before Luffy is even 21 years old. Instead of getting gradually stronger each arc where they face a villain able to push them to their limits these time elapses will allow them to gain many victories under their belts providing big power boosts before being forced to go all out. This makes more sense than them always having just the necessary amount of strength to deal with whatever threat each Island present until gradually they are ready for the top tiers. Also makes more sense than the idea they are already close to top tiers and just need some NW hardships for that final push.
I like this idea because it provides a logical way for Zoro and Sanji to master Haki. I don't think they learned it at all over the time skip. Zoro may have some natural talent and a basic understanding of it from Mihawk but not enough to just start using it casually like Luffy. I see no reason at all why Sanji would know anything of it. Even if they both somehow know a lot about it their training wasn't focused on it like Luffy's and he trained with a Haki master. They need at least need half as much time as Luffy got to focus on it; half since they are much stronger than Luffy when started training but still a while because they have no real teacher. I think they'll slowly learn to use it from Luffy during these long time elapses. Not that Luffy is training them just that they observe Luffy using it in combat ask for some pointers and take it from there.
-
Queen Otohime wasn't murdered by some last-minute new villain. She was killed by Arlong.
After Fisher Tiger's death, Arlong (already known to be violent and disliking humans) takes it to another level and declares war on all humans. This declaration is known as "Arlong's Will" and serves to inspire many fishmen, including Hodi.
Otohime insists on her ideals, and this leads to her confront Arlong, which ends up with her death.These events make Jinbei reconsider his hatred towards humans and realize all this would cause only more unnecessary deaths and pain on both sides. However, Arlong's presence in Fishmen Island is unacceptable, especially with Otohime's family still around.
Jinbei, probably because of his past relationship with Arlong, decides to banish him from the island, instead of killing/putting him into jail, at the same time striking a deal with the Marines to become a shichibukai, in a way to protect his former Sun Pirates associates and reduce the risk of an attack against Fishman Island (and to further aid Whitebeard in protecting the area).
This deal makes the locals respect Jinbei up until today, even with him becoming a "pirate" in a certain way, since his deal with the Marines guarantees more safety to the island (regardless of Whitebeard's already stated protection) and respects the late Queen's desire for peace. Hodi and his gang, on the other hand, see Jinbei's actions as a cop out and choose to follow "Arlong's Will".
Thoughts?
-
Queen Otohime wasn't murdered by some last-minute new villain. She was killed by Arlong.
I find it hard to agree on this.
After Fisher Tiger's death, Arlong (already known to be violent and disliking humans) takes it to another level and declares war on all humans. This declaration is known as "Arlong's Will" and serves to inspire many fishmen, including Hodi.
Otohime insists on her ideals, and this leads to her confront Arlong, which ends up with her death.If someone has to declare war to humans after Tiger's death, it'd better be Jinbe (prior to his change of heart as what you are stating). We saw in the last chapter how he despised humans and ceased to believe Otohime's advocacy more than Arlong.
Arlong's will is true and loyal (not unlike Hodi's) so killing one of his kind will just break the essence of that in the first place. We know how he values his raise and that's part of his will. We saw how he reacted when his crew got beaten by Zoro back in Cocoyashi. He might be a jackass but I don't think he can kill a merman/fishman.
These events make Jinbei reconsider his hatred towards humans and realize all this would cause only more unnecessary deaths and pain on both sides. However, Arlong's presence in Fishmen Island is unacceptable, especially with Otohime's family still around.
Jinbei, probably because of his past relationship with Arlong, decides to banish him from the island, instead of killing/putting him into jail, at the same time striking a deal with the Marines to become a shichibukai, in a way to protect his former Sun Pirates associates and reduce the risk of an attack against Fishman Island (and to further aid Whitebeard in protecting the area).
Its an assasination so how the hell did Jinbe know of it? Unless his one of the masterminds in which you are stating I presume is just Arlong. And if ever someone spilled the beans to Jinbe, do you think he'll just let him go? Jinbe the same as Arlong follow's Tiger's principle of fighting for their kind (not killing them) so it does not make sense that he just let merfolk-killing-Arlong slip away and worse let him loose and cause havoc in other seas.
-
Arlong's will is true and loyal (not unlike Hodi's) so killing one of his kind will just break the essence of that in the first place. We know how he values his raise and that's part of his will. We saw how he reacted when his crew got beaten by Zoro back in Cocoyashi. He might be a jackass but I don't think he can kill a merman/fishman.
The general consensus that a single scene from chapter 73 (check it at http://www.mangareader.net/103-2180-16/one-piece/chapter-73.html) makes Arlong unable to EVER hurt/kill one of his "brethen" (that's the translation, not sure if it's accurate) is kinda overrated, imo. He could simply be pissed off at somene daring to infiltrate his up-until-now invincible stronghold. He's still Arlong, the one villain portrayed as a total bastard with no chance of redemption. It's an extreme situation, where Arlong could have lost it after his hero's death, and when confronted with Otohime, ended up killing her.
There's nothing stating what exactly is "Arlong's Will", much less if it involves not hurting/killing his kind. If that rule exists, Hodi has already broken it by using one of his crewmates as a shield.
Though, I do agree that the circunstances that lead to Jinbei letting Arlong go, one way or other, are pretty confusing right now.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Actually, reconsidering my own goddamn theory, I just noticed that while Otohime's "incident" (most likely the assassination) happened 10 years ago (http://www.mangareader.net/one-piece/615/17) while Jinbei set Arlong free into East Blue 11 years ago (http://www.mangareader.net/one-piece/619/15), what kinda kills my theory, apparently. Duh :P
-
Hodi is the son of a fishman who was enslaved/killed. That's why he's so pissed with humans.
He might even be the son of Tiger, which would be a twist.
-
@Mr.:
Hodi is the son of a fishman who was enslaved/killed. That's why he's so pissed with humans.
He might even be the son of Tiger, which would be a load of sh*t.
16 char of fixed
-
Its not a theory but just a clue?
http://read.mangashare.com/One-Piece/chapter-594/page006.html
The Doctor looks to me, similiar to this guy(middle panel, right.)
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/58373218/8
what do you think? :)
-
Its not a theory but just a clue?
http://read.mangashare.com/One-Piece/chapter-594/page006.html
The Doctor looks to me, similiar to this guy(middle panel, right.)
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/58373218/8
what do you think? :)
Nose is completely off. :P
-
Its not a theory but just a clue?
http://read.mangashare.com/One-Piece/chapter-594/page006.html
The Doctor looks to me, similiar to this guy(middle panel, right.)
http://mangastream.com/read/one_piece/58373218/8
what do you think? :)
Differences - Glasses - Goatee - chin shape - Lip thickness - Hair goes from light coloured Mohawk to dark black curly. But granted there is a 15 year time difference or so. What it probably is, is just a generic face shape which is pretty common when drawing large number of faces.
-
Alright, alright I get it. FINE… I will not cry...
That was meant to be a friendly comment. Besides, I guess I can see where you were going with your theory, but… well, yeah.
-
Otohime's death will be due to a fracture.
-
-
I went on One Piece wiki timekine.
I had goosebumps when I saw Tashigi and Kuina being born in the same exact year.
Either it is a twin or its Kuina. -
I think the story will advance very differently in the New world. Instead of giving us a different story arc every time the SH get to a new island we'll get large expanses of time between adventures. In between these important adventures the SH will have visited many places off-panel. So instead of days or or a small handful of weeks sailing from place to place months will have transpired before another important arc.
This way the SH will not conquer the Grand Line and defeat Kaidou, Teach, Akainu, etc. before Luffy is even 21 years old. Instead of getting gradually stronger each arc where they face a villain able to push them to their limits these time elapses will allow them to gain many victories under their belts providing big power boosts before meeting an opponent who forces them to go all out. This makes more sense than them always having just the necessary amount of strength to deal with whatever threat each Island presents until gradually they are ready for the top tiers. Also makes more sense than the idea they are already close to top tiers and just need some NW hardships for that final push.
I like this idea because it provides a logical way for Zoro and Sanji to master Haki. I don't think they learned it at all over the time skip. Zoro may have some natural talent and a basic understanding of it from Mihawk but not enough to just start using it casually like Luffy. I see no reason at all why Sanji would know anything of it. Even if they both somehow know a lot about it their training wasn't focused on it like Luffy's and he trained with a Haki master. They need at least need half as much time as Luffy got to focus on it; half since they are much stronger than when Luffy started training but still a while because they have no real teacher. I think they'll learn slowly to use it from Luffy during these long time elapses. Not that Luffy is training them just that they observe Luffy using it in combat ask for some pointers and take it from there.
I like it. It should be clear that the 2nd part of One Piece won't go the same as the 1st part, the question is how.
-
I think the story will advance very differently in the New world. Instead of giving us a different story arc every time the SH get to a new island we'll get large expanses of time between adventures. In between these important adventures the SH will have visited many places off-panel. So instead of days or or a small handful of weeks sailing from place to place months will have transpired before another important arc.
This way the SH will not conquer the Grand Line and defeat Kaidou, Teach, Akainu, etc. before Luffy is even 21 years old. Instead of getting gradually stronger each arc where they face a villain able to push them to their limits these time elapses will allow them to gain many victories under their belts providing big power boosts before meeting an opponent who forces them to go all out. This makes more sense than them always having just the necessary amount of strength to deal with whatever threat each Island presents until gradually they are ready for the top tiers. Also makes more sense than the idea they are already close to top tiers and just need some NW hardships for that final push.
I like this idea because it provides a logical way for Zoro and Sanji to master Haki. I don't think they learned it at all over the time skip. Zoro may have some natural talent and a basic understanding of it from Mihawk but not enough to just start using it casually like Luffy. I see no reason at all why Sanji would know anything of it. Even if they both somehow know a lot about it their training wasn't focused on it like Luffy's and he trained with a Haki master. They need at least need half as much time as Luffy got to focus on it; half since they are much stronger than when Luffy started training but still a while because they have no real teacher. I think they'll learn slowly to use it from Luffy during these long time elapses. Not that Luffy is training them just that they observe Luffy using it in combat ask for some pointers and take it from there.
This… This Would be very romantic indeed!
But I think important things like Haki will of course be learnt on-panel.
-
@Mr.:
Hodi is the son of a fishman who was enslaved/killed. That's why he's so pissed with humans.
He might even be the son of Tiger, which would be a twist.
I was actually the first to predict this back in v.1
-
That's maybe why Jinbei don't want Luffy to fight Hodi, because he wants to protect the son of his big idol Fisher Tiger?
-
This makes more sense than them always having just the necessary amount of strength to deal with whatever threat each Island presents until gradually they are ready for the top tiers. Also makes more sense than the idea they are already close to top tiers and just need some NW hardships for that final push.
That is a pretty interesting take on the future. I don't see any more time elapses than what we had in the first half but who knows what Oda will do. I just don't agree with that statement there. I remember what specifically drew me to One Piece was that the Straw Hats were always leagues above their opponents. Though there was always some handicap or a "trick" the enemy could pull to sway the balance of the fight a bit, Luffy/Zoro/Sanji were almost always leagues ahead of the enemy.
I say the few times where the Straw Hats had just enough strength were with Croc and his gang, Lucci/Luffy, Chopper/Gedetsu/Kamudori, Nami/Kalifa, Oars and Moriah. Besides that everyone else stalled out the straw hats a bit but were ultimately completely outclassed by them.
Don't get me wrong I know they will have tough battles from here on out, but judging by the power up it will take a real big shot to put up a great fight with Straw Hats. Seems to me the series more or less restarted itself with how strong the Straw Hats are compared to everyone else.
-
I'm gonna take a random guess and say Jinbe doesn't want them to fight because he knows Luffy will win, and it will just give more reason for Fishman inspired by Hodi and Arlong to continue the cause.
-
@Mr.:
Who told you to fix my quote? I'm entertaining the idea.
I'm not saying oda would never do that, I would just hate it. I would be the same as if we learned that bellamy was whitebeard's (biological) son
-
@Sonic:
This… This Would be very romantic indeed!
But I think important things like Haki will of course be learnt on-panel.
We'll learn more about Haki every time Luffy uses it in battle. I'm saying Zoro and Sanji will learn it off panel and just use it more and more proficiently every arc. No different than how DJ and Gears were developed off-panel.
That is a pretty interesting take on the future. I don't see any more time elapses than what we had in the first half but who knows what Oda will do. I just don't agree with that statement there. I remember what specifically drew me to One Piece was that the Straw Hats were always leagues above their opponents. Though there was always some handicap or a "trick" the enemy could pull to sway the balance of the fight a bit, Luffy/Zoro/Sanji were almost always leagues ahead of the enemy.
I say the few times where the Straw Hats had just enough strength were with Croc and his gang, Lucci/Luffy, Chopper/Gedetsu/Kamudori, Nami/Kalifa, Oars and Moriah. Besides that everyone else stalled out the straw hats a bit but were ultimately completely outclassed by them.
Don't get me wrong I know they will have tough battles from here on out, but judging by the power up it will take a real big shot to put up a great fight with Straw Hats. Seems to me the series more or less restarted itself with how strong the Straw Hats are compared to everyone else.
There are plenty of big shots in the New World and I would hope the SH aren't already on par with commanders like Jozu and Vista and stronger than Vice Admirals, strong NW pirates, Level 6 inmates, strong Island natives, and others living there for years. Fighters from now on will be the whole package(skill, power, and trickery) like Mag not reliant on gimmicks like before. SH should have plenty of opportunities to be pushed.
The New World is huge so it doesn't make sense to conquer it from just visiting a handful of Islands. My idea also lets the SH actually say they have visited most of the Grand Line not just an opportunity for a logical strength progression between arcs. SH won't receive any more power-ups so the only logical progression they can make is with time. Just doesn't sit well with me that some talented kids appear and outclass vets like Squado and Momonga. Then gain enough strength in only a few months to rival the Yonkou and Admirals from a handful of battles.
-
Luffy is going to make fishman island rise to the surface. Then a full on raid on to Mariejois to free slaves. They will also free Jewelry Bonney in the process .
-
@moe:
Luffy is going to make fishman island rise to the surface.
I don't think I've read this before, seems like something Oda would do. Great idea.
-
@moe:
Luffy is going to make fishman island rise to the surface. Then a full on raid on to Mariejois to free slaves. They will also free Jewelry Bonney in the process .
This isn't Naruto.
-
I'm not saying oda would never do that, I would just hate it. I would be the same as if we learned that bellamy was whitebeard's (biological) son
I think it would dispel the "like father, like son" notion. Good/strong fathers can have cruel/weak sons and vice versa. Hodi isn't weak IMO but he certainly is vicious. From what I can tell from Tiger thus far he seems like the Luffy type. I can see Hodi turning out bad if his father wasn't around and he grew up in the fishman district by himself.
It would explain why Jinbei doesn't want Luffy to fight him. Maybe he feels responsible for Hodi because he was supposed to watch out for him and he feels like he failed since hodi turned into such an asshole. Then again there are numerous reasons why Jinbei doesn't want Luffy to fight Hodi if that were not the case.
-
-
@Mr.:
I think it would dispel the "like father, like son" notion. Good/strong fathers can have cruel/weak sons and vice versa. Hodi isn't weak IMO but he certainly is vicious. From what I can tell from Tiger thus far he seems like the Luffy type. I can see Hodi turning out bad if his father wasn't around and he grew up in the fishman district by himself.
It would explain why Jinbei doesn't want Luffy to fight him. Maybe he feels responsible for Hodi because he was supposed to watch out for him and he feels like he failed since hodi turned into such an asshole. Then again there are numerous reasons why Jinbei doesn't want Luffy to fight Hodi if that were not the case.
I thought about this after posting, but I still think it would be a stupid plot point. Also, I wouldn't mind the character difference if he didn't just get 1hkoed by zolo. You'd think that "the man who scaled 10k of sheer cliff and then single handedly took on what is pretty much the capital of the world" 's loins would have produced someone who could back up his bark with some bite and not plot convenience drugs.
-
The Usopp pirates could be later real pirates who will emboss the era after Luffy became PK.
-
Since it is a pretty well accepted fact that Devil Fruits reappear after the owner's death my theory is that the Goverment/Marines have been capturing the person with Jewelry Bonney's fruit for the past 500 years to keep the Five Elder Stars young forever.
-
Since it is a pretty well accepted fact that Devil Fruits reappear after the owner's death my theory is that the Goverment/Marines have been capturing the person with Jewelry Bonney's fruit for the past 500 years to keep the Five Elder Stars young forever.
If that were the case then Bonney's bounty would be like one billion. You can bet that if the Elder Stars are desperate to get a hold of her then her bounty would be ridiculously high.
-
@Mr.:
If that were the case then Bonney's bounty would be like one billion. You can bet that if the Elder Stars are desperate to get a hold of her then her bounty would be ridiculously high.
Everyone seems to have this idea they'll just boost the bounty up into the billions if someone is worth it. The point of the bounty's are to say "We are willing to pay this much money if someone captures her". Bounty hunters aren't going to go after someone in the millions. Considering she was captured, she's not Whitebeard level. If the government did want her for her fruit, they'd measure how strong they think she is, look into her committed crimes, and give a number that strong bounty hunters would be interested in capturing her for.
-
So I have this theory that I like to post every now and then and since this is a new thread I guess I'll re post it because I feel it's worth it. :3
Not much light has been shed of the past back before the WG was initially founded and the Blank Century.
You see I think there's a connection to all Devil Fruits and Haki users.A long time ago, I believe they weren't used for fighting, and instead I believe they were used for life applications.
i.e
Lava - for creating more land for further growth in the country.
Light - Pretty self explanatory.
Fire- to heat and mend and melt and cook etc.Anywho, the people of that nation worked together with their special abilities to live and prosper.
This is where I think haki comes into play.
The other nation, who didn't have the perk of having Devil fruits grow or appear in
there land, had to find another way to survive the harsh weather and cruel land conditions that they lived with. In comes the use of Haki.Now some where the "D" falls in line but I can't really figure that part out hahaha but this is what I have so far. :'D
-
So I have this theory that I like to post every now and then and since this is a new thread I guess I'll re post it because I feel it's worth it. :3
Not much light has been shed of the past back before the WG was initially founded and the Blank Century.
You see I think there's a connection to all Devil Fruits and Haki users.A long time ago, I believe they weren't used for fighting, and instead I believe they were used for life applications.
i.e
Lava - for creating more land for further growth in the country.
Light - Pretty self explanatory.
Fire- to heat and mend and melt and cook etc.Anywho, the people of that nation worked together with their special abilities to live and prosper.
This is where I think haki comes into play.
The other nation, who didn't have the perk of having Devil fruits grow or appear in
there land, had to find another way to survive the harsh weather and cruel land conditions that they lived with. In comes the use of Haki.Now some where the "D" falls in line but I can't really figure that part out hahaha but this is what I have so far. :'D
What possible use could there have been for zoans then? And before you say for better manual labor then i have to ask why a phoenix or a dinosaur when engineering would be far more effective, and for that matter wouldn't it be pretty perverse that the soap fruit user would have to be some sort of unisex bathroom attendant for everyone?
-
Lola's mom is Big Mam.
has this been discussed?
-
-
Is it me or they kinda look similar.
!
!
! I wonder if it implies that Zoro will be dominated by his future wife as well if he is carrying on the old geezer's dreams
-
Is it me or they kinda look similar.
I wonder if it implies that Zoro will be dominated by his future wife as well if he is carrying on the old geezer's dreams.coughBonneycough
-
So I have this theory that I like to post every now and then and since this is a new thread I guess I'll re post it because I feel it's worth it. :3
Not much light has been shed of the past back before the WG was initially founded and the Blank Century.
You see I think there's a connection to all Devil Fruits and Haki users.A long time ago, I believe they weren't used for fighting, and instead I believe they were used for life applications.
i.e
Lava - for creating more land for further growth in the country.
Light - Pretty self explanatory.
Fire- to heat and mend and melt and cook etc.Anywho, the people of that nation worked together with their special abilities to live and prosper.
This is where I think haki comes into play.
The other nation, who didn't have the perk of having Devil fruits grow or appear in
there land, had to find another way to survive the harsh weather and cruel land conditions that they lived with. In comes the use of Haki.Now some where the "D" falls in line but I can't really figure that part out hahaha but this is what I have so far. :'D
This seems more like fan fiction than an actual theory. Maybe next time provide evidence…
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
I started to re-read the Fishman Island Arc, the more I learn about Hodi the less I think he is "main villian material." Madam Shirely on the other hand has peaked my interest. What if she lied about Luffy destroying Fishman Island and is really pulling the strings? If this was talked about already I apologize.
-
@Mr.:
coughBonneycough
She has to compete with Perona.
Zoro's getting all the pink haired chicks. Watch out, Smoker. He's eying your woman!
-
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
I started to re-read the Fishman Island Arc, the more I learn about Hodi the less I think he is "main villian material." Madam Shirely on the other hand has peaked my interest. What if she lied about Luffy destroying Fishman Island and is really pulling the strings? If this was talked about already I apologize.
It surprises me to see that I've never assumed that, as of yet. To be honest, I believe that the idea is plausibly probable, because of Oda's occasional tendency to shock us with his diversity of characters, but also unlikely. Then again, because of the peculiar pace in which Oda is moving, I guess we can't say anything for sure until we come across her name again, later on in the story.
But now that you've brought such a theory up, I suppose I shall be looking out for any mention of her in the future; apparently, while a majority of myself believes that she's only a fairly minor character who will play a mediocre (at the least) to a memorable (max) role, a small portion also believes that you may actually be on to something, and she could be something more vital to the storyline.
Whatever the case, this is one of those ideas that are either incredibly stupid, or impressively smart, so until then, I guess we'll have to wait and see what happens.
-
This seems more like fan fiction than an actual theory. Maybe next time provide evidence…
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
I started to re-read the Fishman Island Arc, the more I learn about Hodi the less I think he is "main villian material." Madam Shirely on the other hand has peaked my interest. What if she lied about Luffy destroying Fishman Island and is really pulling the strings? If this was talked about already I apologize.
Sounds more like fan fiction to me. unless you have clear evidence.
jk. But seriously, it's called a theory. Everything sounds like Fan fiction until proven otherwise. So that's not a really good comment.