@AGOG:
Obviously, you know the difference between "randoms" and a character that had a leading role in an Arc, right?
Yes; I also know that Hancock and Jinbei are much more relevant to the plot than Perona has been, and there's no concrete evidence that Perona will become relevant to the plot later.
Ummm… Well, explain it then. As far as anyone can tell, Perona isn't happy, nor does she know Kuma. Maybe, Kuma's power works somehow where he can send people to "islands" for some strange reason-- WHO KNOWS WHY THIS HAPPENED...
Point is that they're there, and unless you wish to start picking up some choice, stop wasting my time...
Again, you're completely ignoring the fact that a good deal of the crew (if not all of them) appear to have been sent where they were for a reason, and if Kuma had only wanted someone to patch Zoro up and guide him back to Shabondy, he would have chosen a more populated island where they'd be more willing to help, rather than an island where a recent enemy of the crew's was sent to. There has to be an in-character reason as to why Zoro was sent there, and the swordsperson would be the more likely option.
Ummm… Perona would get hurt, and that doesn't assist the issue of him being lost, needing directions, etc. But believe as you wish, regardless if it is a horrible idea to have the main "power" exist before the New World...
And you wouldn't be able to stand the sight of your favourite character in pain, so it's obviously not going to happen.[/sarcasm] Luffy's used Haki before they entered the New World, so your comment is kind of pointless. I'm merely trying to think of reasons as to why Zoro was sent to the island that would make sense; Kuma wouldn't send him there just so he could meet Perona again, when Perona would have no reason to help him, and Kuma seemed to have some kind of reason for the destinations of most of the crew.
Ummm… Do as you wish, but chances are high that he's dead.
And, once again, you're ignoring what's been shown in the series in order to claim that your fantasies are correct.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/477/05/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/477/06/
Moria can teleport to some extent, and once he starts, he can't be stopped. In addition, unlike Ace, Whitebeard, and the flashback deaths, we never saw him being killed, saw the body, or had anyone saying after the fact that he had died. Given how rarely Oda kills characters, and how little Moria's death at that time would mean in terms of moving the story forward, I doubt that he would be killed off in that manner.
You don't see the STUPIDITY that you stated? Do you not read well enough to pick up that I said, "someone wanted a fucking LINK and I gave them a FUCKING link?"
A link where, as you admitted, had nothing to do with the discussion for at least 3/4 of the content, given that you said the first part was listing facts about Perona (which any site, such as the One Piece Wikia could do), and the first half of the second part was (in your own words) a parody of deluded fans.
The fact that you continually cannot do anything over it shows that it isn't baseless speculation since I've already countered any pointless attempt to argue against said point. I've already created a thorough consistent argument that has no weakness.
That's a bit smug and conceited of you, isn't it? Both the theories that I've brought up and the theories that you've brought up are speculation; many people have countered your theories time and time again, yet whenever they do, you say "NO" and move on, acting like you've somehow won. Ignoring the evidence does not count as winning. You can't say your theories have no weakness, particularly when there are many, many weaknesses to be addressed, primarily with the matter of the crew trusting Perona enough to let her sail with them despite the fact that her assistance has been relatively minor.
I'll be the first to admit that my arguments have some weaknesses, but at least I'm willing to admit to them rather than ignore them completely. The arguments for most characters have some kind of weakness (Hancock - has her island to protect, Jinbei - doesn't have much backstory or personality yet, Perona - her self-centered personality, the crew not having a reason to accept her, her fighting style being broken and limited with no easily-accessable weakness), and whether the weaknesses to these arguments will be removed or maintained depends entirely on Oda.
Nyon: "if you go with him to central, this decision will save you…"
You're using that quote entirely out of context.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/523/02/
Nyon believed that going to Marineford would be able to help her get over her crush on Luffy (in other words, her Love Sickness) and keep the island safe at the same time. However, as evidenced later, the first part did not work.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/582/07/
The Love Sickness still has to be dealt with, and if Luffy left without resolving it, she would die, and Luffy wouldn't want that to happen, seeing as she's his friend.
Yes, therefore, she has to fucking stay on her island if the story moves on with Luffy alive, not dead.
Plus, Nyon says it best… LS is probable to have had its cure already completed.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/582/07/
Boa's crush is strong, relatively speaking when compared to Nyon's own experiences with love. As well, Nyon left the island for an undetermined period of time despite being the empress, which would have helped her get over it.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/521/19/
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/523/05/
Oda's story writing isn't romantic, therefore, it won't have that shit. She's not joining because of that shit, and for fuck's sake, she's got an ISLAND that she must watch and save…
Really? Then what other alternatives are there? He wouldn't just sit back and let her die when he can do something about it. He could say something that Hancock misinterprets as a more romantic gesture (as she's done often in the past) and allows her to believe that Luffy will return, but that one might not necessarily stick, and the odds are, he wouldn't be able to return without an Eternal Pose or a way to bypass the Calm Belt, so that wouldn't really provide any closure on the matter. Still, it seems about fifty-fifty between Luffy taking Hancock with him or saying something she misinterprets, which are much better odds than Perona joining the crew when she offers very little in terms of future plot development.
As well, Boa's crush on Luffy seems like Sanji's actions around women; it may be more focused, but the chances of it developing further than comedic effect are slim.
Or, all that MF events that she did were purposely done that way so she could counter her stupid "fake-illness" that couldn't ever exist and save her island: meaning, she's not going to have a buster call attack her.
Except, you know, that didn't work.
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/582/07/
It's not a literal disease; she has a crush on Luffy, and if Luffy leaves and nothing's done about it, she'll be too depressed to eat and will eventually die. The only people to say that it's a disease are Amazons who know very little about romance in general.