Just like the title says, if you were to make a remake of the One Piece anime,
would you keep any of the filler from the original, and if so what?
If you were to redo the One Piece anime, what filler would you remove/keep?
-
-
Just like the title says, if you were to make a remake of the One Piece anime,
would you keep any of the filler from the original, and if so what?I think the only thing I would really change is omit Apis, Goat Island, and Rainbow Mist because those were a true waste of time. I would also adapt ALL the cover story arcs and place them in their appropriate places.
O-chan
-
- Rainbow Mist and probably Apis' deal.
- cover stories, for sure.
-
For me, I would keep/add:
- Cover Stories
- Loguetown Filler
- Fake Rebel Army Alabasta Arc Ep
- Robin/Chopper, Sanji & Zoro Post-Alabasta Eps
- G-8 Arc
- Ice Hunters
- Straw Hat Separation Filler Expansions
I would remove:
- Sennenryu/Apis/Warship Island Arc
- Other Alabasta Desert Fillers
- Nami & Usopp Post-Alabasta eps
- Goat Island Arc
- Rainbow Mist Arc
- Davy Back Fight extension
- Memory Loss Arc
- Foxy's Return
- Enies Lobby Fillers
- Post Enies Lobby Filler eps
- Spa Island
-
For me, I would keep/add:
- Cover Stories
- Loguetown Filler
- Fake Rebel Army Alabasta Arc Ep
- Robin/Chopper, Sanji & Zoro Post-Alabasta Eps
- G-8 Arc
- Ice Hunters
- Straw Hat Separation Filler Expansions
I would remove:
- Sennenryu/Apis/Warship Island Arc
- Other Alabasta Desert Fillers
- Nami & Usopp Post-Alabasta eps
- Goat Island Arc
- Rainbow Mist Arc
- Davy Back Fight extension
- Memory Loss Arc
- Foxy's Return
- Enies Lobby Fillers
- Post Enies Lobby Filler eps
- Spa Island
This, except I'd probably keep the DBF extensions and the Memory Loss arc…and Sanji and Zoro's EL fillers...and mabye the other Alabasta fillers...
-
I would remove all filler except the Loguetown one and MAYBE G-8, memory loss, and some of the SH separation filler. Also would give the episodes from Enies Lobby onward Dragon Ball Kai treatment and fix the terrible color schemes they chose for some characters to their real ones.
-
I would remove all filler except the Loguetown one and MAYBE G-8, memory loss, and some of the SH separation filler. Also would give the episodes from Enies Lobby onward Dragon Ball Kai treatment and fix the terrible color schemes they chose for some characters to their real ones.
Yeah I would increase pacing of Enies Lobby and Thriller Bark to Alabasta-pacing.
-
For me, I would keep/add:
- Cover Stories
- Loguetown Filler
- Fake Rebel Army Alabasta Arc Ep
- Robin/Chopper, Sanji & Zoro Post-Alabasta Eps
- G-8 Arc
- Ice Hunters
- Straw Hat Separation Filler Expansions
I would remove:
- Sennenryu/Apis/Warship Island Arc
- Other Alabasta Desert Fillers
- Nami & Usopp Post-Alabasta eps
- Goat Island Arc
- Rainbow Mist Arc
- Davy Back Fight extension
- Memory Loss Arc
- Foxy's Return
- Enies Lobby Fillers
- Post Enies Lobby Filler eps
- Spa Island
Same for me, too. Cover stories especially. Their omission was just wrong, I tel you! Wrong!
-
Everything goes except Daddy the Father.
-
For me, I would keep/add:
- Robin/Chopper, Sanji & Zoro Post-Alabasta Eps
I would remove:
- Post Enies Lobby Filler eps
Hm, i thought the character-fillers after Enies Lobby (317-319) were much better than the post-Alabasta ones, especially Sanji's. Zoro's was fun.
Only fillers i'd actually remove entirely would be the said post-Alabasta episodes. That was the anime at its worst, hands down.
-
The only fillers that I would completely eradicate are the ones in and after Alabasta. Warship Island had a few sequences that I liked and featured the voice talent of Ryuusei Nakao, Ocean's Dream was decent, though I think that they could've done a little bit more with it, Ice Hunters was all right, despite the Phoenix Pirates being a bit of a disappointment, and Spa Island had good art, was short, had filler children that weren't annoying as all get out, more Ryuusei Nakao, and fanservice.
I guess unlike evryone else, I feel that the anime can continue to survive without the non-Straw Hat coverstories.
-
Hm, i thought the character-fillers after Enies Lobby (317-319) were much better than the post-Alabasta ones, especially Sanji's. Zoro's was fun.
Only fillers i'd actually remove entirely would be the said post-Alabasta episodes. That was the anime at its worst, hands down.
Well, in all honesty I skipped the Post-Enies Lobby fillers because I heard how disgustingly awful/boring they were. Sanji's episode was the weakest of the Post-Alabasta one, BUT, I think it was still pretty nice because they bring up All Blue again, and jumping to Jaya already after Skypiea in the anime would be a little too fast for me, so yeah. 3 episodes would be a good break.
-
I would remove Warship Island, Rainbow Mist, and some Alabasta filler.
I would also make the pacing of Enies Lobby much faster.
Davy Back Fight extension and Spa Island can stay.
-
BUT, I think it was still pretty nice because they bring up All Blue again, and jumping to Jaya already after Skypiea in the anime would be a little too fast for me, so yeah. 3 episodes would be a good break.
See, that's the thing. 319 not only brought the All Blue back, but in a much more inspired, interesting way, connecting it to Aqua Laguna and an old man that knew Zeff. It even had a couple of manga scenes and Tate's great job didn't hurt either.
317/318 were also far from being "disgustingly awful", in fact i remember these fillers were well received back then, so i dunno where you heard that.I agree with Crossword on the cover stories, i don't know if i could stand a whole episode of Enel walking on the moon or Wapol redeeming himself. I'd like to see the BW story, but it's nothing really essential…and we're about to see the best members again anyway.
-
Rainbow Mist, Ocean's Dream, and !@#$ING GOAT ISLAND all need to go.
-
I'd keep it the same.
-
-
Was Loguetown a filler? Interesting, this was the arc that got me hooked on One Piece.
-
i think i would keep everything and jus add the cover stories
-
Was Loguetown a filler? Interesting, this was the arc that got me hooked on One Piece.
The fact that you don't know means you haven't read the manga which makes you an idiot.
-
@Karate:
The fact that you don't know means you haven't read the manga which makes you an idiot.
Oh come on now….
-
Oh come on now….
Someone not reading Oda's actual work is just ridiculous.
There's no good reason to skip the actual source material.
-
You mean other than not wanting to spend the time reading something you've already seen?
-
You mean other than not wanting to spend the time reading something you've already seen?
Yeah because that's the only worth a story has, a one time go through, then toss it aside like a condom.
Great argument doofus.
-
@Karate:
Yeah because that's the only worth a story has, a one time go through, then toss it aside like a condom.
Great argument doofus.
Can you please actually post something that hasn't have to do with insulting someone else, swearing, being an ass or arguing?
-
Can you please actually post something that hasn't have to do with insulting someone else, swearing, being an ass or arguing?
I will if you can define the appropriate storyline wherein it happens.
-
sorry wolf, but he is definitely completely 100% right. xD
what gives?
anyways, i'd keep g8, but that'd be pretty much it, i think….....unless im fergetting one.
-
sorry wolf, but he is definitely completely 100% right. xD
what gives?
Yeah, but he doesn't have to be a dick about it. There's a way of saying things. But I agree with him on Daddy the Father…Daddy Masterson is the MAN.
-
@Karate:
Yeah because that's the only worth a story has, a one time go through, then toss it aside like a condom.
Great argument doofus.
Ahhh, that explains it.
Don't worry, once you grow up and have to move out of your parent's house and get a job, you'll understand all too well the meaning of "I just don't have the time."
-
Ahhh, that explains it.
Don't worry, once you grow up and have to move out of your parent's house and get a job, you'll understand all too well the meaning of "I just don't have the time."
"Ahahaha yes, the time you have to download the anime torrents and watch the episodes that cover the same material the manga does but using 20 minute lag fest vision, and participate in this forum, as well as get mad at random anonymous people for chiding you."
-Me, posting from my apartment in the middle of midterms week after spending a whole weekend preparing an informative speech, writing a screenplay, and analyzing the mythic structure in Apocalypse Now for a paper and paying my rent -
Don't even fucking respond to that, you're done.
-
@Karate:
-Me, posting from my mom's apartment in the middle of high school midterms week after spending a whole weekend preparing an informative speech for second period English, writing a Luffy/Usopp slashfic, and getting high while watching Apocalypse Now for a paper and doing my chores
Fixed for you.
Anyway, yes, I do have time to watch One Piece, because I make time for it, because I like watching the anime. I have no inclination to make additional time to follow the manga of a show I'm already watching. Likewise, I don't spend my time watching anime of shows I'm following through manga. (of course, two of those manga had anime adaptations by Bee Train so that's pretty much turned me off on the whole deal…)
@Karate:
Don't even fucking respond to that, you're done.
You are adorable. I think I'll keep you as a pet.
"And _One Piece is a great title. We feel we needed to do the
more authentic dub that's exactly like the Japanese version."_
- Gen Fukunaga, CEO and Founder of Funimation
-
I didn't mind most of the filler arcs all though they almost always fit the same formula, with the same little kid who is always annoying. That being said I would definitely leave out this weird dragon arc that happened before the grand line which was just horrible.
-
mickgreen58, here's a genuine answer for you:
Loguetown itself is not filler but the arc contains episodes that are. If you have the time to read online, start at chapter 96 and stop at the end of chapter 100.
Spoiler:
Originally Posted by Kaze no Barako
Well, Ace breathes heavily and calls him 'Gramps'. :P
oh god that sounds wrong please nobody take that out of context
-
Is that what's considered a burn now on Arlong Park forums? Changing people's posts with 3rd grade "u live with ur mom" jokes?
Hey, you work with what you've got. I'm trying not to confuse the kid with anything he wouldn't understand.
Let me try
FIXED FOR YOU!!!
LOL LOL LOL
OWNED
Dick jokes? Really? And the laughing isn't funny, just obnoxious. Have some self-respect. Trust in your jokes.
1/10. I'd give you a 2/10 for effort, but I really don't think your heart was in it.
-
I'll redo Skypiea completely, save a the episode with Luffy vs Wiper and Luffy facing Eneru for the 1st time. That arc needed some richer colors.
-
mickgreen58, here's a genuine answer for you:
Loguetown itself is not filler but the arc contains episodes that are. If you have the time to read online, start at chapter 96 and stop at the end of chapter 100.
Thanks for the info.
-
I haven't seen many filler arcs since I've only really watched up to Funi's Season One Fourth Voyage. But I did see the Rainbow Mist arc and even with 4kids voice acting I could see the shit oozing out of that entire arc and would be glad to be rid of it.
-
Fixed for you.
Anyway, yes, I do have time to watch One Piece, because I make time for it, because I like watching the anime. I have no inclination to make additional time to follow the manga of a show I'm already watching. Likewise, I don't spend my time watching anime of shows I'm following through manga. (of course, two of those manga had anime adaptations by Bee Train so that's pretty much turned me off on the whole deal…)
You are adorable. I think I'll keep you as a pet.
This is beyond immature
even for this forum
-
Fixed for you.
Hahaha, what was that supposed to accomplish.
Anyway, yes, I do have time to watch One Piece, because I make time for it, because I like watching the anime. I have no inclination to make additional time to follow the manga of a show I'm already watching.
So you never ever watch movies again.
Like all responsible adults.
Never look at entertainment twice! Insurance companies can fault you on that kiddos! strokes greying beardYeah so anyway, I'm probably older then you and I'm in any case not 13, so why do you think I would believe your bullshit about "time".
Likewise, I don't spend my time watching anime of shows I'm following through manga. (of course, two of those manga had anime adaptations by Bee Train so that's pretty much turned me off on the whole deal…)
The fact that your following the anime over the manga is the first retarded step in a long line of retarded roads here.
You are adorable. I think I'll keep you as a pet.
I know I don't really post in this section, but you should know you're at least in over your head even if you don't know who I am.
The burn level your capable of is not sustainable for one.
I mean look at this..Dick jokes? Really? And the laughing isn't funny, just obnoxious. Have some self-respect. Trust in your jokes.
If you can't follow sarcasm to save your life you have no chance here.
Now if you're so busy fuck off already. -
Oh god, the tears won't stop.
Of all the guys I saw Zephos arguing with, Charagon has to be the most retarded of them.
What an honor -
@Karate:
Hahaha, what was that supposed to accomplish.
Amusement at your expense.
@Karate:
So you never ever watch movies again.
Sadly, very rarely.
@Karate:
Yeah so anyway, I'm probably older then you and I'm in any case not 13, so why do you think I would believe your bullshit about "time".
Doubtful. Even if I were to believe you are in college as you imply, I'm well beyond that age. :
: so oooold. 
@Karate:
The fact that your following the anime over the manga is the first retarded step in a long line of retarded roads here.
Reading comprehension fail!
@Karate:
I know I don't really post in this section, but you should know you're at least in over your head even if you don't know who I am.
The burn level your capable of is not sustainable for one.He he he he he he. Oh man. You are just too much fun. Listen kid, you can posture all you want. We both know that's all it is.
I mean, look at you. Big guy with an attitude. Ooooo scary. You attack people with random insults and curses just to pretend you're the big dog.
But let's face reality here. You're nothing but insults and swears. You can't respond to a valid argument with anything but mindless barking. Hell, you're so scared of me that twice now you've tried to bluff me away.
Poor little puppy. All bark. No bite. You're not making me angry. You're not even hurting my feelings. You're just… amusing. Like a shiny new toy.
@Karate:
If you can't follow sarcasm to save your life you have no chance here.
Now if you're so busy fuck off already.Well gosh, I sure don't want the big scawry meany to hurt me. I better wun for the hills.
-
Both of you guys stop. While Karate D Frank has been the laughing stock in my neighborhood recently, Charagon you're also overdoing it. not trying to act like admin but come on
-
I'll throw us back on topic…
Hmm,I'd get read of every filler except the Where are the crew members now,and Spa Island ones. -
Speaking of Spa Island, that arc ended pretty poorly. I mean, you kidnap a little girl only to point a looooong cannon at her? Even by filler's standards or OP's standards, that's jumping the shark a bit too much.
-
Speaking of Spa Island, that arc ended pretty poorly. I mean, you kidnap a little girl only to point a looooong cannon at her? Even by filler's standards or OP's standards, that's jumping the shark a bit too much.
I'm a pervert so I just liked the ecchi factor in it!
-
Amusement at your expense.
It's the first part I'm not really grasping here.
Sadly, very rarely.
So you just lead a shitty life and want to pretend this is what it's like after moving out on your own, no sorry, you just have a shitty life.
But then get off the case of the rest of us, jealous son of a bitch.
Doubtful. Even if I were to believe you are in college as you imply, I'm well beyond that age. :
: so oooold. You burn people like a four year old.
Anyway I'll just pull the "Greg" card here.
Reading comprehension fail!
No I read it fine.
He he he he he he. Oh man. You are just too much fun. Listen kid, you can posture all you want. We both know that's all it is.
No actually it's true, I wouldn't flex it if it weren't.
I mean, look at you. Big guy with an attitude. Ooooo scary. You attack people with random insults and curses just to pretend you're the big dog.
I attack people with those things when they say dumb things.
Can't have one without the other.
You fit the bill as well.But let's face reality here. You're nothing but insults and swears.
No, I'm really really sorry, but this isn't true.
Like, you really don't even know how wrong this is.One word for you to toss in the thread search, "China".
You can't respond to a valid argument with anything but mindless barking. Hell, you're so scared of me that twice now you've tried to bluff me away.
Your argument is some terrible "I CANT WATCH ANYTHING TWICE BECAUSE IM AN OLD FART" schlock.
I countered that fact already, several times and ways.
Unless you have some heavy duty job or something, bullshit. And if you do, fuck off anyway, because then I wasn't talking to you to begin with.
Poor little puppy. All bark. No bite. You're not making me angry. You're not even hurting my feelings. You're just… amusing. Like a shiny new toy.
I should come into these side forums more often lol, I love me this cluelessness.
Well gosh, I sure don't want the big scawry meany to hurt me. I better wun for the hills.
It's going to take an act of Mod to end this, so yeah, you better.
-
I loved G-8. It's not Oda, but it's the next best thing. Otherwise I would keep cover stories and in the One Piece spirit have the filler arcs be a little more fun and random, a little less drama.
and for god's sake cut the apis arc. whatever it's called.…............................................... .........
-
I would probably put more cover stories in place of filler.
Having not read the manga I've missed out on a lot of them. =(
