I've been tracking these since the First Round began, so here they are:
Total First Round votes
! Monkey D. Garp vs Rob Lucci 261
Pandaman vs Calgara 256
Wapol v Jabura 301
Jambarl vs Magellan 315
Carue vs Minotarus 322
Smoker vs Domino 319
Coby vs Scratchman Apoo 348
Sanji vs Laboon 329
Nami vs X. Drake 364
Tony Tony Chopper vs Stronger 364
Alvida vs Van Augur 374
Jewelry Bonney vs Boa Hancock 404
Richie vs Sengoku 423
Funkfried vs Perona 413
Camie vs Mihawk 389
Hina vs Mr. 5 370
Aokiji vs Franky 412
Ryuma vs Jinbei 415
Lola vs Usopp 413
Ener vs Basil Hawkins 406
Gold D. Roger vs Kalifa 396
Jaguar D. Saul vs Gecko Moria 425
Lucky Roo vs Mr. 3 382
Pell vs Buggy 401
Emporio Ivankov vs Dr. Kureha 428
Margaret vs Nico Robin 442
Mohmoo vs Hatchan 383
Crocodile vs Vivi 427
Norla vs Shanks 389
Mr. 1 vs Bellemere 398
Marco vs Blueno 386
Luffy vs Spandam 436
Igaram vs Duval 407
Django vs Doktor Hogback 386
Marshall D. Teach vs Tashigi 401
Akainu vs Miss Goldenweek 378
Joz vs Donquixote DoFlamingo 388
Boa Sandersonia vs Aphelandra 398
Urouge vs Kizaru 472
Dragon vs Capone Bege 434
Benn Beckman vs Paulie 422
Going Merry vs Kuro 398
Arlong vs Hannyabal 408
Inazuma vs Bon Kurei 391
Bellamy vs Momonga 413
Calico Yorki vs Iceburg 405
Montblanc Cricket vs Foxy 403
Trafalgar Law vs Ohm 391
Roronoa Zoro vs Banchi 435
Bartholomew Kuma vs Portgas D. Ace 423
Tom vs Shackey 397
Yasopp vs Eustass Captain Kidd 428
Kumadori vs Kokoro 388
Absalom vs Don Krieg 413
ShuShu vs Lafitte 399
Odz vs Doc Hiruluk 403
Gin vs Kumacy 345
Zeff vs Jesus Burgess 386
Brook vs Silvers Rayleigh 417
Wiper vs Miss Valentine 384
Sadie-Chan vs Gedatsu 380
Bepo vs Nico Olvia 392
Whitebeard vs Kaku 406
Dorry vs Killer 356
! Average per match (rounded up): 390 votes
Individual Votes per character for the First Round
Italics mean the winner of a match while bold indicates a tie.
! Luffy 374
Usopp 366
Robin 351
DoFlamingo 346
Django 339
Gold Roger/Zeff 336
Crocodile 332
Law 325
Duval 313
Buggy 310
Zoro 307
Hiruluk 302
Shanks 295
Kidd 294
Hatchan/Momonga 286
Smoker/Perona 284
Dragon 283
Tom 280
Chopper 278
Going Merry 274
Mihawk 270
Ivankov 268
Magellan/Teach/Bon Kurei 264
Wiper 263
Franky/Boa Hancock/Iceburg/Brook 262
Jinbei 249
Ener 245
Urouge 243
Gin 240
Van Augur 239
Bepo 235
Sanji/Carue/Kumadori 233
Hannyabal 231
Miss Goldenweek 230
Kizaru 229
Shushu 225
Aphelandra 224
Hina 220
Bart 219
Moria/Gedatsu/Whitebeard 216
Nami 214
Richie 212
Sengoku/Paulie/Beckmann/Krieg 211
Saul 209
Mr. 3/Bellemere/Marco 207
Cricket 205
Ace 204
Absalom 202
Garp 199
Foxy 198
Mr. 1 191
Kaku 190
Dorry 186
Blueno 179
Arlong 177
Scratchman Apoo 176
Lucky Roo 175
Sandersonia/Lafitte 174
Jabura 173
Coby 172
Killer 170
Ryuma 166
Sadie 164
Basil Hawkins 161
Kureha 160
The Pandaman 159
Olvia 157
Kokoro/Rayleigh 155
Capone Bege 151
Mr. 5/Drake/Aokiji 150
Akainu 148
Yorki 143
Jewelry Bonney 142
Tashigi 137
Alvida 135
Yasopp 134
Funkfried 129
Wapol/Banchi 128
Inazuma/Bellamy 127
Kuro 124
Miss Valentine 121
Camie 119
Shackey 117
Kumacy 105
Odz 101
Calgara/Mohmoo 97
Laboon 96
Vivi 95
Norla/Igaram 94
Pell/Margaret 91
Minotaurus 89
Stronger 86
Ohm 66
Rob Lucci/Spandam 62
Califa 60
Jambarl 51
Burgess 50
Lola 47
Hogback 45
Joz 42
Domino 35
! Highest: Luffy
Lowest: Domino
Highest while still losing: Kizaru
Lowest while still winning: Pandaman
First Round by percentages
! DoFlamingo 89.82
Smoker 89.03
Usopp 88.62
Django 87.82
Zeff 87.05
Luffy 85.78
Gold Roger 84.85
Magellan 83.81
Law 83.12
Robin 79.41
Crocodile 77.75
Buggy 77.31
Duval 76.90
Chopper 76.37
Garp 76.25
Shanks 75.84
Hiruluk 74.94
Hatchan 74.67
Carue 72.36
Sanji 70.82
Zoro 70.57
Tom 70.53
Mihawk 69.41
Momonga 69.25
Merry 68.84
Perona 68.77
Kid 68.69
Wiper 68.49
Bon Kurei 67.52
Teach 65.84
Dragon 65.21
Hancock 64.85
Iceburg 64.69
Van Augur 63.90
Franky 63.59
Brook 62.83
Ivankov 62.62
Pandaman 62.11
Miss Goldenweek 60.85
Ener 60.34
Kumadori 60.05
Jinbei 60.00
Bepo 59.95
Hina 59.46
Nami 58.79
Jabura 57.48
Gedatsu 56.84
Hannyabal 56.62
Aphelandra 56.28
Shushu 56.14
Mr. 3 54.19
Marco 53.63
Whitebeard 53.20
Dorry 52.25
Bellemere 52.11
Bart 51.77
Urouge 51.48
Krieg 51.09
Cricket 50.87
Moria 50.82
Apoo 50.57
Richie 50.12
Paulie/Beckmann 50.00
Sengoku 49.88
Coby 49.43
Foxy 49.13
Saul 49.18
Absalom 48.91
Kizaru 48.52
Ace 48.23
Mr. 1 47.99
Killer 47.75
Kaku 46.80
Blueno 46.37
Lucky Roo 45.81
Lafitte 43.86
Sandersonia 43.72
Arlong 43.38
Sadie 43.16
Wapol 42.52
X. Drake 41.21
Mr. 5 40.54
Olvia 40.05
Ryuma 40.00
Kokoro 39.95
Akainu 39.15
Hawkins 39.66
Calgara 37.89
Kureha 37.38
Rayleigh 37.17
Aokiji 36.41
Alvida 36.10
Yorki 35.31
Bonney 35.15
Bege 34.79
Tashigi 34.16
Inazuma 32.48
Ms. Valentine 31.51
Yasopp 31.31
Funkfried 31.23
Kuro 31.16
Bellamy 30.75
Camie 30.59
Shackey 29.47
Banchi 29.43
Laboon 29.18
Minotaurus 27.64
Mohmoo 25.33
Odz 25.06
Norla 24.16
Rob Lucci 23.75
Stronger 23.63
Igaram 23.10
Pell 22.69
Vivi 22.25
Margaret 20.59
Ohm 16.88
Jambarl 16.19
Califa 15.15
Spandam 14.22
Burgess 12.95
Hogback 12.18
Lola 11.38
Domino 10.97
Joz 10.82
Total Second Round Votes
! Ivankov vs Gedatsu 386
Nico Robin vs Shanks 429
Mihawk vs Jinbei 437
Marco vs Van Augur 390
Gold Roger vs Going Merry 404
Hancock vs Hatchan 416
Sanji vs Dragon 365
Perona vs Beckman vs Paulie 433
Crocodile vs Hannyabal 412
Django vs Iceburg 411
Usopp vs DoFlamingo 413
Kumadori vs ShuShu 386
Apoo vs Teach 391
Kidd vs Buggy 385
Law vs Tom 413
Cricket vs Momonga 367
Wiper vs Franky 376
Carue vs Dorry 361
Mr. 3 vs Whitebeard 401
Urouge vs Luffy 415
Miss Goldenweek vs Brook 361
Hina vs Magellan 391
Bellemere vs Hiruluk 383
Aphelandra vs Moria 445
Garp vs Pandaman 398
Bepo vs Jabura 394
Zoro vs Chopper 395
Duval vs Bon Kurei 385
Gin vs Smoker 384
Ener vs Don Krieg 403
Richie vs Zeff 408
Kuma vs Nami 428
! Average per match: 399 votes (+9)
Individual Votes per character for the Second Round
The number following the vote is the change from the vote the character received in the previous round.
! Ener 345 (+100)
Bon Kurei 335 (+71)
Smoker 329 (+45)
Crocodile 325 (-7)
Luffy 316 (-58)
Franky 306 (+54)
Brook 288 (+26)
Garp 284 (+85)
Moria 276 (+60)
Ivankov 274 (+6)
Magellan 273 (+9)
Usopp 271 (-96)
Buggy 270 (-40)
Zoro 265 (-42)
Van Augur 262 (+23)
Zeff 254 (-82)
Robin 252 (-99)
Sanji 251 (+18)
Jinbei 245 (-4)
Hancock 243 (-19)
Teach 243 (-21)
Django 236 (-103)
Hiruluk 232 (-70)
Nami 231 (+17)
Bepo 229 (-6)
Cricket 219 (+14)
Gold Roger 218 (-118)
Shushu 215 (-10)
Law 214 (-111)
Whitebeard 209 (-7)
Carue 204 (-29)
Tom 199 (-81)
Bart 197 (-22)
Mihawk 192 (-78)
Mr. 3 192 (-15)
Merry 186 (-88)
Shanks 177 (-118)
Iceburg 175 (-87)
Hachi 173 (-113)
Kumadori 171 (-62)
Aphelandra 169 (-55)
Jabura 165 (-8)
Beckman 157 (-54)
Dorry 157 (-29)
Richie 154 (-58)
Perona 152 (-132)
Bellemere 151 (-56)
Apoo 148 (-28)
Momonga 148 (-138)
DoFlamingo 142 (-204)
Chopper 130 (-148)
Marco 128 (-79)
Paulie 124 (-77)
Hina 118 (-102)
Kidd 115 (-179)
Dragon 114 (-169)
Pandaman 114 (-45)
Gedatsu 112 (-104)
Urouge 101 (-142)
Hannyabal 87 (-144)
Ms. Goldenweek 73 (-157)
Wiper 70 (-193)
Don Krieg 58 (-153)
Gin 55 (- 185)
Duval 50 (-263)
! Highest: Ener
Lowest: Duval
Highest while losing: Tom
Lowest while winning: Beckman
Biggest increase in vote from last round: Ener
Biggest decrease in vote from last round: Duval
Second Round by percentages
! Bon Kurei 87.01
Smoker 85.68
Ener 85.61
Franky 81.38
Brook 79.78
Crocodile 78.88
Luffy 75.66
Garp 71.36
Ivankov 70.98
Buggy 70.13
Magellan 69.82
Sanji 68.77
Van Augur 67.18
Zoro 67.09
Usopp 65.61
Zeff 62.25
Teach 62.15
Moria 62.02
Hiruluk 60.57
Cricket 59.67
Robin 58.74
Hancock 58.41
Bepo 58.12
Django 57.42
Jinbei 57.38
Carue 56.51
Shushu 55.70
Nami 53.97
Gold Roger 53.96
Whitebeard 52.12
Law 51.82
Tom 48.18
Mr. 3 47.88
Merry 46.04
Bart 46.03
Kumadori 44.30
Dorry 43.49
Mihawk 42.62
Iceburg 42.58
Jabura 41.88
Hachi 41.59
Shanks 41.26
Momonga 40.33
Hiruluk 39.43
Aphelandra 37.98
Apoo 37.85
Richie 37.75
Beckman 36.26
Perona 35.10
DoFlamingo 34.39
Chopper 32.91
Marco 32.82
Dragon 31.23
Hina 30.18
Kidd 29.87
Paulie 28.64
Pandaman 28.54
Gedatsu 28.12
Urouge 24.34
Hannyabal 21.12
Ms. Goldenweek 20.22
Wiper 18.62
Don Krieg 14.39
Gin 14.32
Duval 12.99
Total Third Round votes
! Van Augur vs Hancock 430
Luffy vs ShuShu 412
Hiruluk vs Whitebeard 424
Beckman vs Robin 409
Ivankov vs Moria 449
Garp vs Crocodile 496
Brook vs Smoker 461
Magellan vs Gold Roger 447
Law vs Usopp 429
Zeff vs Ener 421
Cricket vs Jinbei 424
Bon Kurei vs Zoro 538
Carue vs Nami 436
Franky vs Sanji 517
Django vs Bepo 433
Teach vs Buggy 458
! Average votes per match: 423 (+24)
Individual Votes per character for the Third Round
! Jinbei 334 (+89)
Luffy 326 (+10)
Robin 313 (+61)
Nami 308 (+77)
Hancock 289 (+46)
Zoro 277 (+12)
Ivanov 276 (+2)
Sanji 272 (+21)
Usopp 267 (-4)
Whitebeard 264 (+55)
Bon Kurei 261 (-74)
Brook 251 (-37)
Garp 248 (-36)
Crocodile 248 (-77)
Buggy 248 (-22)
Ener 247 (-98)
Django 247 (+11)
Franky 245 (-61)
Gold Roger 240 (+22)
Teach 210 (-33)
Smoker 210 (-119)
Magellan 207 (-66)
Bepo 186 (-43)
Zeff 174 (-80)
Moria 173 (-103)
Law 162 (-52)
Doc Hiruluk 160 (-72)
Van Augur 141 (-121)
Carue 128 (-76)
Beckman 96 (-61)
Cricket 90 (-129)
ShuShu 86 (-129)
! Highest: Jinbei
Lowest: ShuShu
Highest while losing: Bon Kurei
Lowest while winning: Roger
Biggest increase in vote from last round: Jinbei
Biggest decrease in vote from last round: ShuShu/Cricket
Third Round by percentages
! Luffy 79.13
Jinbei 78.77
Robin 76.53
Nami 70.64
Hancock 67.21
Whitebeard 62.26
Usopp 62.64
Ivankov 61.47
Ener 58.67
Django 57.04
Brook 54.45
Buggy 54.15
Gold Roger 53.69
Sanji 52.61
Zoro 51.49
Garp/Crocodile 50.00
Bon Kurei 48.41
Franky 47.39
Teach 45.85
Magellan 46.31
Smoker 45.55
Bepo 42.96
Zeff 41.33
Moria 38.53
Law 37.76
Hiruluk 37.74
Van Augur 32.79
Carue 29.36
Beckman 23.47
Cricket 21.23
ShuShu 20.87
Total Fourth Round Votes
! Buggy vs Jinbei 487
Usopp vs Whitebeard 534
Zoro vs Hancock 512
Robin vs Luffy 489
Django vs Sanji 436
Roger vs Nami 525
! Average per match: 494 (+70)
Individual votes per character for the Fourth Round
! Zoro 374 (+97)
Sanji 304 (+32)
Buggy 286 (+38)
Luffy 283 (-43)
Whitebeard 271 (+7)
Roger 263 (+23)
Usopp 263 (-4)
Nami 262 (-46)
Ener 251 (+4)
Ivankov 223 (-53)
Crocodile 211 (-37)
Robin 206 (-107)
Jinbei 201 (-133)
Brook 146 (-105)
Garp 139 (-109)
Hancock 138 (-151)
Django 132 (-115)
Fourth Round by percentages
! Zoro 73.05
Sanji 69.72
Buggy 58.73
Luffy 57.87
Ener 52.95
Whitebeard 50.75
Roger 50.10
Nami 49.90
Usopp 49.25
Ivankov 47.05
Crocodile 42.54
Robin 42.13
Jinbei 41.27
Django 30.28
Brook 29.44
Garp 28.02
Hancock 26.95
Total Fifth Round Votes
! Ener vs Zoro 492
Buggy vs Sanji 577
Crocodile vs Whitebeard 498
Roger vs Luffy 474
! Average per match: 510 (+16)
Individual votes per character for the Fifth Round
! Luffy 348 (+65)
Zoro 321 (-53)
Buggy 290 (+4)
Sanji 287 (-17)
Crocodile 268 (+57)
Whitebeard 230 (-41)
Ener 171 (-80)
Roger 128 (-135)
! Highest: Luffy
Lowest: Roger
Highest while losing: Sanji
Lowest while winning: Crocodile
Biggest increase in vote from the last round: Luffy
Biggest decrease in vote from the last round: Roger
Fifth Round by the percentages
! Luffy 73.11
Zoro 65.24
Crocodile 53.82
Buggy 50.26
Sanji 49.76
Whitebeard 46.18
Ener 34.76
Roger 26.89
Total Sixth Round Votes
! Crocodile vs Luffy 556
Buggy vs Zoro 608
! Average per match: 582 (+72)
Individual votes per character for the Sixth Round
! Luffy 334 (-14)
Zoro 308 (-13)
Buggy 300 (+10)
Crocodile 222 (-46)
! Highest: Luffy
Lowest: Crocodile
Highest while losing: Buggy
Lowest while winning: Zoro
Biggest increase: Buggy
Biggest decrease: Crocodile
Sixth Round by the percentages
! Luffy 60.07
Zoro 50.66
Buggy 49.36
Crocodile 39.93
Championship Match
! Total votes: 618
! Luffy 356 57.61
Zoro 262 42.39
Your 2009 Arlong Park Character Tournament Champion: Monkey D. Luffy!
Each match ranked by total vote
! Luffy vs Zoro 618
Buggy vs Zoro 608
Buggy vs Sanji 577
Crocodile vs Luffy 556
Bon Kurei vs Zoro 538
Usopp vs Whitebeard 534
Roger vs Nami 525
Franky vs Sanji 517
Zoro vs Hancock 512
Crocodile vs Whitebeard 498
Garp vs Crocodile 496
Brook vs Garp vs Crocodile 496
Ener vs Zoro 492
Robin vs Luffy 489
Buggy vs Jinbei 487
Roger vs Luffy 476
Ener vs Ivankov 474
Urouge vs Kizaru 472
Brook vs Smoker 461
Teach vs Buggy 458
Ivankov vs Moria 449
Magellan vs Gold Roger 447
Aphelandra vs Moria 445
Margaret vs Robin 442
Mihawk vs Jinbei 437
Luffy vs Spandam 436
Nami vs Carue 436
Django vs Sanji 436
Zoro vs Banchi 435
Dragon vs Bege 434
Perona vs Beckman vs Paulie 433
Django vs Bepo 433
Van Augur vs Hancock 430
Robin vs Shanks 429
Law vs Usopp 429
Ivankov vs Kureha 428
Yasopp vs Kidd 428
Kuma vs Nami 428
Crocodile vs Vivi 427
Saul vs Moria 425
Hiruluk vs Whitebeard 424
Cricket vs Jinbei 424
Richie vs Sengoku 423
Kuma vs Ace 423
Beckman vs Paulie 422
Zeff vs Ener 421
Brook vs Rayleigh 417
Hatchan vs Hancock 416
Ryuma vs Jinbei 415
Urouge vs Luffy 415
Funkfried vs Perona 413
Lola vs Usopp 413
Bellamy vs Momonga 413
Absalom vs Krieg 413
Usopp vs DoFlamingo 413
Law vs Tom 413
Aokiji vs Franky 412
Crocodile vs Hannyabal 412
Luffy vs ShuShu 412
Django vs Iceburg 411
Beckman vs Robin 409
Arlong vs Hannyabal 408
Richie vs Zeff 408
Igaram vs Duval 407
Ener vs Hawkins 406
Whitebeard vs Kaku 406
Yorki vs Iceburg 405
Bonney vs Hancock 404
Roger vs Merry 404
Cricket vs Foxy 403
Odz vs Hiruluk 403
Ener vs Don Krieg 403
Pell vs Buggy 401
Teach vs Tashigi 401
Mr. 3 vs Whitebeard 401
ShuShu vs Lafitte 399
Mr. 1 vs Bellemere 398
Sandersonia vs Aphelandra 398
Garp vs Pandaman 398
Merry vs Kuro 398
Tom vs Shackey 397
Roger vs Kalifa 396
Zoro vs Chopper 395
Bepo vs Jabura 394
Bepo vs Olvia 392
Inazuma vs Bon Kurei 391
Law vs Ohm 391
Apoo vs Teach 391
Hina vs Magellan 391
Marco vs Van Augur 390
Camie vs Mihawk 389
Norla vs Shanks 389
Joz vs DoFlamingo 388
Kumadori vs Kokoro 388
Marco vs Blueno 386
Django vs Hogback 386
Zeff vs Burgess 386
Ivankov vs Gedatsu 386
Kumadori vs ShuShu 386
Kidd vs Buggy 385
Duval vs Bon Kurei 385
Wiper vs Miss Valentine 384
Gin vs Smoker 384
Bellemere vs Hiruluk 383
Sadie-Chan vs Gedatsu 380
Mohmoo vs Hatchan 383
Lucky Roo vs Mr. 3 382
Akainu vs Miss Goldenweek 378
Wiper vs Franky 376
Alvida vs Van Augur 374
Hina vs Mr. 5 370
Cricket vs Momonga 367
Sanji vs Dragon 365
Nami vs Drake 364
Chopper vs Stronger 364
Carue vs Dorry 361
Miss Goldenweek vs Brook 361
Dorry vs Killer 356
Coby vs Apoo 348
Gin vs Kumacy 345
Sanji vs Laboon 329
Carue vs Minotaurus 322
Smoker vs Domino 319
Jambarl vs Magellan 315
Wapol vs Jabura 301
Garp vs Lucci 261
Pandaman vs Calgara 256
If you spot any errors, let me know and I'll correct them.