Villains Tier list

[Elektrik Dynomite]

This is a tier list out of all the villains the Strawhats fought so far, basically in an order with the strongest, most cunning, all around best villain at the top to the worst. This is Not a popularity contest, nor is there any reason for this, it just came to my head :getlost:. Any way feel free to comment and edit where you feel necessary. And if possible, provide reason for your edits. Thank you

So this is what i think so far. Agree?

Kizaru
Aokiji
Mihawk
Kuma
Blackbeard
Lucci
Sentomaru
Magellan
Moria
Crocodile
Eneru

[Captain Shmeckie]

This can only lead to arguments and overall disaster…

[wolfwood]

You only say that cause people always put Croc near the bottom.

If i made that list id place Blackbeard at the top and push eneru up to top five. and drop Lucci and sentamarou below Magellan. Moria maybe some where around where Blackbeard was on your list. Oh and i wouldd probably put some more Buggy on that list as well.

[Groene Beret]

Why is Lucci so high on that list?

[Captain Hypersock]

Run! It's the attack of the tier list!

[Elektrik Dynomite]

on second thought im gonna change it around

Kizaru
Aokiji
Mihawk
Kuma
Magellan
Blackbeard
Lucci
Moria
Crocodile
Eneru

Yeah, sentomaru doesnt belong and Magellan is much stronger.
Eneru is low only because he pretty much went down after one hit, then again against anyone besides Luffy the fight may have had a different outcome, maybe he can move up
Lucci isnt too high is he? i think he belongs about here. I think his speed allows him to beat moria
And i dont think Blackbeard can beat an admiral. also magellan beat him so i dont know what to do with him

[wolfwood]

Blackbeard has the number one anti-logia weapon, Like he showed against Ace those who havent honed their stamina taking countless killing blows dont stand a chance against him. Aokiji and Kizaru are Blackbeard prey. But in turn Jimbei might beat him since he relies on nothing but his own inate fishman strength. And the same goes for Kuma since he has a body harder than steel and other weapons beside his devil fruit.

[fedcom]

Is this a best villain list or a villain strength list?
I'm assuming you're talking about their fighting abilities here.

Eneru should be above Lucci.
It would take an incredibly powerful opponent to beat him sans rubber powers.

@wolfwood:

Blackbeard has the number one anti-logia weapon, Like he showed against Ace those who havent honed their stamina taking countless killing blows dont stand a chance against him. Aokiji and Kizaru are Blackbeard prey. But in turn Jimbei might beat him since he relies on nothing but his own inate fishman strength. And the same goes for Kuma since he has a body harder than steel and other weapons beside his devil fruit.

But he has not shown these powers except against Ace, which looked like it was a really close match.
I don't think he can take on higher level logias right now.

[wolfwood]

It irks me to say it, but there isnt much more of a higher level of logia than Ace. He´s the third on command on the strongest man in the worlds pirate crew. Thats pretty much makes him the pirate equivilent to one of the three admirals And well you seem to think it was a close call, to me it looked like Blackbeard kicking him around like no big deal and tanking all of Ace´s best moves without it leaving any lasting damage.

[The man with a pigeon]

I still think that you put Lucci higher than he should be. Out of all the Grand Line villains, he may be the weakest. Not saying that he's weak, it's just that his abilities work perfectly against Luffy, but won't do shit to Magellan(well, yeah technically they would, but I doubt he'd get that far), Moria(brick bat, doppelman, brick bat, doppelman, shadow steal) or even logias(Enel kills him in every scenario, Crocodile dehydrates him when Lucci goes in close range for Rokuogan, assuming he's smart enough to figure out his weakness and let's face it, he is). My two cents on this. Good list otherwise .

[Darklord]

This list can only cause endless pointless debate, since the strength of some of those characters hasn't even been revealed yet.

If I have to arrange them in a list, I would say:

Mihawk
Kizaru/Enel
Magellan
Blackbeard
Aokiji
Kuma
Crocodile
Moria
Sentomaru
Lucci

My reasoning?

I put Mihawk at the top, since he is the greatest swordsman and Shanks' rival. If old man Rayleigh, who is far from his prime can handle Kizaru, I am pretty sure Mihawk in his prime can do it as well.

Then Enel and Kizaru are both about equal, since their DF powers are similar and enable them to travel instantaneously and have devastating ranged attacks. Enel even has his mantra which would be a great advantage. He was just really really unlucky that he got Luffy as an opponent.

Magellan has proven to be a beast, which no one without ranged attack or haki can beat (if haki really can resist poison or something like that).

Blackbeard can totally devastate most Logias and has extreme endurance and strength. He would probably be higher on this list if he did not get so easilly defeated by Magellan. He could probably still beat Enel/Kizaru though…I don't know

Kuma and Aokiji are pretty strong overall fighters, especially Kuma has a variety of interesting abilities.

Croc is pretty much a generic Logia user - most of his power comes from being invincible. However, water is not that hard to come by, so he is not near the top.

I don't have much to say about Moria...

Sentomaru is just a haki user, which is good, but the only thing he did is fight about evenly with an extremely distracted Luffy. He is way overrated!

Lucci is insanely strong, but pretty much everyone else on this list can defeat him...