HI,,,
As All We Know there is no die or romance in one piece anime or manga
in Arc hanckok love luffy it's love from one side
OK Oda didn't kill anybody and there is no love between
any one in the crew or out the crew SO,,,
i heard a lot of stuff that oda Say:
"i will break the rules of Death & Romance
And I will Make One Piece Perfect Manga Or Anime
Without Death & Romance".
If anyone Know About this,,,
please tell as where Oda say that,,,
if it was TRUE I hope there is one know about it,,,
If it was A FAKE tell As it's A fake,,,
ThX,,,
OP :(Death & Romance)
-
-
isnt this a question for the "questions that do not deserve their own thread" thread?
-
I think, possibly, Oda just wants it to be really special when it actually happens. Romance and death in a fictional world doesn't hold any value if it occurs all the time.
-
i know it was a filler but in the anime before thiller park there was a couple kissing all the time but that was just a filler i guess
Swansea city capital one cup winners 2013 !!!!!FC : 2337-3982-3157 trainer name: oldmanscraps mii name: ltsmash
-
@Guybrush:
i know it was a filler but in the anime before thiller park there was a couple kissing all the time but that was just a filler i guess
so whats the point, when you know it??
it was in this ice-bountyhunters side arc…romance we never saw before :)
-
???
I'm not english, and I understand almost every single post, even from guys who can't speak English at all.Yet, you lost me, you were the first to lost me
-
HI,,,
As All We Know there is no die or romance in one piece anime or manga
in Arc hanckok love luffy it's love from one side
OK Oda didn't kill anybody and there is no love between
any one in the crew or out the crew SO,,,
i heard a lot of stuff that oda Say:
"i will break the rules of Death & Romance
And I will Make One Piece Perfect Manga Or Anime
Without Death & Romance".
If anyone Know About this,,,
please tell as where Oda say that,,,
if it was TRUE I hope there is one know about it,,,
If it was A FAKE tell As it's A fake,,,
ThX,,,To post above
my interpretation of what hes saying."As we all know there are no deaths or romances in one piece.
In the Amazon Lilly arc, Hancock loves luffy, however, this love is unrequited.
Oda hasn't killed anyone, and there isn't love between anyone in the crew or out of the crew. (which is a load of shit cos the crew obviously love each other)"i will break the rules of Death & Romance
And I will Make One Piece Perfect Manga Or Anime
Without Death & Romance".
(This guys quote)
If anyone knows about this, please tell me where Oda says this. If it is true I hope someone knows about it. If this is fake, please say so." -
To post above
my interpretation of what hes saying."As we all know there are no deaths or romances in one piece.
In the Amazon Lilly arc, Hancock loves luffy, however, this love is unrequited.
Oda hasn't killed anyone, and there isn't love between anyone in the crew or out of the crew. (which is a load of shit cos the crew obviously love each other)"i will break the rules of Death & Romance
And I will Make One Piece Perfect Manga Or Anime
Without Death & Romance".
(This guys quote)
If anyone knows about this, please tell me where Oda says this. If it is true I hope someone knows about it. If this is fake, please say so."yes that's what i Mean BTW :(Sorry For My English)
Thanks -
It would be great if some death and romance eventually happen right?
Come on! Even Goku got his wife.. So why Luffy can't get Hancock? =D It would really add to the story and relationships make the characters more deep..
As for death.. He MUST be saving it for some WOW moment, I hope! With Pell coming back in one piece from that bomb he started to lose many of our respects!!
But weeeell.. Even without death and romance, LOVE one Piece!! -
With Pell coming back in one piece from that bomb he started to lose many of our respects!!
But weeeell.. Even without death and romance, LOVE one Piece!!Tell me. Whose manga is One Piece again? Oda or yours?
I certainly can understand this whole justification about Death and Romance in a storyline. But is death and romance a MUST for a storyline to be great? I don't think so. However, people are going to justify this whole Death and Romance thing over and over.
Anyways, you will continue to love One Piece, even if no one dies and Luffy is still single, eventually when One Piece ends at the legendary chapter 1000 in the future.
-
I don't understand why people are so worked up about death and love in OP. I love how it's only about friendship, which I find being deeper than "love". As for death, we cry enough during the flashbacks TT^TT
-
Excalibur: BAKA!!
The whole One Piece series runs on Romance. Just not the type -Tash- is interested :P
True Romance is seeking whats beyond and the thrill of adventure.
Please look at the 3 founding words of Shounen Jump :P
In Oda We Trust
-
onr pirce does have romance the romance of adventure
-
the romance and death is just off screen up untill nw because it hasn't yet been of importance for the story
We will soon hear that Nami is married to Luffy at the reverso mountain and that sanji married Robin at enies lobby, nice and romantic, between the cannonballs of the bustercall
-
I think, possibly, Oda just wants it to be really special when it actually happens. Romance and death in a fictional world doesn't hold any value if it occurs all the time.
THIS.
Also, I think Oda-sensei said that as a general rule that he would ATTEMPT to avoid adding the oversatturated cliches in manga of constantly pairing up the characters with a romantic other or killing off main characters in some lame attempt to make the series seem more intense or unpredictable. Oda has already shown signs of caving a bit on that stance with Zoro and Tashigi or Luffy and Boa, and occasionally characters DO die in OP. I think romance and death will happen, just not a lot overall.
It's like fanservice, for the longest time OP was devoid of any fanservice and then BOOM! There it is–shower scenes in Thriller Bark and the like.
Also, it's a children's comic from Japan.
Why are you comparing it to cultural engravings and burritos.
-
@Ao:
THIS.
Also, I think Oda-sensei said that as a general rule that he would ATTEMPT to avoid adding the oversatturated cliches in manga of constantly pairing up the characters with a romantic other or killing off main characters in some lame attempt to make the series seem more intense or unpredictable. Oda has already shown signs of caving a bit on that stance with Zoro and Tashigi or Luffy and Boa, and occasionally characters DO die in OP. I think romance and death will happen, just not a lot overall.
It's like fanservice, for the longest time OP was devoid of any fanservice and then BOOM! There it is–shower scenes in Thriller Bark and the like.
Smartest post on this thread.
You win a Poneglyph -
This post is deleted!
-
I'll just say, I do think there will be some romance or couples getting hooked up at the end of One Piece.
Not throughout the duration of the series perhaps, but for the ending, definitely. I'm expecting a beefy epilogue kind of deal.
We'll see, I'm sure the ending will be epic no matter how it turns out.
-
We will soon hear that Nami is married to Luffy at the reverso mountain and that sanji married Robin at enies lobby, nice and romantic, between the cannonballs of the bustercall
Just knowing we're in the same genus makes me embarrassed to call myself homo.
-
^Why are you copying jokes from TODAY'S episode of Futurama??
Also, it's a children's comic from Japan.
Why are you comparing it to cultural engravings and burritos.
-
@Ao:
^Why are you copying jokes from TODAY'S episode of Futurama??
Are you kidding me?
- Not an episode, it's a movie.
- It's been out for a looooooooooooong time.
- Watching it again reminded me of that quote.
- The quote fit and it's a great one.
-
- is about as incorrect as something can possibly be.
Also, it's a children's comic from Japan.
Why are you comparing it to cultural engravings and burritos.
-
@Ao:
- is about as incorrect as something can possibly be.
Matter of opinions, I thought that it would of been obvious even though I numbered it like a fact.
-
One Piece would be best, most superior manga/anime IF there is these things in story. If they would be normal things of this story… shame, but glad OP is in god tier still. Well there is couple of these things already... but not enough for my taste.
-
One Piece wouldn't feel right if there were these on screen current time psychological dramatic deaths.
One Piece is pretty much a black and white adventuring story. There are some nuances here and there like in the meaning of "justice", but the Straw Hat's is about doing things their own way, with freedom, and the reader is compelled to identify with the Straw Hat's justice every arc.
All the ambiguities and conflicts such as Vivi's inability to save everyone or Robin wanting to save the crew by sacrificing herself are gray areas that reality present, but Luffy dispells all of that with good o' shonen clarity. Death has no place in this clarity.
Pell's resurrection certainly negated the after-impact of the alabasta arc, but you've already had your emotional impact when he blew up, and this way Luffy did help Vivi save everyone (that mattered anyway). Would you prefer a mass funeral for Pell and all the rebels/soldiers who died fighting a senseless war? That wouldn't be very One Piece-ish
Luffy just wants to have his light sea-faring adventure free from the shadow of death or any moral ambiguities like freedom vs death. Just see this panel:
ch507 p9As for romance, there is plenty of romance in One Piece, that is,
OTOKO NO ROMAN -
That's a good way of putting it, nexusil.
The flashbacks are so dark and violent though, and increasingly so. Countless people die in horrible ways, but never during the current story. It creates an odd disconnect.
The characters keep encountering situations where tons of people die in horrible ways long before they get there. It shows us that the Buster Call is serious, and Lucci is deadly, and that Brooke has a tragic past.
It's a useful dramatic device, but I think it would feel more natural if one of those dramatic deaths that makes the story urgent happens in the current storyline. And I actually wouldn't be surprised if we do see a few deaths in the coming story arcs. As long as the Straw Hats aren't the ones doing the killing, it wouldn't tarnish their optimistic outlook.
As for the romance, of the relationship between two lovers definition, I don't think that's something that would impede on the lighthearted feel of One Piece, and I think it'll happen.
But I do think that kind of thing will happen at the end of the story, which seems to be the way it goes. In stories like these they'll often give characters a romantic happy ending, that way they don't have to weigh on the story with a serious romantic relationship throughout the duration, while still getting the fulfillment at the end.
-
nexusil has indeed stated it best, imo. The scene you pointed out from the manga, i truly did love when i first read it, because to me, that IS One Piece, in a nutshell.
I really don't think the series is lacking in either category at all, though the Pell reveal will always kinda feel like a slap in the face (an "are you shitting me?!" moment if i've ever seen one).
There is just enough "romantic tension" in the story to make it interesting, and it's barely tense at all. We have the Zoro/Tashigi/Kuina thing, now the Luffy/Hancock thing (my personal favorite way that Luffy's "defeated" a Shichibuki), and of course Usopp/Kaya.
yo, visit me at www.agent-oharah.deviantart.com
-
I would like one piece to have deaths and romance…..without them it's not real.....for example the scene with pell that somebody else brought up.....he was my hero for that moment...but when I saw him alive I was like :blink:wtf?....how ?but there is a good point in the fact that characters ain't dying....and we saw that in the last chapter:D...crocodile and luffy in a team?who would have expected that:D?
P.S.: it would be really lame if Gol D. Roger would br alive,or Saur or Olvia(robin's mom....don't remember her name well)
-
Easy on the recent spoilers there Ady.
I'm don't mind getting spoiled so much, but yikes, that's potent stuff you're tossing around.
-
@Ady:
I would like one piece to have deaths and romance…..without them it's not real.....
Sorry, but I find this a ridiculous and hilarious thing to say
Exciting as this would be, i hate to break it to you that this is not the only thing keeping One Piece out of the non-fiction section…
yo, visit me at www.agent-oharah.deviantart.com
-
One Piece is a "pure" show, and not in the way most would think I'm referring to. It's about chasing after one's dream and not getting held back for anything. Sex and death are in One Piece turned into perverts and fights. Much milder, and without implications that would hold someone back or slow them down.
There's something to be said for romance and death, but ultimately those are TRAGIC elements, and One Piece is a COMEDY. =P Like I said, perverts and fights, those are comedic, but serious relationships and death… that's not One Piece, simply because that's not comedy.
ALLEZ CUISINE!!
-
There's something to be said for romance and death, but ultimately those are TRAGIC elements, and One Piece is a COMEDY. =P Like I said, perverts and fights, those are comedic, but serious relationships and death… that's not One Piece, simply because that's not comedy.
Romance doesn't have to be tragic, I mean there are plenty of comedic romance anime out there, Maison Ikkoku, etc.
-
@Psycho_Kenshin:
Romance doesn't have to be tragic, I mean there are plenty of comedic romance anime out there, Maison Ikkoku, etc.
Haven't seen Maison Ikkoku, but does it involve serious, committed romance? Because to me, that's what turns a comedy into tragedy (or vice versa, depending on which way we're going). And I mean in the more traditional sense of the words, not modern. You might have already known this, but I'm just putting it out there.
ALLEZ CUISINE!!
-
i don't know if anyone before me has mentioned this as i couldn't be bothered to read everyones reply's but… refering to death oda did right someone dying... in one of the earlier episodes... lucky roux (the fat guy from shank's crew) kills a bandit by shooting him in the head!!! lol
-
Flaaaaaaaaaaaaaashbaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaack.
Just a place-holder until I find a more interesting picture.
-
is it clasified a flash back it hapens before the main story starts well atleast in the manga
-
@Psycho_Kenshin:
Easy on the recent spoilers there Ady.
I'm don't mind getting spoiled so much, but yikes, that's potent stuff you're tossing around.
lol..sorry…didn't knew that:D.....tought in the manga section everyone who read or write something have seen the latest chapters
-
Sorry, but I find this a ridiculous and hilarious thing to say
Exciting as this would be, i hate to break it to you that this is not the only thing keeping One Piece out of the non-fiction section…
if you say so…:P
-
Flaaaaaaaaaaaaaashbaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaack.
Coby's enrolment into Alvida's crew in chapter 2 was the first flashback. Only the anime was Shanks + Luffy = flashback. A lot of people such as myself didn't like it that way, since a lot of build up was lost in that ep.
-
How about Bellamy? Would you consider that a death?
-
It was off-camera and the Strawhats were long gone, sooo…not really.
-
Hm… maybe, though it did occur in the present. That's the only thing that I'd say makes it valid for any second thought.
Oh yeah! Then there was that guy who refused Axe-Hand Morgan something and was sliced right then and there. I think the One Piece Wikia lists him as deceased. Does that count?
-
He was a nameless grunt, so it doesn't matter. They die all the time, even in One Piece.
Just a place-holder until I find a more interesting picture.
-
He was a nameless grunt, so it doesn't matter. They die all the time, even in One Piece.
Nope, he's got a name: http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/Rokkaku Not a major character, but he's still got a name.
-
Ok, I went back to read Chapter 4 and it's not specified whether or not he died. Frankly, it doesn't look to me like a fatal wound by Oda standards.
Just a place-holder until I find a more interesting picture.
-
Ok, I went back to read Chapter 4 and it's not specified whether or not he died. Frankly, it doesn't look to me like a fatal wound by Oda standards.
Helmeppo states something about Morgan having killed him.
-
I think I remember that. Besides, I don't think he'd be put on the "Dead characters" list on the OP Wikia if he wasn't really dead, from what I know about that site.
-
Fair enough.
Still, considering how early that was in the story, perhaps it was before Oda decided, "You know what? I'm never going to kill present-time characters again, no matter how obscure!"
Just a place-holder until I find a more interesting picture.
-
Fair enough.
Still, considering how early that was in the story, perhaps it was before Oda decided, "You know what? I'm never going to kill present-time characters again, no matter how obscure!"
He's always occasionally killed off little obscure side guys.
Mr. 11, Roshio, etc. -
He's always occasionally killed off little obscure side guys.
Mr. 11, Roshio, etc.Ack! Yeah, I forgot about that thing with Mr. 11… I guess he just means main characters (most likely) stay alive in the present. Hopefully. shrugs
