To hopefully bring some liveliness to this practically dead sub-forum (we're almost through the second month of the FUN Piece drought [fourth for those who didn't buy the DVD set]), so I thought about making a thread where you rate the voices of the FUNimation dub. Please, justify your reasons and don't say "they all are 0!" or "they all 2000 out of 10".
Colleen Clinkenbeard as Luffy: I gotta say, I didn't like her at first, but she grew on me and can really convey Luffy's "Luffiness" pretty well. However, some lines sound plain awkward ("I slept so great!") Overall, CC gets a 8.
Christopher R. Sabat as Zoro: Same as Luffy above, I didn't like him early on (obviously, it was deep) but in the DVD release, he almost nails Zoro. I give him a 7 because he still sounds deep to me.
Luci Christian as Nami: First, Nami's voice actress really seemed to play conservatively, she was good but not stand-out good. However, in the later portion of the DVD release and in Movie 8, Luci really comes into Nami, I believe more so than her seiyuu. 10.
Sonny Strait as Usopp: Really good, he does Usopp well. He really shines because of how well he performs Usopp, but he doesn't really nail the serious or high-pitched Usopp (UA Sogeking, anyone?) I give him a solid 9.
Eric Vale as Sanji: I'm really unsure about Sanji. I haven't heard enough to be too judgmental. He's mediocre in Jaya, decent in Skypiea, but quite good in Unlimited Adventure. The second DVD set will help me decide on what to give Sanji, but as it stands, Eric gets a flat 6.
Brina Palencia as Chopper: Remember how everyone assumed Chopper would be the stand out voice of One Piece? Well, they were right, but unfortunately in a bad way. She started strong, but in Skypiea she really started to taper off. She rebounded a bit in UA when she's serious, but god the constant screaming gets incredibly annoying. Until the screaming cuts down, Brina gets a 4.
Stephanie Young as Robin: Really, I like Robin, except for her OOC moments throughout Skypiea. Her voice really fits, it's sultry but at the same time, she sounds intelligent, which is what describes Robin. Stephanie recieves an 8 from me.
**>! Patrick Seitz as Franky: To me Patrick is the reverse Brina. He doesn't fit Franky at all, but he still sounds okay. It's not the same SUPPPAAA~! Franky we all know and love, but still it's not TOO bad. I'll give him a 6.
Laurie Steele as Alvida: While I'm not keen on her Slim voice (or the one or two lines we heard back in Jaya), I think as Fat Alvida, Laurie fits the bill nicely. I like the way she says "Coby", but she still sounds somewhat hickish. I give her a decent 8.
Mike McFarland as Buggy: I know I'll be flamed flashily for this, but Mike as Buggy is epic. I can see the voice being hard to do, but Mike fit the bill nicely. Mike gets a 9.
Kent Williams as Kuro: Anyone remember the 4kids voice? Yeah… Kent does quite an excellent job as Kuro. Not much else to say really, but 9.
I'll post more later. So, everybody, post your own ratings!**