Well I figured hey…it's a new arc and the other topic is like 97 pages...so I just thought since it's so long why not start fresh. Anyway back on topic. In my crazy opinion I think either Hatchan or Camie or the both of them will join the Mugiwara crew.
Throughout this month, we will be testing new features (like search) so you may experience some hiccups from time to time. We'll try to not be too disruptive...
The next new Nakama? Part 2
-
-
I'd love for both to join, but what's the need for a designer? and a second chef will get in sanji's way
-
Hatchi won't. Not a chance. We already have a cook and a swordsman (two of them in fact, even though Brook fills a different role and his swordsmanship isn't as important to him as to Zoro). Hatchi is just this arc's Johnny & Yosaku/Vivi & Carue/Conis/Pauly.
As for Camie, there's no reason to think she isn't in the same group. I think it would be cool if she joined: she's a funny character, we need another girl, and a fashion designer would be awesome. And who knows what might come up? Maybe by the end of the arc there's be a good motivation for her to join. But for right now she hasn't expressed any interest in joining the Straw Hats, and they haven't expressed any interest in her joining them.
-
Your crazy don't start unnecessary threads.
EDIT: On second thought you created the last thread so I guess it's up to you.
-
I'd love for both to join, but what's the need for a designer? and a second chef will get in sanji's way
What was the need for an archaeologist/liar/musician? Or a reindeer for that matter (Luffy had no idea he was a doctor)?
As I said in my post, I agree that Hatchi isn't going to join though. But a fashion designer would be awesome.
-
because, they all had skills no one else officially had and proved actually usefull, designer could, but it's not adventure like at all.
-
And are you sure Camie has no other usefull skills ctarlong?
hmmm… weren't mermaids the fastest swimmers in the ocean? I seem to recall something like that. And she can talk to fish way better then Chopper can. (if he can at all)... Who is to say that she doesn't have more abilities we haven't seen yet, just because she is labled as and her ambition is to be a "designer".
Still I find it unlikely she will join.
Sanji the cook: tell me again why you couldn't just continue in the old thread? Was it because you didn't really have anything new to say and wanted to seem like you did?
-
it does make it a little easier to have a new thread.
I never said they couldn't join, just that right now I can't see why they wouuld
-
… what? I'm not saying they should join. I'm just countering your "they have no usefull skills" argument since that was crap.
They are quite obviously the Johnny/Yosaku/Conis of Fishman island.
-
by having no usefulls skills I meant she has no skills that qualify her for a position that hasn't been taken.
and I know what you were saying, but I wouldn't be surprised if somebody thinks I'm saying she can't join
-
A little girl who has a crush on Sanji!
Ok, seriously. How about a girl with actual fighting skills? Maybe at around Franky or Brook's level. That'd be nice.
-
A little girl who has a crush on Sanji!
Ok, seriously. How about a girl with actual fighting skills? Maybe at around Franky or Brook's level. That'd be nice.
Yeah, we have someone like that. Her name's Nico Robin. Heard of her? It takes a little bit of knowledge on human anatomy, martial arts and physics to do the moves she does with her powers. It's not like she can randomly spout hands and expect her power to work.
I still say we need a mad bomber in the crew. Who loves pretzels. Lots and lots of pretzels.
-
@Fire Fist:
Yeah, we have someone like that. Her name's Nico Robin. Heard of her? It takes a little bit of knowledge on human anatomy, martial arts and physics to do the moves she does with her powers. It's not like she can randomly spout hands and expect her power to work.
I still say we need a mad bomber in the crew. Who loves pretzels. Lots and lots of pretzels.
I think you misunderstood him. He means real fightin-skills.
I think Shakky will join
-
^I got confused about her, is she stronger then luffy or is that the other guy? if she's also stronger than Luffy, I personally don't she'll join. But if she isn't she's a good possibility
-
Well, I want a girl that can really get down with some fighting moves, not like Robin and Nami that will fight when it's due time, I mean a girl thats willing to fight for the hell of it, maybe like Zoro, and she could be in the top 3!
Also, I really doubt Camie will join, but if she does, she could be a cabin-girl (cabin-boy, look it up) she already does chores and stuff for Hatcchi, and her dream is to be a designer, so she could make cloths and clean n other stuff on Sunny (I'm sure later Oda will make her a fight like Nami), but hey, she's a great character, even though I still want my crazy girl fighter in the crew!
-
I think you misunderstood him. He means real fightin-skills.
I think Shakky will join
Robin has real fighting skills, it's just that there all sorts of fighting skills. Also neither Shakky nor Camie will join. Camie already has nakama - the takoyaki 8. She obviously cares to much for hatchi to leave him behind as well. Shakky quit being a pirate and enjoys her life more because of it. Theres no reason to believe that either would want to join the SH nor that they would bring anything of value to the SH crew.
@ctarlong910:^I got confused about her, is she stronger then luffy or is that the other guy? if she's also stronger than Luffy, I personally don't she'll join. But if she isn't she's a good possibility
So your saying that if she isn't strong she has a good possibility of joining or just stronger than Luffy? I don't think the crew needs any more weaklings right before entering the NW. As a sidenote she was talking about the coater.
-
too bad shakky WON'T join.
thank god.Anyways.
-
I hope Hatchan doesnt-jumping the whale shark there.
Anyway-couldn't you wait till the old thread had at least 100 pages?
-
-
@Fire Fist:
Yeah, we have someone like that. Her name's Nico Robin. Heard of her? It takes a little bit of knowledge on human anatomy, martial arts and physics to do the moves she does with her powers. It's not like she can randomly spout hands and expect her power to work.
Snapping people's backs isn't martial arts. Robin obviously isn't a fighter. I think anyone who's not retarded could do what she does or more if they had the same power, especially if they had it for 20 years. Give me a break.
-
So your saying that if she isn't strong she has a good possibility of joining or just stronger than Luffy? I don't think the crew needs any more weaklings right before entering the NW. As a sidenote she was talking about the coater.
no I'm saying, if she's 10 times stronger then luffy she probably won't join, if she's as strong as franky or brooke, she may
-
Snapping people's backs isn't martial arts. Robin obviously isn't a fighter. I think anyone who's not retarded could do what she does or more if they had the same power, especially if they had it for 20 years. Give me a break.
Yeah, because breaking someone's back doesn't take a considerable amount of strength, especially a man that easily weighs 500 pounds or more (Yama). Nope, doesn't take any strength at all.
[/sarcasm]
Do you take martial arts? Then you'll know that holds are very much a part of Martial arts. Robin doesn't do a bunch of chops and punches with her hands, but she does do different types of grappling, and that's martial arts, like it or not.
-
Robin may not be strong, but she's a helpful nd verstaile fighter. do some of you really think we've seen the last of her tricks? I think there's tonsmore to come.
Damn Golden week. was miss golden week's name a pun on this? -
golden week is over vash now its just the pause Oda decided to take after golden week.
-
@Vash:
Robin may not be strong, but she's a helpful nd verstaile fighter. do some of you really think we've seen the last of her tricks? I think there's tonsmore to come.
Damn Golden week. was miss golden week's name a pun on this?Well, for starters, Robin's pretty strong. Not as strong as Luffy, Zoro and maybe Sanji, but still strong. She struggled to lift Yama, but she was able to do so. If you re-read the fight, she comments on how heavy he is (and he was a huge man).
And the Baroque Works Agents were named after Holidays (the officer agents). So yes, Goldenweek's name comes from the holiday that was celebrated last week.
-
Camie already has nakama - the takoyaki 8. She obviously cares to much for hatchi to leave him behind as well.
Usopp had the Usopp Pirates. Sanji had Baratie. Chopper had Dr. Kureha. Franky had the Franky Family.
Who knows what might come up? It's already clear that although she does like working at the Takoyaki-8 a lot, it's not what her dream is. She doesn't plan to work there forever.
-
Usopp had the Usopp Pirates. Sanji had Baratie. Chopper had Dr. Kureha. Franky had the Franky Family.
what those had in common (well maybe not chopper) was that their "crews" depended on them instead of the other way around.
Camie on the other hand really depends on hatchan. (in so many more ways then chopper in the end depended on kureha)
-
Ummm, to keep her from being eaten. I'm sure the Straw Hats can handle beating up a sea monster every now and then?
-
camie could serve as the crew's official lifeguard haha
saving the DF members if they fall into the sea
-
Camie would be detrimental. Would you want someone that gets eaten on a regular basis to be your partner on a dangerous pirate crew?
Also, I don't know how many times I have to say this, but she is of NO asset to the crew. Robin can fight, she just usually doesn't. Camie is someone who can't defend herself in any way and thus gets captured and/or eaten constantly.
The designer argument? They pull new outfits out of their asses anyways at the beginning of each day. I don't think they have any use for a designer, nonetheless one that they would have to look out for and protect 24/7.
Also, she can't walk.
3DS FC: 0662-3589-2887
NNID: Gibbs-free
-
Camie would be detrimental. Would you want someone that gets eaten on a regular basis to be your partner on a dangerous pirate crew?
Also, I don't know how many times I have to say this, but she is of NO asset to the crew. Robin can fight, she just usually doesn't. Camie is someone who can't defend herself in any way and thus gets captured and/or eaten constantly.
The designer argument? They pull new outfits out of their asses anyways at the beginning of each day. I don't think they have any use for a designer, nonetheless one that they would have to look out for and protect 24/7.
Also, she can't walk.
I facepalm'd.
Seriously, how often is she actually going to be eaten on a ship? And look how physically weak Nami and Usopp are and the assets (even as fighters) they've been. We hardly know anything about Camie, who knows what ways she'd be useful? She's obviously better in the water than any other members, and for a group that sails on the ocean this could be handy.
And they're not going to have to "protect her 24/7". If she's living with them on the ship she isn't going to be swimming around sea monsters being eaten. Sea monsters aren't going to sneak into the girls' bedroom at night to eat her. If she did join, it'd probably just happen once in a while while she was in the water as a gag.
I know this part is just a matter of opinion, but I'm saying it anyway. A fashion designer would be awesome. Oda could do all sorts of cool stuff with that.
And she can walk, she walked to the edge of the deck to call the fish to lead the Straw Hats. She's probably not very good at walking, but she obviously can.
-
I hope a girl with a Zoan fruit joins. We need another Zoan to join, chopper is cool, but we need another, like someone who has an octopuss fruit, and uses 4 hatchets with 4 tentecals, a battle axe with two, and two tentecals to walk.
-
Octopuss-Fruit is pretty useless. I don't think, that such a DF exists.
Well, we know that the SH-Crew is a very individual crew. Everyone is different and pretty rare. Brook is a Skeleton, Ruffy a Rubberman, Lysop and his Long nose, Franky the Cyborg… . I personally think, Camie or Hatchi fit into the crew very well, because they are rare and different from the others.
Camie even more. -
being differnt sn't the qualifier though. tey didnt pick up guy-in-chest or jango either.
Cant we agree that sof ar there is no sign that caimie could join, she seems pretty useless, but that Oda has always one-upped us, so who knows?gorlom: thanks, yeah I know its over, but it still caused a total of a 3 week wait for us, so damn that golden week.
-
Well, a designer like her could also disguise their faces since their wanted, and maybe do stuff to their hair like change it a different color, so that way as they travel they become less noticed… (Sanji with black hair would be sexy)
or they could get a cleaning lady... one who has a weird mop like mermaid fin which can also spin around to fight. but either way, I pray the next nakama is some one who's a mermaid or merwoman... as long as it's female and aquatic, I'm good
they need some one who can fight in the water, period. And they need another female, since the crew is becoming a sausage fest.
Camie has a chance of joining, but unless she shows she's able to fight or some one makes some sort of gizmo for her to fight with, then I doubt she'll join the crew...
-
It's a very simple argument (I don't think I can handle Camie's funeral in english) but until she's not 30 so able to walk (you know, like Kokoro), she just can't be part of the crew.
I'll always think it's impossible. -
It's a very simple argument (I don't think I can handle Camie's funeral in english) but until she's not 30 so able to walk (you know, like Kokoro), she just can't be part of the crew.
I'll always think it's impossible.She CAN walk, she DID. I already said this. I already pointed this out. She's just likely not very good at it.
-
Yeah but she's just unable to handle a fight on the ground.
It's just a big problem, no ? -
Caimie would be nothing but a needless burden. She's a mermaid, so she has to hop around on a tail and possibly has to feel water every now and then. She can't fight, she's not terribly smart, all she has going for her is that she's a female and everyone wants another one of those in the crew.
Opinion or not, Caimie isn't joining. Only way I see her joining is if she goes Ariel at some point and shows that she has some funky designer based fighting style.
-
You're right guys, Oda sure isn't creative enough to make a mermaid a cool member of the crew.
-
You're right guys, Oda sure isn't creative enough to make a mermaid a cool member of the crew.
you can use that argument about anybody. Wiper will join because he's a great fighter, unique, he can fly, he's a rocketeer which is so cool and oda is creative enough to bring him back.
-
you can use that argument about anybody. Wiper will join because he's a great fighter, unique, he can fly, he's a rocketeer which is so cool and oda is creative enough to bring him back.
I believe my original statement was basically "There's no reason yet to believe Camie will join, but it's possible. And I personally think it would be cool if she did."
I'm not trying to prove she WILL, just that people who are saying "no that will never happen" are dumbasses who haven't been paying attention to One Piece where things like KUMA IS A CYBORG and BROOK IS LABOON'S NAKAMA happen.
-
oh then I agree, it's possible
-
I like mermaids and I like Camie…but for the long run I don't see it. She really doesn't have a tool or a purpose on the ship that isn't already being taken...and fashion designer really doesn't have a connection to pirates as stuff like "navigator", "doctor" or even "musician". I personally wouldn't mind a younger female to balance out Nami and Robin but Camie..then again, any mermaid under 30...wouldn't really be it.
At the same time, I wouldn't mind if one of the Supernova's sort of becomes a second SH fleet akin to the WB pirates.
Y'know, Negima WAS awesome…
For the first 18 volumes.
-
Was pondering the supernovas myself. Strictly on first impressions, I could see really liking Jewelry Bonny (the eating chick). I can't see this designer/bartender woman joining, just because she looks way too much like Robin at a glance.
Do see the next nakama being a girl, since the numbers are looking pretty imbalanced about now.
When GM demands to know what my character is doing, it better not be "The Charleston"
Wash: Little River just gets more colorful by the moment. What'll she do next?
Zoe: Either blow us all up or rub soup in her hair. It's a toss-up.
Wash: I hope she does the soup thing. It's always a hoot, and we don't all die from it.
-
I stick to my belief that the next two crewmembers will be a fishman and a woman. A great white shark or squid fishman and a woma that joins the crew after they enter the new world.
As forthe supernova's, i wouldn't want them to become allies but rather rivals in the new world, especially Kid, Law and Drake. -
Was pondering the supernovas myself. Strictly on first impressions, I could see really liking Jewelry Bonny (the eating chick). I can't see this designer/bartender woman joining, just because she looks way too much like Robin at a glance.
Do see the next nakama being a girl, since the numbers are looking pretty imbalanced about now.
I'm open to Bonney being one of those allies I mentioned instead of a crewmate myself. Her gluttony and Oda's love of cowboys might make her a good person to show up down the line. Drake and Hawkins seem like potential allies as well…Kid just seems like a creep that needs to be surpassed and Law's just creepy. The rest will probably not be that important.
-
Neither Camie nor Hatchan will join, Hatchan is a loser and Camie is just a cheerleader. Right now my favourite is a mermaid who ate a devil fruit and is thus unable to swim.
Gorlak wants you for the army
-
Neither Camie nor Hatchan will join, Hatchan is a loser and Camie is just a cheerleader. Right now my favourite is a mermaid who ate a devil fruit and is thus unable to swim.
If a mermaid like that were to join, she'd have to be at least 32. Between, Franky, Robin, and Brooke, we have enough old people. It'd be nice to see some genius kid. May be a Shonen Stereotype but I don't care.
But he needs to be a mad bomber. And addicted to pretzels.
In any case, I still think Octopako is gonna show up and join at some point in this arc.
I called it wrong, so long ago. I guess this needs to be changed.
-
Samson and Adon from Chou Aniki need to join, so that Thousand Sunny can fire off volleys of lasers as a back-up to Gaon Cannon; they would also serve to terrify enemy pirates with that "I'm gonna rape you!" vibe. [/bat-shit insanity]
I'm like Hisotensoku: Not here to preserve peace, nor to destroy it. I certainly can't move mountains. Mostly, I'm just full of hot air.- Meh
