A majority of girls I've talked to dislike Brook, and I've created this thread to ask you women of apforums why. Is it his pervertedness? The fact that he's the second swordsman of the crew? Do you not like skeletons? Does he scare you? What?
edit-
And I'm allowing the guys to post theri speculations as to why women hate Brook as well.
I like Brook. Skeletons are interesting and some girls are scared of interesting things, like skeletons.
But but but…. He's just so cute! D: A very likeable character, YOHOHOHOHO.
Well, he's not really flesh...I can't imagine having....er, sleeping with a skeleton. It's weird, but he's like a really silly uncle. Like Millenium Earl from D. Gray Man....but not as sadistic.
Do any girls think that Brooke is "hawt"?
Well, he's not really flesh…I can't imagine having....er, sleeping with a skeleton.
You've been thinking about that, haven't you? :getlost:
Anyway, I don't see any reason why girls would dislike Brook. I mean, he is a gentleman. Maybe it's the afro. =/
FLOW for any OP Opening! 
Thank you so much, Amai-Mikan!
You've been thinking about that, haven't you? :getlost:
No, not alot. This thread just brought up the thought like ten minutes or so ago. Now it's really scaring me.
I think someone needs to eat a happle. <3Mah dA.Bombing for peace is like having sex for virginity.
I would think he was hot if it wasn't for his sunglasses when he was human. I'm no necrophiliac, so I don't think that skeleton Brook is hot, just adorable like a puppy. His sunglasses made his entire face look odd to me. But girls should be crazy about men in suits, isn't that one of the reasons CP9 has so many fans (me among them)?
Note to self: Wear more suits.
I'm thinking that it's the afro. Definitively. Afros are not compatible with females.
They were in the '70s. Even my grandfather had a 'fro.
^ But that was then, and this is now. I say we build a time machine and get afros! I mean…ask them about Brook there.
FLOW for any OP Opening!
Thank you so much, Amai-Mikan!
Because they can't talk about his "package" which is the most important thing a guy should have.
I am not a girl, but this is the only place I found with questions about Brook.
How are his pants connected? I tried to find a logical answer, but it didn't turn out so well.
pants connected to what? maybe he is wearing suspenders? or whatever
I came here to speculate as well-probably cause,unlike Zoro or Sanji, theres nothing to "idolise" on him.
Describe what you mean by idolize.
like the girls may like their type or something,its a general "likes/dislikes" thing, but theres nothin' like that on Brooke.
There's his personality 
Don't tell me you think he lacks pesonality. He's a jolly, cheerful sole. He's also shown a sense of honor in recent chapters, as well as several strong emotions.
He's also a musician. Girls digg musicians… =P
he's 88 years old.
89, actually. just made things worse for Brook
And still as lively as when he was ~42.
and he has no wrinkles. pretty damn good
waits for someone to pull a viagra joke
Er, I like him. And I like zombies as well
Talking skeletons are fucking awesome
So… I guess I can't help you =/
Brook is so cool <3
My mate really likes Gecko Moria, but then again there always are exceptions.
Okay, here's the dirt on us ladies;
We want them to be nice and buff, with nice butts.
So we can slide our hands into their pockets.
Reason why Zorro is one of the most popular males amongst us.
Now Brooke, despite his personality…he lacks the grope-able arse.
Nuff said.
:ninja:
Is there some woman around here that can think about things other than ass and penis?
@AWB:
Is there some woman around here that can think about things other than ass and penis?
….
OOH! Testicles!
=D
Just kidding, don't shoot the messenger.
I said I luffle Brook.
I just dislike him cus he's a freakin' douche. I have no problem with afro's, bones, pervertness or crude humor.. he's just a douche.
EDIT: Wait.. there was mentions of ass and penis? I see neither.. YOU LIE.
Explain why you think he's a douche.
[QUOTE=funkyfunkyusopp
]I just dislike him cus he's a freakin' douche. I have no problem with afro's, bones, pervertness or crude humor.. he's just a douche.
Brook is a pervert?!?!
[QUOTE=funkyfunkyusopp
]EDIT: Wait.. there was mentions of ass and penis? I see neither.. YOU LIE.
~cough~
Says Usopp. I-roooo-neeeee!
Reasons why I think he's a douche?
I've seen up to 349.. yes I am SO behind.. anyway… he's just reallly OTT and the tings he's funny at he over does. He's too in your face and frankly... I am yet to be impressed.. his voice makes me shuuder too.
I see….
You should still read his flashback. It's quite touching.
I don't know… I bet I'll still hate him.
Let me ask you one question: what does OTT mean?
Apearantly he is into scat. Going around and asking decent women/mermaids if they poop. Proposterous.
You gotta be kidding me.
…
Now that I think of it...how do mermaids poop?
mermaids poop like fish do?
OOT = Over The Top
But, I haven't seen any holes drawn onto them…
That felt wrong, I'm pulling out of this discussion.
~gags~
I'm female annnnd I love Brooke. I reckon he's awesome. :D
WHAT
Girls don't like Brook??
I've loved him since I first saw him in the manga. He's so hilarious and rude, and of course his story is touching. He's easily in my top three favorite characters.
I guess there are some girls who are only interested in male characters that they think are HAWT, so I can see why they wouldn't like Brook, since I would assume that most girls aren't sexually attracted to skeletons.
WHAT
Girls don't like Brook??
I've loved him since I first saw him in the manga. He's so hilarious and rude, and of course his story is touching. He's easily in my top three favorite characters.
I guess there are some girls who are only interested in male characters that they think are HAWT, so I can see why they wouldn't like Brook, since I would assume that most girls aren't sexually attracted to skeletons.
Haha I find Foxy hot and I'd bone skinny Wapol so it's not due to him not being 'hot' I like ugly men so.
Haha I find Foxy hot and I'd bone skinny Wapol so it's not due to him not being 'hot' I like ugly men so.
Eeeek!
:cwy::sick:
Women on the internet?
Thanks for the good laugh.
(yea, i'm an ass for that)
J
Check out larger(huge) pictures of One Piece flags in my deviant art gallery: http://zerocustom1989.deviantart.com/gallery/
Official Gol D Roger. Just added.
see now this topic is getting somewhere… metions of ass, penis AND woman I hope not all at once..
So, basically women who like Brook like him for who he is and what he's overcome in his..er, "life"? And other women dislike him because he's lacking somewhat in the 'performance' department or because they have a bad first impression of him?
Just to hijack AWB's thread for a minute, I'd like to pose a question about Brook to the ladies of APforums: Is Brook doomed to always be in the "just friends" category, or is there any woman in OP that could be paired with him romantically, but not sexually?
Brook doesn't ask anyone if they can poop, that's a new running gag for Luffy.
You know, I can't think of anyone besides Brook and Caimie that he's asked that to.
He asked Camie… I think
They aren't exact "human" so that's why he asked them (besides, wouldn't you want to know).
