Oh, and Cap'n, you're also right about that whole giant chicken thing, only funny the first time.
Gotta disagree on the chicken thing. So long as they limit it to completely random unexpected moments and each is subsequently more obnoxious than the rest, I think it's great.
The difference between the chicken and Herbert is….Herbert is the same goddamn thing over and over.
The chicken grows and expands though.
First they had a somewhat unexpected altercation that parodied multiple action franchises.
Second it came literally the fuck out of nowhere and just went insanse.
Third it also came out of left field BUT not only did it parody itself with the ferris wheel insanity which is even more ridiculous than most other things the show has attempted, but then they added the restaurant scene which was priceless.
That I don't mind really because it's showing growth and development of an idea, plus it only pops up like once a season.
Herbert is literally the same gag over and over with no sign of going anywhere new.
I'll admit it showed promise when they said Stewie took over Chris' route, and it looked like Herbert was gonna have a rival in Stewie, but no, back to Chris and more of the same 'lure the boy out' gags, ho hum.
I don't want to demand a show display something new or I shall not be entertained, but don't become a one-trick pony. South Park parodied themselves awesomely with the whole Kenny thing.
The Kenny thing was retarded by 2001 and when they actually bothered to put it in we didn't even care anymore (neither did Stan or Kyle) but then when they really killed him off for a season, suddenly it was funny and hilarious when he just wandered back in at the end of an episode. I hope the chicken thing goes that route because I think it's one of the best things the show has to offer.
That and random raccoon attacks.