Which country so far do you guys think the Straw Hats have stayed in the longest: Alabasta, Skypia or Water 7?
IMHO, it seems like they were in Water 7 longer than anywhere else. Or maybe it's just me.
Longest Host Nation for the Straw Hats
-
-
Alabasta Vol 18-23
Skypiea Vol 24-32
Water 7 Vol 34-38,45-46
Volume-wise Skypiea would be the longest, Although one volume alone was merely flashbacks with Norlands ancestor so seven volumes of Skypiea involving the strawhats. Leaving Alabasta and Water7 on roughly the same length, assuming that you count the water7 arc for just water7, if you add it to the seatrain chase and Eneas lobby then it will without a doubt become the longest sofar. Volume 34 all the way to vol 46
-
Either Alabasta or Water 7.
Water 7 happened in a week. However, without knowing Alabasta's log time we can't say how long they spent there. We know from Luffy being sick for a few days after being posioned by Croc they spent a couple of days in the capitol. Rough guess, length of days wise, they stayed at Alabasta for the longest period of time.
chapter length wise, the situation is very different.
-
Yeah, if it's the "real time", ie days passed in the story, that would mean Alabasta is the longest host nation. The whole process would have been no less than a week, from arrival to Luffy's recovery. I think it took them more than 3 days just getting from places to places, and not hitting the right one
Water 7 and Enies Lobby combined, I think, would amount to only 3-4 days approx. Remeber that everything happened really quickly in Water 7 (but not for us readers =P) and they progressed to Enies Lobby right after. Enies Lobby itself is extremely short, but the chapers are dragged out so much because of the sheer amount of different battles.
-
Its suprising that each arc is only like 1-7 days long. Wierd. I think that the time it takes them to sail is the longest though. But definitely Alabasta. Don't forget after it they spent like a week bathing and feasting.
-
Its suprising that each arc is only like 1-7 days long. Wierd. I think that the time it takes them to sail is the longest though. But definitely Alabasta. Don't forget after it they spent like a week bathing and feasting.
lol luffy is going to become pirate king after only being on sea for about less than a year. sucks for all the pirates on the grandline that have been there for decades.
-
Come to think about it, their whole journey's probably about a few months – half a year max. But of course, we don't know how long they spend on the sea... Oda would have skipped all those days of Luffy's "are we there yet?"
-
Yeah, if you are not on a motor powered boat, it can take weeks to get to islands. Im asumming its like this. East Blue Arc was about 1 1/2 months. Alabasta including all of the islands like Cactus Town, Little Garden and Drum Island was about 4 months. Jaya and Skypeia was maybe 2 weeks. Foxy, W7 and Thriller Bark so far maybe 2 weeks again. So far they have been sailings for like 6 and a half months. LMAO
-
skypia was 3 days we see…..(night at the campfire....night at the big end party...and than they go)
water 7 was longer (night at:usopp vs. luffy....ehm the night they go after the seatrain...and when they `re back they waited some days for the new ship)
alabaste---(night in the oase....than 3 days sleep of ruffy...and than the couple of days they stated their...)so water 7 was cause of the waitingtime for the ship the longest....
dont want to look upUnrevealed_Loki/Rocks/Im-san_
IslandElbaf/Raftel/GodValley
UnresolvedWeevil´s plan/Explaining DFs/Deal with Kuma-Bonney´s past/Joy-Boy/Zunisha´s story/Rocks flashback/Void Century/Rioponeglyph/Uranus/the D.clan
DFWind/Metal/Acid/Liquid/Time-Stop
-
-
number of chapters to measure the length of time? Nonsense i say…
Skypiea arc only lasted 3 day...
longest TOTAL time spent at an island:
WATER SEVEN = 2+5 days
LONG RING LONG ISLAND = 5 days
ALABASTAN KINGDOM = 6 daysthese are the only places that the manga had stated the number of days they stayed..
人生不过三万天，成功失败均坦然，
是非恩怨莫在意，健康快乐最值钱.
-
so how much times has passed in the actual manga?
-
Since the first chapter till the current one, how long is it?
BTW, I REALLY want them to celebrate a birthday of someone from the nakama one day, It'll be totally awesome. -
what do you mean by longest host nation? are you talking about actual days or just chapters?
-
I think that Thriller park may be a long arc as well, but that's just me.
-
remeber they also stay extra 5 days waiting for the ship to be build
-
The log pose changed for water 7 after 1 week. The ship was just about built in time thanks to the Galley-le's help. EL happens in less then one day.
Alabasta definately happened longer, there is no way it could be a week. They spent 3/4 (can't remember) days just nursing Luffy back to health! That means only 3/2 days were spent running around the country, which doesn't sound right at all.
The only clue for length of time is the fact none of the crew have been announced to have aged, so we can presume that they haven't been at sea for a year - yet.
-
Kind of random, but didn't the Baratie arc and Arlong arc happen on the same day? o.o
-
Yes, the entire East Blue Saga (excluding travel time, which you can assume isn't very much) took no more than a week if I remember correctly.
-
Does that include potential travel time between islands?
Waldorf: You know Statler, after watching the last one thousand episodes of One Piece, I think I've come to a conclusion.
Statler: No you haven't.
Both: DOHOHOHOHOHO!
-
Spicy Chicken
Kind of random, but didn't the Baratie arc and Arlong arc happen on the same day? o.oi dont think so,cause ruffy sleeped also after the fight vs krieg…
but sometimes we havent any hint if its the same day or the next....we always just getting the waiting time on a gl-island so far
the action seems to be that the whole story could be in so far maybe a few months.....
the moon-theorie gives us some conclusions but we don`t get the time the SH just have no action---lol this few days hahaha
-
Ah dammit, not another "How long has the One Piece storyline been?". We've had so many of these topics..
-
Ah dammit, not another "How long has the One Piece storyline been?". We've had so many of these topics..
That wasn't the point of this topic though. I'm just curious as to which country has hosted the Straw Hats the longest. Sorry if some people are discussing the time-length of the overall storyline.
-
Ah dammit, not another "How long has the One Piece storyline been?". We've had so many of these topics..
Well, One Piece isn't done ya know. I don't care if we will have another 3 like these. It's really interesting to know since Oda won't tell us, always keeping the calculations to himself.
-
Leaf Cable: are you wondering about time they spend at an island. or number of chapters?
-
Leaf Cable: are you wondering about time they spend at an island. or number of chapters?
Actually, I'm curious about both! To be specific though, I would say I'm leaning towards the time they spent. From the looks of it, it seems like either Alabasta or Water 7 is the record-taker.
I wouldn't mind knowning the chapter length for either country either. So now you know what I'm asking about!:happy: -
Kind of random, but didn't the Baratie arc and Arlong arc happen on the same day? o.o
Man, I hope not. That would be one exhausting day. Let Luffy catch a break.
-
The end of the Krieg fight didn't happen on the same day as getting to AP. But Sanji and Luffy DID appear to get to Arlong Park the same day as Zoro and Usopp did, thanks to Mohmoo.
-
I remember that there was this guy who did a amazing job on making a time table by using the moon. Maybe that could help.
Here's the like:http://www.apforums.net/showthread.php?t=11069&highlight=moon+theory
-
Just want to point out that after the battle of Skypiea, it mentions that Luffy and co celebrated for a couple of days. No exact number but it's probably three days like Alabasta and Water 7.
-
I remember that there was this guy who did a amazing job on making a time table by using the moon. Maybe that could help.
Here's the like:http://www.apforums.net/showthread.php?t=11069&highlight=moon+theory
That's a very interesting point. Do you think Oda did that on puropse? I wouldn't put it past him.
Click here for the best Pokemon fanfiction ever written!
-
the funniest part about everything is that they've become so damn close after only being with each other so little. also they developed that real close relationship with the going merry that made the klauberman come out. lol it's gonna suck when luffy defeats both shanks and whitebeard after only being on sea for like 6 months and they've been on the grandline for decades getting stronger and stronger but only to be beaten by some rookie.
-
It actually wouldn't suprsie me… A person can raise and fall to power qu ickly in RL as well. Also it suits t he image building up in front of the WG, if he does everything quickly; he came out of nowhere and undid everything in the last 22 years.
It wouldn't suprise me if Luffy is crown PK 25 years from the last PK because Oda decided to slow everything down at some point for a few years (OP timeline) making it 3 years after Luffy departure. At that time, Luffy will be 20 as well. Not saying it will happen, but it wouldn't suprise me.
-
If I remember rightly, Johnny (Or Yosaku?) said that Baratie was a week's sailing away from where they boarded the ship, so the East Blue saga was probably a bit longer than a week… two weeks, maybe.
-
East Blue is tough to assume.
What we know:
Everything pre-Baratie is impossible to determine, but probably a couple of weeks including travel time
Luffy worked at the Baratie for two days(caption says '2 days later)
The Baratie and Arlong arcs took place over 2 days(Luffy sleeps after beating Krieg, and it's morning of the next day when he wakes up)
After beating Arlong, they partied for like 3 days or so
They were in Logue Town for one day, travel time unknownSo there was 6 days between Baratie and Arlong arc, and counting everything, the East Blue arc probably lasted a month or so.
-
Well,we could asume that the time taken up by filler arcs in the anime could be the equivalent of when nothing happened,though its just me.
-
Alabasta 6 days
Skypeaia.4 days
Water7 5 days. -
Come to think about it, their whole journey's probably about a few months – half a year max. But of course, we don't know how long they spend on the sea... Oda would have skipped all those days of Luffy's "are we there yet?"
It couldn't be that short, no one's boobs grow that big that fast. Unless of course you have the boob boob fruit.
