who thinks that in order to cross the red line have to go to the underwater mermen/fisherman island and when you are ready to go to the next island the underwater cavern or tunnel takes to the other side of the red line so you cross underneath the land using the water cavern or what not instead of crrossing over the red line
any thought as to my theory or theory of your own might good.
Likely. And maybe there's an over-the-top way as well but it just leads out of the Grand Line.
I can see that being a deffinative.
Could be a possibility.
How can an Island be underwater? An island is land above the water, maybe the land part is just the upper part of the caves.
well it can be in a sort of "air bulle" or something.
and for crossing the red line, it's either that, or they will jump over it with coup de bust.
If water can run up a mountain than an island can be under water. It will be explained, somehow.
Of course not. If an island is under land, the log pose would set to the magnetic field of the closest mass of land, aka the RED LINE.
Coup de Bust was introduced for a reason. It's either to go back to the White Sea or to cross the Red Line. Both are possible, but the latter is far more likely.
I think that there is a "myth" about the equivalent to the real world's myth about the straight that let's you cross south america (but didn't actually exist), and that Luffy and crew will find it somehow, but finding it will only be half the battle as crossing it will leave them completely vulnerable and only able to flee in two directions (or no directions if the navy is smart).
who thinks that in order to cross the red line have to go to the underwater mermen/fisherman island and when you are ready to go to the next island the underwater cavern or tunnel takes to the other side of the red line so you cross underneath the land using the water cavern or what not instead of crrossing over the red line
any thought as to my theory or theory of your own might good.
Unfortunately I don't support this theory. If you had to go to Merman/Fishman island in order to "cross" the RL, then it would imply that every magnetic path connects to Merman/Fishman island (which to my knowledge it does not). We're told that the paths eventually join at Raftel.
However, I do support the underground water tunnels or maybe even something similar to Reverse Mountain where there is a current that let's you go back and forth "across" the RL for each magnetic field.
After the SHs first entered the GL via RM, I had a theory that the official exit from the GL was at the 2nd intersection of GL and RL. I speculated that at this 2nd intersection, there'd be the option of continuing through to the 2nd half of the GL, or exiting to any of the 4 blues. Depending on where you approach to the RL would determine which field you connect to as you exit. Of course, this could lead to the possibility of having to wait a few days at the RL, and I actually don't like this theory. Not very feasible IMO, so I think the tunnels are a better speculation.
I think that there is a "myth" about the equivalent to the real world's myth about the straight that let's you cross south america (but didn't actually exist), and that Luffy and crew will find it somehow, but finding it will only be half the battle as crossing it will leave them completely vulnerable and only able to flee in two directions (or no directions if the navy is smart).
This isn't "15 miles on the Pirate's Canal". The Red Line is Marijoi or Marine HQ (Most likely scenario; I doubt some ordinary town would be in such a strategic location). They have to go over under or the Red Line, and considering that Coup de Bust was introduced for a reason, the obvious reason is to use it to fly over Marijoi and cross the Red Line.
I called it wrong, so long ago. I guess this needs to be changed.
Wow, like everyone hasn't already been talking about this.
@Fire Fist:
This isn't "15 miles on the Pirate's Canal". The Red Line is Marijoi or Marine HQ (Most likely scenario; I doubt some ordinary town would be in such a strategic location). They have to go over under or the Red Line, and considering that Coup de Bust was introduced for a reason, the obvious reason is to use it to fly over Marijoi and cross the Red Line.
I really doubt that Coup de Bust is going to send the ship a mere fifteen miles in the sky (that would be a longer distance than the ascent into Skypeia), let alone more than that. A canal seems much more reasonable and I wasn't aware that the ship doubled as a submarine, and I really doubt that every single ship which has crossed the red line either flew over it or submarined under it.
I've also been theorising that that part of the Red Line is The Holy Land of Mariejoie, which have made me theorising about how to get pass it.
I have a fanboy dream that the World Government might have set up this huge system of boarder controlls and things like that in order to capture pirates wishing to get into the New World, and other criminals. There's several straits and things like that, and the Strawhats will face a major problem when getting into the New World.
Franky will tell them that the Coup de Bust might have them flying a long bit, but that the Holy Land is several miles from one coast to another, and that it would be impossible for them to get over using it.
How they actually will enter the New World I do not even have a fanboy dream about. Maybe Franky will install some system of propellers and stuff like that that'll make the ship technically fly over the Holy Land.
OP 
