well since there seem to be few polls out there….i decided to do one...
This is a tough question but my answer would have to be robin...she doesnt seem to have much dialogue
well since there seem to be few polls out there….i decided to do one...
This is a tough question but my answer would have to be robin...she doesnt seem to have much dialogue
I don't think I like this topic
:(:(:(:( see all the sad faces?
Nami !
(Yes, that was a joke. Shut up.)
Gotta say Zoro, with Robin-chwan running a close second. :(
Gee, I don't really like where this topic is going.
Btw: Tengu, I love your sig.
This….
I don't feel any of them are. They're all cool, and the story wouldn't be the same without them.
Usopp… just as Zoro and Robin, serves for no specific purpose aside from helping out in the action, but as much as it pains me to admit it he's not quite as reliable at doing that as the other two. :/
Edit: Wait a second, dispensible as in useful to the crew or dispensible as in the one I would least mind leaving?
just to make something clear…by making this poll im not saying oda should get rid of ANY characters...im just curious as to wat other people think
I think a poll like this is a bad idea. It usually leads to someone's feelings getting hurt. And I really don't think ANY of them are dispensible.
I think Luffy…..........................................(hehehe)
No One's Goin To Leave! That's It! :lol:
i voted ussop because if you look at the big picture zoro and robin are luffy's strongest crew members. Sanji and and chopper are needed to keep the members alive via medicine and food. And well nami is the navigator they would be lost without her. And luffy is the captain he cant leave.
I would be sad if ussop left though since he is the comic relief :(
Dammit, Usopp is not just comic relief. :P (I'm in a fightin' mood today) Luffy more often is the comic relief anyway.
to each his own if you think he has a greater purpose other then comic relief i respect your opinion, but i see him as part of the comic relief :)
Damn, I can't believe you guys. Why would you you post here? There is TWO poll post about are gonna leave and yet you know it gets old: why post here?
I say this again, and I'm not going to say anymore of this, no one is leaving the crew. Now please shut up and let it go(Don't rise my warning level Mods, it's not like I'm being rude; it's just old :( )
i dont like this topic too! it's bad
As long as no one bashes, I am leaving this open.
And no, I am not gonna vote anyone. No one is dispensible.
this poll is stupid there should be a option for noone.
Originally posted by StrawHatLuffy@May 20 2005, 10:46 AM
As long as no one bashes, I am leaving this open.
Want me to start bashing so that you can close it?;)
No but seriously, though I find this (yet again) a silly poll there should at least be the none option. That way it would at least be clear how many people find that idea stupid.
i can't decide. maybe robin sice all she does is sit around reading books. i mean, who reads books? :P
(i'm kidding of course ;))
They all should be dispensible. That way I can save money from products…but then what would I do with my life?
I..I can't choose
I love them all
so I'm not going to ;_;
I can't choose, so therefore I won't choose… I think a better question would have been which is the most indispensible of the straw-hats... Because, face it, people aren't gonna say so'n'so' is useless because–
People would more likely prefer to say who they feel are the most important members.
Hah! Some people have said Luffy is dispensible! Hello... No Luffy, no crew. Period. Pah.
--Saito
Originally posted by Saito Ayame@May 20 2005, 10:46 AM
**I can't choose, so therefore I won't choose… I think a better question would have been which is the most indispensible of the straw-hats... Because, face it, people aren't gonna say so'n'so' is useless because–People would more likely prefer to say who they feel are the most important members.
Hah! Some people have said Luffy is dispensible! Hello... No Luffy, no crew. Period. Pah.
--Saito
[snapback]52439[/snapback]**
Yeah I choose Luffy just to be stupid. I don't mean it. Of course they need Luffy, he's the CAPTAIN! The other people who choose Luufy are proboally doing the same thing, to see what people will say.
Robin.
The other six have so much chemistry and friendship together. They're the perfect cast for an anime. Then they toss Robin at us and it's just like…why? I personally don't find her interesting at all. Bon Clay would have been a much better choice if they had to pick a character from the Alabasta arc, if only for the comedic scenes that would come with him. The first time he met the Strawhats, he showed a lot of chemistry with them. Robin did not. She's just mysterious and enigmatic, and that's boring with an anime like One Piece. We already have Zoro to be the brooding one. Vivi would have been a better choice, as well, but I liked it better that she stayed and tried to rebuild her country. I dunno, something about Robin just irks me.
There's my two cents.
The problem is, generally when someone starts a poll like this, they have a particular crewmember that they feel is dispensible, and they just want to see if other people agree :lol: Why even put Luffy on the list? Does anyone really think he's dispensible? I don't think so.
Eh, and Usopp DOES have a greater purpose other than comic relief. That is not an opinion, it's a fact. I'm not saying he isn't EVER comic relief; he is a lot. Every member of the crew is part of comic relief at some point.
Originally posted by RomanMack@May 20 2005, 11:16 AM
Yeah I choose Luffy just to be stupid. I don't mean it. Of course they need Luffy, he's the CAPTAIN! The other people who choose Luufy are proboally doing the same thing, to see what people will say.
[snapback]52446[/snapback]
Either that or they have something against rubber monkeys :\ I'd agree with ya, but sometimes, peoples minds are funny and they don't consider the bare facts.
I agree with ComicDebriss, Ussop is vital, throughout the story thus so far, there have been occasions that if Usopp had not stepped in… Well, bye bye straw-hats... The story really wouldn't be the same without him...
--Saito
None of them… I can't vote on a mean poll like this.. :(
Originally posted by Nyssane@May 20 2005, 11:25 AM
**Robin.The other six have so much chemistry and friendship together. They're the perfect cast for an anime. Then they toss Robin at us and it's just like…why? I personally don't find her interesting at all. Bon Clay would have been a much better choice if they had to pick a character from the Alabasta arc, if only for the comedic scenes that would come with him. The first time he met the Strawhats, he showed a lot of chemistry with them. Robin did not. She's just mysterious and enigmatic, and that's boring with an anime like One Piece. We already have Zoro to be the brooding one. Vivi would have been a better choice, as well, but I liked it better that she stayed and tried to rebuild her country. I dunno, something about Robin just irks me.
There's my two cents.
[snapback]52450[/snapback]**
I agree, except I think Vivi and Bon Clay would be even worse (I find both of them to be hideously annoying).
Though I admit Robin is good as a comedic foil (like when she effortlessly caught the Southbird when everyone else was struggling, how she got straight to the ruins in Upperyard, etc.), she'd be my pick, though I don't want to see anyone go.
Originally posted by fubukii@May 20 2005, 09:34 AM
to each his own if you think he has a greater purpose other then comic relief i respect your opinion, but i see him as part of the comic relief
Really, without Usopp the ship would had dunked and sunk long time ago - he even painted and invented the flag you're using as your avatar. Besides, Usopp has had some of the most baddass moments of the series and he has more character development than others. I wouldn't call that mere comic relief.
We have seen topics alike several times before, haven't we, and I still don't like the idea as all of them serves a good purpose, even Robin and Zoro whom I'm not that fond of.
bleh iretract all statements ussop is god
ur mom is dispensibl!!!!1111oneeleventwelvwomglololo i dont evne feel lik takin thsi sereuslee!1111 is's not even wrth it!!!!1111oneomg
bleh iretract all statements ussop is god
There you go, that's the spirit. xD I knew you'd see things my way.
Originally posted by StrawHatLuffy@May 20 2005, 04:46 AM
As long as no one bashes, I am leaving this open.
< I'm really fighting the urge to bash this poll…...
i just dont feel like agrueing about ussop. Just because he isnt my favorite character. If you guyz like him alot to each his own, he just isnt one of my favorite crew members respect my opinion :)
Hey, I'm not trying to dis your opinion or anything. ^_^ I don't really see what's there to argue about anyway, it's a fact that Usopp does more than comedy.
OMG TENGU. YOUR SOGEKING SIG ….. IS SO SEXSAH.
Originally posted by Cap'n Carter@May 20 2005, 02:54 PM
I agree, except I think Vivi and Bon Clay would be even worse (I find both of
them to be hideously annoying).
whhaaaaatttt?unbelieve!someone who dont like these two great characters? :blink:
ok vivi was a little bit annoying at some times but still great but how can someone dont like the man/woman who is friendship itself in person?
~luffy cant get rid of him because with out him i dont think the group would stay together plus hes the main character
~zoro hes the swordsman and although he doesnt act it often he is definetly the first mate look at anytime luffy is really gone not just lost and they need a leader zoro takes over.
~nami they would be so lost its not even funny plus who would keep luffy zoro and sanji in line
~usopp if the whole crew was made up of people who where like unbelevably strong the show would be borring. usopp is the average guy hes good at one thing shooting and when hes really chalanged he will step up but he is afraid just like any normal peron would be
~sanji they would starve or get sick and die
~Chopper zoro would blead to death and everyone else would die from wounds and disease
~robin something tells me being able to read the cubes (cant remember what they are called right now and i dont fell like loking it up) will be needed latter on
to sum up they are all needed to balance out the crew and help eachother get to ther goals i think each is just as important they are all just are needed in different areas. so i piked no one -_-
Bon Clay was a really cool and fun character, but by the end of Alabasta it became apparent he'd be severely annoying if he had stuck around.
I think Mashira, he was just too strange even for me to like.
I choose Luffy olny to see the poll results, I did not actully voted anyone.
Luffy-I saw you in a Toei site in 1999, you'r cool dude so don't die on me
Usopp-Yer a reflexible character just like Jou Kido from Digimon. You'r too ligth-hearted, you'r a battery to my interst in One Piece
Zoro-Not much to say about him but I don't want him to go away
Nami-Yeah, yeah she's an annoy bitch but she is worthy not to die
Robin-Do you want her word in DBF arc "I don't want to travel with two-piece head" be a lie? she olny been in the crew for 107 chapters and replaced Vivi's postion, it's not wise to kill her off now or her dreams would be a rip off.
Chopper-When did people started theorizing him to be a terminated character?
Sanji-Why won't someone remamber my "Sanji the terminated character" post back in the old forum? Anyway his girl-crazy attitude can be annoy but he earn my respect because he does not always go girl-crazy. So terminating him will suck BIG time.
sadly i mkust say ussop.
Nami? She's with Zoro in the glue of the Straw Hats, imo.
Luffy. I mean, what DOES he do?! He never seems to do anything! Who has he beaten in a fight? No one, that's who! He never makes any jokes, so he's useless as comic relif, and he's rarely ever in the show!
Luffy, I say! Luffy!
Little sad thread…well,I will say what I think:
Starting,for me,the captain and navigator are the heart of ship.So there´s no way for Luffy or Nami run away,even the strawhat are idiot,or she are the weakest(only in strenght,of course.).
A doctor and a cook are very very important too.Injuries and hunger are no good.Then Sanji and Chopper(Even the kawaii reindeer are a little cowardly) stay too.
Then we have a fighter.Yeah,Luffy and Sanji take the situations easy,but...ah whatever,a first mate are important!So Zoro stays(Even the Marimo are lazy sometimes...).
Now,Usopp and Robin...in fact,wihout the sniper,maybe GM doesn´t get all the way to W7...and the archaeologist are very strong,smart and experient...
Conclusion...no one run away...
Originally posted by Nami-chan@May 21 2005, 06:13 AM
…and the archaeologist are very strong,smart and experient...
[snapback]52737[/snapback]
I might add that on a pirate ship an archeologist is actually a very important part. In every pirate story there´s some guy who´s able to understand treasure maps and the writing on some old ruins where a treasure lies. In fact you see more of such character´s in pirate stories then you see the cook. That´s why Nico Robin is a very important part of the Strawhats and why her position on a pirate ship is justified. Everyone who doesn´t want to accept it should also accept that he doesn´t really understand pirate stories!
In fact,that´s a important point…
Originally posted by Ivotas+May 21 2005, 08:25 AM–>QUOTE(Ivotas @ May 21 2005, 08:25 AM)
I'm really glad we implicated that new poll rule, it's just too bad this one wasn't started later.
…I cannot believe 6 people voted for Luffy. I mean...really. Have you been watching the show?
I'm not even going to discuss this, we've already had threads like this, and I've already given my answer.
Don't worry, I think most of the people voted for Luffy out of anger of the ridiculousness of the poll. ^_^
Nico Robin, she doesn't do much for the Straw Hats but they need a cook, marksman, captain, swordsman and doctor.
Originally posted by Seta Ginny@May 25 2005, 05:48 PM
**I'm really glad we implicated that new poll rule, it's just too bad this one wasn't started later.…I cannot believe 6 people voted for Luffy. I mean...really. Have you been watching the show?
I'm not even going to discuss this, we've already had threads like this, and I've already given my answer.
[snapback]55849[/snapback]**
Well, I'd hope they did it for the same reason I did it; as a joke.
And man, what's with this "ditch a straw hat" talk as of late?!