I think that the idea that Garp "cornered" Gol D Roger may be the same way he is "cornering" Luffy now. Maybe GD is family or a friend, and the report to Marine HQ is "I had him cornered, but he got away." Really he was talking with him like with Luffy. I doubt he will turn Luffy in, but the report will be that he found him and Luffy escaped (IE, "cornered').
Luffy's family tree? (431 spoilers!)
-
-
don't know why many think garp captured roger they just said that he cornered him. hina cornered the strawhats that time in alabasta does that mean she cought them?
-
The only word Luffy has used to refer to this 'grandpa' of his is 'jii-chan,' at least I can't remember another word. While it can mean a family relation, it could just as well mean that Garp took Luffy in as a kid and gave him shelter. Sort of an affectionate way to say 'old man' …
IMO, assuming Garp is Luffy's grandfather is jumping the gun. Next chapter will give more hints, I hope.
-
The only word Luffy has used to refer to this 'grandpa' of his is 'jii-chan,' at least I can't remember another word. While it can mean a family relation, it could just as well mean that Garp took Luffy in as a kid and gave him shelter. Sort of an affectionate way to say 'old man' …
IMO, assuming Garp is Luffy's grandfather is jumping the gun. Next chapter will give more hints, I hope.
I don't see how.
-
Well I think that luffy is related to Gold Roger he jstu doesnt know it.. Mabye because of everytime he was mentioned it was Gold instead of Gol D. Roger… And mabye he wasnt talked of in fear of the family being destroyed or something like that...
-
Maybe Garp IS Roger!*
*No, I don't ACTUALLY think that.
-
I don't think the situration is as complex as everyone is trying to make it out to be or wants it to be…
-
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!! The trans doesn't say Garp caught Roger, it says he "cornered" him several times back in the day! Just like, in the future, if Aokiji is still around, people will say he cornered Luffy back in the day!
And people… couldn't it be posible that Roger is Luffy's UNCLE??? -
what if gol d roger was still alive?
i've always thought the execution was a sham, i mean why kill the greatest pirate ever?
maybe they enlisted him into the navy? maybe they gave him a suit that looked like a dog and fabricated a story?
anyways ANYTHING IS POSSIBLE.
so maybe luffy is gol d rogers son.
just wait and find out.
-
The pirate king faking his execution and joining the Marines? Wow that is one of the funniest theories ive ever heard…
-
I agree with Monkey Spirit for the "why must Garp be related to Roger" part ._. Dissapointed that Roger's not Luffy grandpa? Seriously… that would just... suck. It's just too cliché.P
Im so glad people are saying this! I was so relieved that Roger wsn't Luffy's grandpa. I mean I kept thinking about how could Luffy possibly NOT know that Roger, his hero, was his grandfather. I was dissapointd to even think about the possibility of him being his grandfather.
also I wanna jump on the "Cornered not caught" bandwagon ^_^
-
I think it's actually far more interesting and dynamic for Luffy's grandfather to be a high-profile Naval officer, IMHO.