This is ridiculous.
I'm saying to you that we already had this discussion.
I already wrote why to me Carrot being in the crow nest means nothing. Go to pp. 1134 ff. if you don't believe me and look at my posts. And look also at Galaxy posts while you're at it. And I'm 100% sure that before that the point was already been discussed more than once.This Carrot is a lookout thing hasn't been handled like the other SH roles in the crew have been. Look at Jinbe in the same arc.
There hasn't been any storyline or big moment or chapter or even just half a chapter dedicated only to it, and the panels you keep posting are far from those things.
It's not something she's been shown excelling at any more than any of the other characters that in the past holded a pair of binoculars or shouted that there's an enemy somewhere or stayed in the crow's nest.
She is a mink that jumps high and it is unexceptional to put her in the crow's nest when Usopp is in Wano.
Other characters have had this supposed lookout role in the same arc.These are our points. It's fine to disagree, but acting like pages of discussion never happened and claiming that nobody was ever able to explain your stuff and that all the arguments against it were just that lookout is an irrelevant position it's just bad.
BTW I'm not pointing out these things again because I think you are able to hold a discussion, and I already explained in my previous post why I don't think there's any reason to continue this, I'm just doing this because you called me a liar and after this I'm out of this mess.
The willful ignorance people have regarding Carrot and her positioning is so strange to me. I'm not saying you're ignorant, but why are you (and others) conveniently overlooking how many times Oda has placed her in that position? Those things are not mistakes. He's meticulous about details. You know that. It's just like how her first few panels showed her scouting abilities when, from a story perspective, it wasn't even needed. Ever since she asked for a job on the ship, she's been doing it. It's not about what people think is a valuable position or how well she's done it at this point.
She asked for the role and she's doing it. The fact that Oda has her sticking to it despite all that's happened is not a coincidence. If she's just a useless side character, why has he consistently shown her doing the same job? Why not just have her on deck with the rest of the SHs like every other person who's ever sailed with the SHs? Brook or Chopper being randomly placed up there with her doesn't change the fact that she's still been there.
Like I said, almost no one was the best at their role when they first joined, but I can fully see her asking to stay on in that role (after Wano) and growing into it. When it gets to the point where seeing anyone else in a role gets weird (like seeing anyone else in the crow's nest at this point), then it starts to mean something.