@•Ace•:
You didn't even try to counter any of my points. We're you not paying attention? Read back to the part when the Toy Soldier and Rebecca see each other. The toys were most likely human to begin with.
If you go back to the part where Law is talking about SAD on the way to Dressrosa, he states CC applied the "lineage factors" that Vegapunk discovered to create SAD. By "lineage factors", Im guessing that means DNA.
If they toys were human:
Option A - Everyone knows they were once human
Impossible since everyone in Dressrosa likes the toys. Would you like one knowing they were once humans?
Option B.1 - Nobody knows they were once human
To each toy (and there are a TON of toys) there must be a person. I think a buttload of people missing to become toys would be noticed.
Option B.2
If they were not from Dressrosa they wouldn't have their previous memory of being human (otherwise why would they be full of joy and playful?), so how does someone know they were human?
Option C - They were transformed because of SAD radiation
Why them and not everyone else who was in touch with it? You know, like CC or any of his underlings? CC never used any protection.
Also OP is not illogical. Radiation could never transform you in a toy.
This part you're saying I didn't pay attention was already discussed here and, to return in your words, pay attention to Rebbeca laughting at the kid playing with a toy (can't find it yet but she's in the coliseum, it narrows down to just a few chapters). Here:
[hide][/hide]
Would someone who knows that toy was human be having fun with it playing with a kid? And you said I didn't counter what you said before so I'll quote myself:
"Just think a bit people, the toys are loved by everyone. Would you love them if your dad had been turned into one?"
So yeah, your theory belongs in the dumb theory thread.