Was this not an implication that one "super hero" is enough?
No. You said you would like to see a superhero archetype in the crew. My response was that "one does exist", not "we already have one, what's the point of more?"
I don't see why a suppaman character couldn't join the crew.
And neither do I
Was this not an implication that one "super hero" is enough?
It seems to me like this thread has become a parody of itself. Not sure if that makes it more sad or interesting.
We seriously discussing Suppaman in a One Piece manga? Wow you guys constantly intrigue me.
The only other super hero/super hero wanna be in the story(Daz Bones) will forever be at Crocodiles side.
I'm hoping for a "Blind Monk" archetype. Someone who is physically blind, but also has extremely good CoO Haki that lets him/her fight very well against enemies regardless.
No real reason as to why, I just think it'd be interesting since with CoO Haki Oda made this trope more than just "Is so good at fighting that they don't need to see" and actually provided an in-universe method as to how it would work.
ok since we are just throwing any characters here….ill say that i want a human viking-themed non fruit user that was raised in elbaf.
I hope "the man with the eye-patch" joins the crew.
CURRENT PH characters
Kinemon - As awesome as this BAMF is… Nope I don't think
Momonosuke - We need to see more of him but I doubt a child will join the crew... But I still find it fishy that he went all alone on this ship, we only have seen a shadow of his appeareance and his strange DoFla/Pirate reaction
I can see this 2 being more of a plot device for Wano
Monet - Well she is a hot chick... but on top on that I lov her abilities. But seeing how she is potrayed... Nope any chance. Even if she still has some misteries around her
 [RPG Time is now fully colored. Check it out!!
Thanx for everyone's support](http://forums.arlongpark.net/showthread.php?t=37915&p=2813930#top)
@Kishido: Yeah. Monet intrigued me when she was first introduced, but recent chapters showed she's a no go. I don't think we'll have anyone from PH as a new nakama. But if i'm forced between a room full of Okamas and choosing a new nakama, I'll have to choose…................SMILEY!!!
What would Smiley's role on the ship be?
LA LA LAAAAAA. LA LA LA LA!(-Dearly Beloved)
What would Smiley's role on the ship be?
It would be the strwahat`s weapon of mass destruction/ lovely axolotl to play with
Edit: Now that we are throwing in random people for the heck of it. Ill go with Brownbeard. His role, Strawhats crocbus…There is a certain level of badassery in entering a stage over a croctaured wheeled pirate . Btw, I would love to have a croctaur byke version as my avatar
@Kishido: Yeah. Monet intrigued me when she was first introduced, but recent chapters showed she's a no go. I don't think we'll have anyone from PH as a new nakama. But if i'm forced between a room full of Okamas and choosing a new nakama, I'll have to choose…................SMILEY!!!
Smiley is dead =(
To Monet… I agree with you. She is potrayed as evil as fuck and a No Go... Only thing what still makes me curious about her story is... Why did she let herself change into a harpy like creature (I know she wants to fly and such) but still it is a bit strange. Has nothing to do with her nakama potential just with my own desire to get knowledge why she let Law change herself and why she had no problem with getting her heart out for CC
Smiley is dead =(
To Monet… I agree with you. She is potrayed as evil as fuck and a No Go... Only thing what still makes me curious about her story is... Why did she let herself change into a harpy like creature (I know she wants to fly and such) but still it is a bit strange. Has nothing to do with her nakama potential just with my own desire to get knowledge why she let Law change herself and why she had no problem with getting her heart out for CC
IT'S STILL not dead is in the fruit maybe it can be eaten by Ussop kabuto and thus the strawhats oficial(by the strawhats standards) pet
Why do you guys hate the idea of the SH have more swordsmen? So far, none of the, have a regular sword style. And the series will last for 15 more years. More people should join, but they dont have to be as important as the main characters( such as shanks crew). You want luffy to fight the world with only 10 people? Pfft- hell no. The pirate king that has only 10 crew mate, in which only two can use swords!
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
Why do you guys hate Monet so much? ( besides the whole giving kids crystal meth thing). Shes a good candidate because she was the only one who could'fe given Chopper the drug formula. I dont care if she joins or not, but this is a MAJOR factor. ( "cough" and the whole planetary theorm thing " cough"
Fighting the world with only ten people is so much cooler, though.
Don't see why you'd want more people to join, but… not be important. Beyond just "need a bigger crew, with lots of people" for later, but they've got friends and stuff for that sort of thing, not to mention that doesn't really have much barring on talk of the next crew member anyway.
@Money:
Why do you guys hate Monet so much? ( besides the whole giving kids crystal meth thing). Shes a good candidate because she was the only one who could'fe given Chopper the drug formula. I dont care if she joins or not, but this is a MAJOR factor. ( "cough" and the whole planetary theorm thing " cough"
Oh dear me. Maybe she just wants to meet with GOD ENEL someday hence she asked Law to give her wings so she could feel more angel-like while traversing the universe:ninja:
Now seriously, She might just want to have a means to escape flying if things go wrong. But make no mistake so far she´s rotten to the core.
Yes shes evil, for a fact
@Kishido: Yeah. Monet intrigued me when she was first introduced, but recent chapters showed she's a no go. I don't think we'll have anyone from PH as a new nakama. But if i'm forced between a room full of Okamas and choosing a new nakama, I'll have to choose…................SMILEY!!!
bro, there's tashigi.
and smoker will follow in the future after joining the revolutionaries. LOL.
In all seriousness, I truly believe Bonny will join. I know my post may be simply reiterating what posters have said in the past, but I have to state the obvious reasons.
LA LA LAAAAAA. LA LA LA LA!(-Dearly Beloved)
Poe's law is throwing me for a loop here.
Are people serious about Monet and Bonney? Really?
In all seriousness, I truly believe Bonny will join. I know my post may be simply reiterating what posters have said in the past, but I have to state the obvious reasons.
- She's without a crew.
- She's a SN so she's New World material.
- She's a woman. (and by observing how the latest chapters has lit a fuse within the forums) I say a strong(er), capable, self assured woman is definitely needed! Not only in the crew, but in the series in general.
- Furthermore, she doesn't resemble the other woman currently on the crew.
1. i agree with you there but im thinking of her being allied with one of other pirate groups (and allied with the strawhats, because its most likely strawhats will save her)
2. zoro and luffy are already supernovas.
3. her fighting abilities are not yet known and i agree with people here that her abilities are hax, robin's hax abilities are enough imo.
4. she is like the combination of luffy and nami.
on a personal note, i prefer someone like tashigi (not to mention that she got an specific dream which sounds really fishy and she got the will to improve),..polite, modest and clumsy….clear contrast to nami, bossy, bitchy, hyterical and loud and robin, which is morbid and calm.
Poe's law is throwing me for a loop here.
Are people serious about Monet and Bonney? Really?
I've seen support for Hody, VDD, even Perona. In comparison, Monet n Bonney doesn't seem that bad
@1PceXperience: You're free to believe what u want, but until Bonney reappears, its just a pointless discussion
I'm hoping for a "Blind Monk" archetype. Someone who is physically blind, but also has extremely good CoO Haki that lets him/her fight very well against enemies regardless.
No real reason as to why, I just think it'd be interesting since with CoO Haki Oda made this trope more than just "Is so good at fighting that they don't need to see" and actually provided an in-universe method as to how it would work.
That's my idea! Get out of my head!!
<3
<3
3DS Friend Code: 2466 - 2906 - 8327 | FS: (Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong)
PS4 Gamertag: GeoLigar
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
In all seriousness, I truly believe Bonny will join. I know my post may be simply reiterating what posters have said in the past, but I have to state the obvious reasons.
- She's without a crew.
- She's a SN so she's New World material.
- She's a woman. (and by observing how the latest chapters has lit a fuse within the forums) I say a strong(er), capable, self assured woman is definitely needed! Not only in the crew, but in the series in general.
- Furthermore, she doesn't resemble the other woman currently on the crew.
No, she simply won't. Like no way. It's pretty much impossible. Forget it.
–- Update From New Post Merge ---
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
!
Edit: For some reason my picture of Sanji was deleted.
if tashigi travels with the strawhats after this arc (ill say likely) and her dream would be revealed in detail….then she's a great candidate to be the next nakama imo.
***if smoker's pose before he and tashigi part ways chapters ago was a foreshadowing, i think we will not see smoker for a long time, like being presumed dead or something.
--- Update From New Post Merge ---
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
like i said earlier:
ok since we are just throwing any characters here….ill say that i want a human viking-themed non fruit user that was raised in elbaf.
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
refer to my avatar on the left.
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
Guess you forgot about Sanji.
Guess you forgot about Sanji.
people are so focused in having new things that only exist in they're heads that they don't think anymore…
on the last couple of pages we see ideas without 1 single prof of existing or that it would be good for the team, some people who standed by Vivi, Jinbe, Tashigi, Monet, Smoker, Kinemon or Momonosuke despite having they're theories and arguments where criticized but now you can say that you want Goku and that's fine, I just don't understand some people here -.-"
The next cremates physique should either be rotund or very short. Most of the crew are either tall, muscular, and/or thin. Every straw hat has an idealized body type with twenty packs, which luffy showcases every chance he gets. Even brook is incredibly ripped!
These kind of body types:
Guess you forgot about Sanji.
Sanji isn't really represented as pure brute strength. He's all about speed and finesse (which is been coined upon many times since his body can't really take much of a beating or exert an exceeding amount of force.) It contrasts with Luffy and Zoro since they're about unpredictability and force, and endurance and discipline respectively.
<3<3
3DS Friend Code: 2466 - 2906 - 8327 | FS: (Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong)
PS4 Gamertag: GeoLigar
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
Yeah, this guy fits your description, although we do not know whether his bulking was Seimei Kikan or a DF.
!
Sanji isn't really represented as pure brute strength. He's all about speed and finesse (which is been coined upon many times since his body can't really take much of a beating or exert an exceeding amount of force.) It contrasts with Luffy and Zoro since they're about unpredictability and force, and endurance and discipline respectively.
Sanji easily kicked a giant bananagator, broke a stone wall, kicked Mohmoo, deflected an attack from Oars and launched a giant metal chain around him.
And Sanji's body can take almost as much of a beating as Zoro, since he and Zoro were the only Straw Hats who were conscious after Kuma's Ursus Shock.
The next cremates physique should either be round or very short.
Jinbei fits the bill for round. Maybe not short… but definitely round.
@SomebodyUDon'tKnow:
I think that they need someone on the crew with vrute strength alone. No devil fruit, no weapon just pure freaking strength. It'd be an ineresting turn around.
The next cremates physique should either be rotund or very short.
These kind of body types:http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_vv2IGE5obwk/TU24RuPyy1I/AAAAAAAAG6E/sq5Gw53cD3g/s1600/Sumo-Wresting-Cheating-Scandal.jpghttp://www.manofactionfigures.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/product_full/sites/default/files/blob.jpg
You mean, Jinbe…right?
Sanji easily kicked a giant bananagator, broke a stone wall, kicked Mohmoo, deflected an attack from Oars and launched a giant metal chain around him.
And Sanji's body can take almost as much of a beating as Zoro, since he and Zoro were the only Straw Hats who were conscious after Kuma's Ursus Shock.
Not to start a debate (since in a way we're both right) but all his feats are leg strength. His legs are his main source of power, but even those have their limit since on numerous occasions they've come close to getting broken. Sanji does have superhuman strength, but most of his attacks require/display speed, velocity and torque. Speed = Mass. When it comes to brute strength, I think Chopper's Heavy Point is a good example of what SomebodyUDon'tKnow was getting at. Muscle, grappling and raw power.
<3<3
3DS Friend Code: 2466 - 2906 - 8327 | FS: (Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong)
PS4 Gamertag: GeoLigar
Not to start a debate (since in a way we're both right) but all his feats are leg strength. His legs are his main source of power, but even those have their limit since on numerous occasions they've come close to getting broken. Sanji does have superhuman strength, but most of his attacks require/display speed, velocity and torque. Speed = Mass. When it comes to brute strength, I think Chopper's Heavy Point is a good example of what SomebodyUDon'tKnow was getting at. Muscle, grappling and raw power.
Oh, I see what you mean. You're referring more to upper body strength, right?
people are so focused in having new things that only exist in they're heads that they don't think anymore… on the last couple of pages we see ideas without 1 single prof of existing or that it would be good for the team, some people who standed by Vivi, Jinbe, Tashigi, Monet, Smoker, Kinemon or Momonosuke despite having they're theories and arguments where criticized but now you can say that you want Goku and that's fine, I just don't understand some people here -.-"
Exactly, Monet ( mabye ), Kinnemon, Momo n Bonney are all really good canidates. You could debate about Bonney, but you guys are too picky. You dont want a regular swordsman, a child, a person who actually kills people ( Monet ) , a muscular fishman, or a glutton that can eff around with peoples ages. But you do want every female character after one appearance , a vice admiril n comander who've been around for +300 chapters, a female SWORDSMAN, and even more. You guys sure are picky :/ .
@Money:
Exactly, Monet ( mabye ), Kinnemon, Momo n Bonney are all really good canidates.
Kinemon, kinda. Momo and Bonney…..meh. Monet, not at all.
You dont want a regular swordsman, a child, a person who actually kills people ( Monet )
Again, since when is this a desired trait to have? Just because we're lacking in on-screen deaths doesn't mean we need amoral psychopaths to start raising the quota.
But you do want every female character after one appearance
Wasn't this Monet's calling card at the beginning of this arc? I'm almost positive we had some "MONET 4 NAKAMA" supporters during her first few scenes. Back when, y'know, she was "just a female character".
I supported Monet because she likely gave Chopper the note
Oh, I see what you mean. You're referring more to upper body strength, right?
More or less. When I hear brute strength I think about the Hulk. No fighting style, just raw muscle and physical domination.
<3<3
3DS Friend Code: 2466 - 2906 - 8327 | FS: (Delibird, Bergmite, Dewgong)
PS4 Gamertag: GeoLigar
@Money:
I supported Monet because she likely gave Chopper the note
Except most people think that was Law. Especially given everything we know now.
Even if she did, I don't understand how that would vault her into crewmate contention. Countless characters have done more than that without a whiff of having a chance to join up. Hell, even the ridiculous option that is the three eyed girl from Big Mom's crew seems to have a better chance at this point. In the same way that I have a better chance at winning the lottery if I buy two tickets instead of one.
I fully undestand Monet is not joining, but I get pissed when people strike down other peoples opinion, but then suggest Smoker n Tashigi. I know i just did that, but Im too lazy to fully explain right now.
You just openly admitted to doing the very thing that pisses you off. Amazing.
With Jinbei joining the crew has enough brute force on their side as it is.
**Here's a Breakdown of Everyone
Brutes: Luffy, Jinbei, Sanji, Franky, Zoro
Utilizations: (e.g. tramboline, invisibility, cloning) Nami, Ussop, Robin
Multipurpose: (e.g. sleep induction, digging, giantification) Brook, Chopper**
The new member needs to have either a "utilization" or multipurpose ability.
Possibilities include:
LA LA LAAAAAA. LA LA LA LA!(-Dearly Beloved)
Hey, while were on the characters who have done a lot for the SH.
It's too bad Mr. 2 Bon Clay is still locked up in Impel Down after 2 years. I was always a big fan of him joining up for nakama.
You just openly admitted to doing the very thing that pisses you off. Amazing.
Thank you. But I also said Ill explain more about it later
Hey, while were on the characters who have done a lot for the SH.
It's too bad Mr. 2 Bon Clay is still locked up in Impel Down after 2 years. I was always a big fan of him joining up for nakama.
Well the good news is he's no longer locked up in Impel Down. You may have missed it, but in the cover story it should that Bon Clay is now on Okama Isle
LA LA LAAAAAA. LA LA LA LA!(-Dearly Beloved)
NewKama not Kama Island
I want to believe too big guy3ds code friend:0404-6254-1866
