Closed Thread
Page 629 of 1301 FirstFirst ... 129 529 579 619 627 628 629 630 631 639 679 729 1129 ... LastLast
Results 12,561 to 12,580 of 26007

Thread: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

  1. #12561

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Okay, I wanna throw my input into this. I'm also just gonna say beforehand that I read none of the previous 600 pages so I have no clue if there's already a topic being discussed lol... Anyway.

    Spoilers

    Jimbei: Ever since Jimbei said that he couldn't join Luffy because he had 'stuff' to do or something, I just feel like he's going to die somehow.

    Bartolomeo: No. for two reasons. 1) We don't need a LuffyxBartolomeo ship. 2) In the newest chapter he was seen in a big picture with all the other captains/contestants of the tournament. If he was truly Straw Hat material he would have had his own panels and a much more important/personal role. He's also a Captain already and looks up to Luffy only.

    Sabo: I'm not against this one, its just I can't see him leaving the revolutionary army to join the crew. Team up? Sure, they can even travel together for a little bit. But not a crewmate

    Kin'emon: Nah, just because we already have 2 swordsman and we don't need more members with fire attacks lol

    Aokiji:
    I would love to have Aokiji join the crew. But it would need to happen a little later when Luffy and Zoro get strong enough to fight on a perfectly even playing field with admirals.

    I think I got everyone lol

  2. #12562

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    I used to think 2 swordsman were enough but Kyros this arc has me thinking otherwise. As long as it isn't another samurai (ie. Zoro) or fencer (ie. Brook). Not that Kyros is joining since he's staying on Dressrosa, but something like a knight could make an addition to the crew while keeping all 3 swordsman distinctive.

    Aokiji is too strong. He fought nearly on par with the now current Navy Fleet Admiral. If we have any new members join, its going to be near the start of the New World and not halfway through or later. Luffy and Zoro won't be on equal footing with him for quite a while.

  3. #12563
    Cyclops was right! GetsugaZoro's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Portugal

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by Kinger556 View Post
    Okay, I wanna throw my input into this. I'm also just gonna say beforehand that I read none of the previous 600 pages so I have no clue if there's already a topic being discussed lol... Anyway.

    Spoilers

    Jimbei: Ever since Jimbei said that he couldn't join Luffy because he had 'stuff' to do or something, I just feel like he's going to die somehow.
    Jinbe said he had to do something and when that was done if Luffy still wanted him to join he would, that something has most likelly to do with making sure the other Fishman that were part of his crew(that don't want to be pirates) are safe, so it will be Big Mom related and will tie in with the SHs story yet again at some point, Oda even put the damn kid in 3 covers with the 10 on his shirt, he could have put freaking 38 there if its just a random number its a big coincidence thats its a 10(which would be Jinbe number on the crew).

    No need to put spoilers in your post this is the manga section we are all caught up with the story.

    Quote Originally Posted by fapfapfap View Post
    I used to think 2 swordsman were enough but Kyros this arc has me thinking otherwise. As long as it isn't another samurai (ie. Zoro) or fencer (ie. Brook). Not that Kyros is joining since he's staying on Dressrosa, but something like a knight could make an addition to the crew while keeping all 3 swordsman distinctive.

    Aokiji is too strong. He fought nearly on par with the now current Navy Fleet Admiral. If we have any new members join, its going to be near the start of the New World and not halfway through or later. Luffy and Zoro won't be on equal footing with him for quite a while.
    Yeah aslong as the fighting style is diferent I'm fine with other sword users, even though I would love to see someone with a mace or an axe as a weapon join the crew, those are weapons that I usually like to use in games.

    Pokemon X/Y ingame name: Pedro
    3DS FC : 1547 5213 7769 - NNID : SunGodKizaru Switch: SW-7487-5553-2501

  4. #12564
    Discovered Stowaway HacheBe's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2015
    Location
    on your screen

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by Kinger556 View Post
    Jimbei: Ever since Jimbei said that he couldn't join Luffy because he had 'stuff' to do or something, I just feel like he's going to die somehow.
    I think that since he is coming off of this cover story he is going to get wrapped up in the storyline pretty soon. Maybe next arc. While i think there is a possibility he could die i don't see anyone that Luffy cares about dying anytime soon. At least till later in the series. Maybe before a second timeskip.

  5. #12565
    Cyclops was right! GetsugaZoro's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Portugal

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Oda killed two characters, one that provoked a change on Luffy and one that provoked a change on the entire world, he doesn't kill named character just for the sake of it, he wants it to be meaningful, Luffy already lost his brother, I dont see any need to make him lose a friend now, it would be impactful on him but it was already done and in a much harsher way(since it was his brother).

    Pokemon X/Y ingame name: Pedro
    3DS FC : 1547 5213 7769 - NNID : SunGodKizaru Switch: SW-7487-5553-2501

  6. #12566

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by GetsugaZoro View Post
    Oda killed two characters, one that provoked a change on Luffy and one that provoked a change on the entire world, he doesn't kill named character just for the sake of it, he wants it to be meaningful, Luffy already lost his brother, I dont see any need to make him lose a friend now, it would be impactful on him but it was already done and in a much harsher way(since it was his brother).
    Your right. Like completely right. But almost every time I hear someones explanations or expectations for where One Piece may make it almost always goes in the opposite direction. For instance Jinbeis death might not be character development for Luffy, but someone else? I feel like Oda likes making odd left turns and as much as I would be upset about Jinbeis death, the way him an Luffy left things off just gave me an itch that he'd die. Though I could be completely wrong lol

  7. #12567

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by Kinger556 View Post
    Okay, I wanna throw my input into this. I'm also just gonna say beforehand that I read none of the previous 600 pages so I have no clue if there's already a topic being discussed lol... Anyway.

    Spoilers

    Jimbei: Ever since Jimbei said that he couldn't join Luffy because he had 'stuff' to do or something, I just feel like he's going to die somehow.

    Bartolomeo: No. for two reasons. 1) We don't need a LuffyxBartolomeo ship. 2) In the newest chapter he was seen in a big picture with all the other captains/contestants of the tournament. If he was truly Straw Hat material he would have had his own panels and a much more important/personal role. He's also a Captain already and looks up to Luffy only.

    Sabo: I'm not against this one, its just I can't see him leaving the revolutionary army to join the crew. Team up? Sure, they can even travel together for a little bit. But not a crewmate

    Kin'emon: Nah, just because we already have 2 swordsman and we don't need more members with fire attacks lol

    Aokiji:
    I would love to have Aokiji join the crew. But it would need to happen a little later when Luffy and Zoro get strong enough to fight on a perfectly even playing field with admirals.

    I think I got everyone lol
    No you didn't get everyone.
    Bellamy's an infinitely more likely candidate than Bartolomeo ans you didn't even put him.
    (And Bellamy doesn't even have a real chance)

  8. #12568

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Bellamy just needs to be happy and away from Doflamingo.

  9. #12569

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by Kinger556 View Post
    Okay, I wanna throw my input into this. I'm also just gonna say beforehand that I read none of the previous 600 pages so I have no clue if there's already a topic being discussed lol... Anyway.

    Spoilers

    Jimbei: Ever since Jimbei said that he couldn't join Luffy because he had 'stuff' to do or something, I just feel like he's going to die somehow.

    Bartolomeo: No. for two reasons. 1) We don't need a LuffyxBartolomeo ship. 2) In the newest chapter he was seen in a big picture with all the other captains/contestants of the tournament. If he was truly Straw Hat material he would have had his own panels and a much more important/personal role. He's also a Captain already and looks up to Luffy only.

    Sabo: I'm not against this one, its just I can't see him leaving the revolutionary army to join the crew. Team up? Sure, they can even travel together for a little bit. But not a crewmate

    Kin'emon: Nah, just because we already have 2 swordsman and we don't need more members with fire attacks lol

    Aokiji:
    I would love to have Aokiji join the crew. But it would need to happen a little later when Luffy and Zoro get strong enough to fight on a perfectly even playing field with admirals.

    I think I got everyone lol
    You may have forgotten one or two ;)

  10. #12570

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    I knew I was forgetting someone. As for Bellamy, the only reason I think he wouldn't join the crew is because his powers are virtually a second Luffy lol But ever since Gear 4th and "awakened" devil fruit powers I guess anything can take a unique turn.

  11. #12571

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    It's hysterical how so many people like to assume Jinbe is going to die.

  12. #12572

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    true.

    i think luffy has stronger relationship with jinbe compared to, like, brook. jinbe saved his life, pulled him away from despair, gave his blood to, once again, save luffy's life, etc. plus, jinbe said that he'll protect the 'seed'/'dream' of shirahoshi/otohime/tiger regarding thr fishman-human relationship and luffy most likely will be the guide for shirahoshi like joyboy did earlier. and so on and so forth. there is simply NO WAY for jinbe to not join the crew.


  13. #12573

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by MetaMario View Post
    I'll admit, this is a first.

    But much like using the alphabet or colors to guess a crewmate....it's just twisting the coincidental variables to fit some kind of pattern. Doesn't it?
    That person's theory is already messed up by Sanji, Brook and Franky.

  14. #12574

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    regarding jinbe (if he indeed join straw hat) i think oda will split japan into two region : kanto and kansai
    zorro and jinbei then will take one region each.

    i don't know which one though

  15. #12575

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    People are forgetting that the only people who join the SH are master specialists.

    Every single member of the SH has a specific specialty that only they do, save for Zoro who is a pure combatant(but he's first mate, he doesn't need a specific job)

    Nami is navigator, Robin is a scholar/language expert etc(very useful when traveling all over the world), Chopper is a doctor, Sanji is a chef/food expert, Franky is an engineer/shipwright, Brooke is a musician, Usopp is a gunner/marksman.


    Most of the people named have no actual specialty. just because someone is strong or useful in a fight does not make them SH material.


    The only one named in this thread so far that has any real possbility is Jinbei, and not because of his strength or even his bond with luffy, but because he is a master helmsman(which is the only specialized position the SH still lack)

  16. #12576

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by ES2200 View Post
    The only one named in this thread so far that has any real possbility is Jinbei, and not because of his strength or even his bond with luffy, but because he is a master helmsman(which is the only specialized position the SH still lack)
    Jinbe is a master helsmsman ? What ? I thought you were about to say Fishman Karate master.
    By the way, we can't say which position they lack. Before Robin joined, they were not lacking a language expert at all. But they got one anyway.

  17. #12577

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Wait, since when was Robin a language expert? Last I checked she was an archaeologist.

  18. #12578

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    When escaping Impel down, it was revealed that Jinbei's ability to perfectly read the eb and flow of the ocean basically makes him the perfect helmsman.


    And yes, she's technically an archaeologist but this lends itself pretty heavily to language. you can't travel the world studying different cultures if you can't read and speak the many languages required to actually understand any of it.

    She's a scholar. she has a deep understanding of the OP world as a whole, and it's people, customs, languages etc.

  19. #12579
    7transformation duck rider Chopper Madness's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    St. Louis

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by ES2200 View Post
    People are forgetting that the only people who join the SH are master specialists.

    Every single member of the SH has a specific specialty that only they do, save for Zoro who is a pure combatant(but he's first mate, he doesn't need a specific job)

    Nami is navigator, Robin is a scholar/language expert etc(very useful when traveling all over the world), Chopper is a doctor, Sanji is a chef/food expert, Franky is an engineer/shipwright, Brooke is a musician, Usopp is a gunner/marksman.


    Most of the people named have no actual specialty. just because someone is strong or useful in a fight does not make them SH material.


    The only one named in this thread so far that has any real possibility is Jinbei, and not because of his strength or even his bond with luffy, but because he is a master helmsman(which is the only specialized position the SH still lack)
    that was a pattern earlier in the series but we are in the new world now.... we might be getting new patterns of joining

    from a story perspective all new crew members will be unique in some way that makes them interesting but how many more "positions" are thereleft on the ship to be filled?

    PS. go back and read like a couple hundred pages of this thread all of these things i just mentioned are discussed in depth. so if you are looking for new thoughts, ideas or sides to an argument its their....


    3ds friend code: 2509-2091-9671

  20. #12580

    Default Re: Next Strawhat Crewmate (Vol. 6)

    Quote Originally Posted by Chopper Madness View Post
    that was a pattern earlier in the series but we are in the new world now.... we might be getting new patterns of joining

    from a story perspective all new crew members will be unique in some way that makes them interesting but how many more "positions" are thereleft on the ship to be filled?

    PS. go back and read like a couple hundred pages of this thread all of these things i just mentioned are discussed in depth. so if you are looking for new thoughts, ideas or sides to an argument its their....

    I already said in my post, they're only really missing one last crew member: a dedicated helmsman(they take turns at it for the moment).

    Guess what Jinbei is really really good at?


    I believe luffy's Goal was a crew of 10, if I remember right. one more SH makes 10.


    there's likely not gonna be any more after the next one.

Closed Thread

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 2 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 2 guests)

     

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts