It's because some people seem to think that the DF theory would help support Yamato potentially joining if he's a tiger (i.e. cat or "neko") That doesn't really fit the "Ni" or "Kyu" (2,9) from the...
Type: Posts; User: BobLoblaw
It's because some people seem to think that the DF theory would help support Yamato potentially joining if he's a tiger (i.e. cat or "neko") That doesn't really fit the "Ni" or "Kyu" (2,9) from the...
So if Yamato turns out to not be a white tiger, are people going to start doubting his NN potential (even though, again, the 2,9 theory doesn't apply to a tiger anyway)?
From what I've read, the DF theory is 2,9. That would be Ni not Ne, which would be tiger-related.
This thread sure has gotten spicy. Some people are probably going to be devastated about their NN pick after the end of this arc.
carrot sure is a hot topic these days. :)
I guess I'm just missing the significance. Luffy tells him to help Shinobu protect Momo. Even if he didn't, I have a hard time believing Yamato would sit idly by and watch Momo get attacked. That...
Didn't Yamato say that it was only natural for him to look after Momo since he was his son? I do think he seemed skeptical when saying that, but given that Momo is the son of his idol, he didn't need...
It's hard to understand why people are assuming that someone with no leadership experience (or experience at all outside of Onigashima) would somehow usurp the leadership hierarchy of the SH crew....
Agreed. Just the SH crew please, NN or not.
This is how I feel and you've stated it perfectly. Granted, Carrot had no foreshadowing at all either unless you consider "minks" at the auction house as anything of significance. Bepo was there, but...
There is no debate about the fact that literal months elapsed. The point is the significance. Think back to some other build ups. Like Jack being referenced after PH, for instance. Or Pudding between...
8 chapters is less than a volume. Are we really going with "months of build up" as a metric when something gets revealed within the span of one volume?
It is pretty contradictory. I guess it goes back to the fact that Oda likely gender-swapped the character at the last minute after reading The Rose of Versailles. So either Oda didn't remember to...
Why would we assume that Carrot losing to Perospero somehow makes her chances of joining zero? You'd have a point if every Carrot supporter said "Carrot can only join if she beats Perospero right...
I still see Carrot's potential as a net positive after the last chapter. It was already highly questionable about whether or not she could defeat a $700 million pirate and now we have our answer. The...
Oda has shown with Jinbe that he's treating NN differently in the New World, so I'm not going to assume that someone missing for 10 chapters automatically gets disqualified. This isn't Carrot's arc....
It's not just you. After Whole Cake, the vast majority of people on this board (and others) assumed that she was the best candidate we'd had in the NW. Then Oda introduces Yamato out of nowhere, ties...
While I don't believe we should make things personal, I can get behind this sentiment. Be constructive, debate in good faith, or f off into the sunset.
This would severely cheapen the experience and make their search and sacrifices for the road poneglyphs pointless. The closest thing to a shortcut the SHs will get was the road poneglygh on Zou and...
I've joked that he's a red herring that Oda conveniently gave red horns. :) There's still plenty of time for Oda to expand on the character, but everything so far has been extremely convenient. Oda...
Nope. No meta-clues. Everything is a retcon so far. If someone said that Kaido had a son like 25 chapters ago, everyone would've laughed at them. That's just how out of left field it was.
This was my previous argument. I refuse to believe that Luffy will let a new SH on his ship that pretends to be someone else and wants to follow someone else's dream. Either Yamato embraces who...
I read Oden's journal. It influenced my life so much, that I dress like Oden. I speak as if I'm Oden. In fact, I am Oden. Oden's son is my son. Oden's goals are my goals. Oden's gender is my...
Can you kindly point me to chapters where Luffy went around claiming to be Shanks? Or what about chapters where Luffy dresses like Shanks. There's a difference between someone inspiring you and you...
Only fanboys roleplay. Sorry. :)
Modeling your whole life around someone else, claiming to be them, and claiming that their son is your son sounds pretty fanboyish to me. If you think being a fanboy simply means being starry-eyed...
If Yamato isn't an Oden fanboy, then Bart isn't a Luffy fanboy. And he said Momo was his son. Clearly, that's a normal thing that anyone would say, right?
People seem to have forgotten that Bart made it to number 9. He was a fanboy also. :ninja:
You're asking me about things that haven't been addressed directly or indirectly about her wanting to be the best look outlook, what else there is for her to learn, or if she's a great lookout. None...
You're asking questions that I'd have no way of knowing. If you want me to pull something out of my ass then
1) No, just like most members of the crew aren't aiming to be the best at anything.
2)...