Search:

Type: Posts; User: ChocolateBar999

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Search: Search took 0.10 seconds.

  1. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    How are any of those examples exceptions when they're popular? Do you just live to look stupid all the time?

    --- Update From New Post Merge ---


    Kochikame, City Hunter and Video Girl Ai didn't...
  2. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    You're literally saying that Twilight is good now. The extent you people would go I swear.
  3. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    And I'm still waiting on you to prove how manga sales and ToC rankings aren't correlated but you've failed to do so.
  4. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    You still have not made an argument.



    That ain't contradiction either. Now please actually make a rebuttal
  5. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So this is going to be the default answer to when a chapter ranks high on the ToC from now on I see.
  6. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    What does RxL have to do with the fact that four of the 5 participants in the Campaign are in the top 5? Its yet another exception to the many in the ToC
  7. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    WSJ TOC 19
    Haikyuu (Cover)
    Promised Neverland
    Black Clover
    Yuragi-sō no Yūna-san (Color Pages)
    Kimetsu no Yaiba
    Dr Stone
    Inishie no Horobimon (Color Pages)
    We Can't Sudy
    ZIGA
  8. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So Every chapter of One Piece is the best in every issue of Jump is what you're sayng


    Good job putting words in my mouth also good job not exactly proving anything.
  9. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Do you like making a fool out of yourself as much as novice here Kaizou 10 does?




    So its just a coincidence that Naruto, AssClass, Slam Dunk, YYH, Dragonball, Hikaru no...
  10. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    You can just check the listing of olf ToC to see that they were in the top spots as well as having top sales so why is now the exception?


    Its like you have literally nothing to say


    So why...
  11. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So Naruto, AssClass, Slam Dunk, YYH, Dragonball, Hikaru no Go, Hokuto no Ken, Kinnikuman, Saint Seiya, all did not have good ratings is what you're saying now?


    Before the first volume is even...
  12. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Wow! You sure showed me with that well-written argument.
  13. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    And yet Kimetsu dropped and sales last volume. Thanks for proving that the ToC only means something to fit your own narrative. I guess those universally reviled chapters of BC than ranked 1st for two...
  14. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So why isn't the same applied to MHA and Haikyuu?


    How the hell do they have nothing to do with each other?
  15. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So OP is literally the only damn exception to this rule and the correlation to everything else is just coincidence and clearly not editor manipulation.
  16. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So every series gets an anime boost is what you're saying now.



    So the metric is flawed in itself because it doesn't account for anything other than what the editor placed.


    So how is it...
  17. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    15% from the previous arc though the Hideout Raid coincided with the series second boost in sales. Bleach fans had the exact same mentality and the series sales didn't improve as its ranks fell. In...
  18. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Your assumption is based on a ignorant notion that you need to be a 1 million seller to be considered a top seller most manga don't even sell 500k to begin with. The amount of anime with a...
  19. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    It did move sales it bit in August of last year after that episode aired but it wasn't huge. Kingdom had a 5 minute segment on Ame Talk which had a bigger boost in sales than 2 seasons of its anime....
  20. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    I'm not sure how anyone can sit here and say Neverland wasn't shilled to hell and back same with Dr. Stone. Hell it was discovered that their were bots used on the Dr. Stone PV to inflate views for...
  21. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Of course its established. Not every series that gets an anime gets a boost in sales the fact that you can only list "the big titles" is proof enough of that (which certainly doesn't help your case...
  22. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    We already established that anime rarely do anything to push sales. Why are you bringing it up as a deciding factor when there's an example that run counter to your claim?






    ....I wasn't...
  23. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Your stance was that MHA was only selling more because it was older


    Critical has never been a contributing factor in sales unfortunately.



    So its just a coincidence that One Piece is the...
  24. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    It did. On the same episode they promoted Dr. Stone before its first volume was released.


    That is not true in the slightest. Dr. Stone had a damn PV as well as a AmeTalk promotion segment before...
  25. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    So what does that say about Neverland which managed to outsell both BC and Souma despite premiering after? By your logic it should not be selling more than either of them.
  26. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    You're right it just had two author recommendations, an excerpt on AmeTalk and a plethora of promotion from other valets.

    --- Update From New Post Merge ---


    Dr. Stone and Neverland had bigger...
  27. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Not according to sales.
  28. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    Its a misprint. Its his twin brother Seishi Kishimoto (author of 666 Satan).
    https://twitter.com/MangaMagJapon/status/928436157586616320/photo/1
  29. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    The infamous interview with Oda states that while feedback from readership is necessary what order the ToC goes in is ultimately up to the editor in chief. One Piece will always be in the top 3 for...
  30. Replies
    16,844
    Views
    6,182,605

    Sticky: Re: The "Shueisha" Thread

    It doesn't matter. The EiC is the one that ultimately makes the decision.
Results 1 to 30 of 32
Page 1 of 2 1 2